I do agree with you on all counts - 1) I listen to acoustic bass and not anything electronically synthesized, nor do I listen to pipe organs, and 2) True - I have not listened to speakers that have more bass extension, but I've sure heard plenty of booming boxes that folks consider as having "great bass". However, the comments have been parroted to the point where I feel they are scaring away folks thinking these are thin with NO bass, and especially believing the bass they do produce is of poor quality. Considering the design, tradeoffs, and limitations of the enclosure, sealed box, etc. it's a fine speaker. I've gotten comments from folks (non audiophiles) who've heard these in my house and commented on the tight bass, and are surprised when I say they're noted for their lack of bass.