Cool idea for a thread Kegger. I could sure use some input form some of the veteran tubies, and it's allways good to have fresh ideas from newbies. I'm somewhere between, but a lot closer to the newbs. I am honestly just now learning how to listen to a Hi-Fi system. I know that may sound strange but it's how I see it. A good example is tonight I put up another table in the cave, and set up my old Dyna 70 and my junk shop Dorians I've been working on. I'm in the process of switching the tube shop to a speaker shop for a while.

Anyway I ran a Marantz CD50 straight in as it has variable output. Now I've been listening to my homebrew SET El34 for several days through some Heresy's. At first I honestly thought the 70/JBL rig sounded fairly lame, but after some adjusting and switching from Ralph Stanley to Jimi Hendrix, it's awesome. These two setups are totally different sounding, but both are excellent IMHO in there own niche. The 70/JBL really didn't seem to have the detail for the really complex strings, and obviously the EL34 SET will never be a rocker. As far as tube selection goes the best setups for these two rigs I have come up with is Sylvania Milspec 12AT7's and Gen III EI KT90's in the Dyna and Jan Sylvania bottom getter 6SL7's with RCA 6CA7's in the homebrew, but I'm still rolling it. Here's the sick part :yes: I'm sitting here listening to the JBL's and keep thinking that the Heresy's would fit just perfect on their marble tops, and the 70 has 4ohm taps :thmbsp: Anybody got a tape measure? :scratch2: Jay
Edit- I read your first post again and saw you asked about tube outcomes. I will share my experience, but in no way would bash any tube.
JJ EL34- Best new prod I've used.
EH EL34- Good for a tester outer
Mullard EL34- Very Lush (I guess thats the warm tube sound I hear about)
Siemans EL34- Purty Good
Svetlana EL34- Not bad
Sovtek EL34- Bright and shimmery (real good for some female voice
RCA EL34- Nothing else really comes close so far IMHO
6SL7 RCA (several different types) all very good
6SL7 Russian- :thumbsdn:
6SL7 Sylvy- Way in front of others, incredible detail on Mandolin and such