Before setting the counterweight to 1.5 grams did you zero out the tonearm so that it floats level with that particular headshell / cartridge and then reset the counterweight indicator to zero at that point? Even after doing that to get the proper starting point it’s still best to double check the tracking force with a digital scale to assure that it’s accurately set. I think the AT-440ml series is generally happy at 1.25 grams, it’s got a pretty compliant suspension.