Same make, size and nominal impedance does not tell the whole story. Even if the drivers were the same size, they are not necessarily the same drivers. Different sensitivity, crossover design, crossover points...tons of variables.
In any case you're basing your judgement on a single side by side test between two speakers. Sensitivity (db per watt of input) is not even consistently correlated with impedance rating amongst all speakers. For example, the mighty AR9 is a 4 ohm speaker capable of ear shattering output, but with an input sensitivity of 87 db/1W/1m. Requires massive 4-ohm capable amps. In contrast, the Klipschorn, an equally thunder-capable 8 ohm speaker, has a sensitivity of 104 db/1w/1m and is happy with a small amp. Granted these are the extremes - few home speakers go beyond these limits or even equal them. Most are in the 90s. But the point is, output and how you like the sound is related to other factors besides the impedance. Which is great for you: now you can expand your search pool.