Ancient thread, I realize, but I had a comment on live Vanguard recordings and didn't want to start a new thread.
I agree with Nick, the Village recordings and ambiance are wonderful. But I got to thinking about the talking, laughing and clinking glasses you hear constantly in the background.
I actually wondered if engineers added that to the recordings just to make it more interesting. It's a nice effect, but is that really the way New York jazz clubs are? Are NY jazz fans really THAT disrespectful? Bill wasn't exactly un-known at the time of the recordings. He had already played with Miles. So why go and pay the cover charge to see the Bill Evans Trio and talk through the performance?
So, you're at the club, witnessing an intimate live recording of a legendary artist/group and half the club is laughing out loud, having conversations, etc.
I wonder if anyone had the urge to stand up and tell everyone to shut the hell up and go to some other bar?
I grew up in the mid-west....maybe I'm just naive about social rules in the Big Apple.