Unfortunately, it sounds as if you're making the right decision with this particular amplifier. You have however dipped your feet in the water so you know just how good it feels.
As for the MC2205 vs. the MC2105, I'll be the odd duck here. I prefer the MC2105 all day long - always have. The MC2205 is one amplifier in the McIntosh lineup that I've never been super excited with. With the MC2105, you get the pinnacle of what McIntosh was when the amplifier was introduced, the best of the best. For several years, it simply did not get any better. MC2105s were owned by celebrities, used in studios, and even at Woodstock - and for very good reason.
The MC2205 was the very first McIntosh amplifier to feature Power Guard. So what? I've owned just as many McIntosh amplifiers with Power Guard as I have without. Quite simply, Power Guard allows you to enjoy a higher average listening level when comparing to a similar powered amplifier that doesn't have it. [I never missed this with the MC2505 or MC2105.] The MC2205 has the first gen Power Guard, which I've always felt a tad over zealous. Fortunately, it does include a rear panel switch that allows you to defeat it should you choose. But that's never been my real beef with the MC2205 as it's a fine sounding amplifier indeed. My beefs are:
- The MC2205 does not have the ability to be operated in mono into an 8 Ohm load. It lacks the 16 Ohm taps required to do so on this generation of Mc amp. [Oddly enough, the smaller MC2125 includes them - never understood that.]
- The design of the MC2205 faceplate is a flawed one. Look only at the MC2205 STEREO POWER AMPLIFIER lettering under the power meters to see. In 90% of cases, some of this lettering is dull as it has been pulled away from the glass on the rear of the faceplate via the double sided tape that holds the blue plexi pieces to the rear of the glass.
- The black plastic meter bezel has never been to my liking. In many cases, when folks replace the glass (see above), they leave this off - gives the amp a more modern look. [So, this can be considered a non-issue.]
- the MC2205 is not a value proposition in the world of used McIntosh. Given what they sell for, there are many far better buys - the MC7270 being the finest example. For just a few dollars more, an MC7270 will run circles around the MC2205.
Now, just because the MC2205 isn't my favorite doesn't mean that you wouldn't enjoy the hell out of it should you get one. It's just my opinion. I've owned about the same number of MC2205s as I have MC2105s. IMHO, there's just something magical about the MC2105 that you don't get in a McIntosh amplifier until you go to the MC7270. Hard to explain really.
So, you have a contrasting opinion. Although I did elect to sell my last MC2105 a few years ago, I still do have a pair of it's larger siblings - the MC2300s - so I still do have that sound!