• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

anyone else running vintage Empire carts?

Hi Dave and other 2000E series owners,

The Astatics I have are aftermarket but with VG styli. I scored a Astatic packaged original Empire S2000E/II stylus on eBay, it's arrival is expected midweek, I take pictures of it and the aftermarket next to each other for comparisons of the cantilevers.

Hi rread13,

Looking forward to seeing the pics and reading your impressions of the comparison.

Happy New Year!

Dave
 
The S2000 E/II stylus is virtually identical to the S2000 E/III stylus. If you look at the specs. you will see this. They must have used just a slightly less compliant rubber in the suspension or otherwise adjusted it.

The diamond and cantilever are the same.

And, as far as the Astatic replacements, the Astatic I have for my Pickering 625E cartridge is excellent so the same may hold true for their Empire replacements.

Doug
 
Empire S2000E series Styli

Hi rread13,

Looking forward to seeing the pics and reading your impressions of the comparison.

Happy New Year!

Dave

Hi Dave, and others!

I received the stylus the other night via USPS. The Pfanstiehl *237-DEC is a Empire S2000E/I Green stylus. I did some preliminary listening last night on a vintage album: Bruce Springsteen and the E-Street Band Live 1975-1985 Album 1 side 1 & 2, Album 2 side 1 & 2. I am happy to report the suspension is still good on this one and the stylus performed near as I can tell like the higher Clear S2000E/III in sound quality. I had the tracking force set at 1.0 grams and no distortions or sibilance issues to report, just sweet, rich full bodied sound.

The Astatic brand S2000E/II has a .002 x .007 elliptical diamond and looks to have a thicker cantilever but is a quality sounding and light tracker, it worked fine in my system at 1.0 grams as the OEM ones.

The EVG (I think it's an EVG?)on the other hand is clear like the OEM and has a .003 x .007 elliptical diamond, thick cantilever also, but needed to track at a 1.50 - 1.75 initial setting for a few weeks and has since loosened up some, and now sounds much better playing most albums with out sibilance issues. I can now play the EVG one at 1.0 - 1.25 and it now is working fine at this setting.

I took some pictures to share: The Empires have the flip down guards, and the Empire Logo on them. The Astatic EM103-ed's for the S2000E/II are high quality aftermarket units with .002 x .007 diamonds in the translucent Blue. Lastly the clear one, mine came from eBay seller Carols Needles part # 237-DET is from EVG or Jico (un-sure, mine just has the jewel box and 237-DET on a Red and White label). Pictures taken with Galaxy S2 phone set on Macro mode. I hope to invest in a USB Scope in the near future to inspect stylus tips.
 

Attachments

  • 20140105_090700.jpg
    20140105_090700.jpg
    37.1 KB · Views: 87
  • 20140105_100441.jpg
    20140105_100441.jpg
    20.4 KB · Views: 62
  • 20140105_100857.jpg
    20140105_100857.jpg
    26.3 KB · Views: 56
  • 20140105_105959.jpg
    20140105_105959.jpg
    18.3 KB · Views: 57
  • 20140105_110036.jpg
    20140105_110036.jpg
    23.3 KB · Views: 61
Last edited:
Thanks for your analysis and photos, Rick.

I agree with all of your observations, particularly the identical sound from the S2000 E/I stylus and S2000 E/III. I compared them in the past and reached the same conclusion. You can't really tell the difference between the two. I imagine if you used a record with difficult-to-track passages on it, the differences may show up but for the vast majority, I doubt anybody could tell.

Your aftermarket styli appear very close to the ones I have. I have an S2000 E/III I got from Elex Atelier (he became LP Gear) years ago and it looks the same as yours you got from Carol's Needles. The plastic housing has those "steps" in it whereas the originals from Empire don't have that. Of course, I'm talking about the ones with the clip-on stylus guard. Using my "scientific" compliance test (pushing down on the cantilever with my finger) I can tell the aftermarket stylus is stiffer and, of course, would require a higher VTF.

BTW, has anybody ever mentioned there is a review of the 2000 and 2000E and also of the 1000 ZE/X family on the Vinyl Engine site? These are from British magazines from the past. Intereting reading.

Doug
 
Hi Guys!

I spent a few minutes and swapped out one cartridge body for another of my Empire 2000's. I have two working bodies; one is a S2000E/III very shinny gold and thankfully the lettering is still intact, the other came from TurntableNeedles.com (I put a short review on the sight). The "replacement" body is a Empire 2000 body but not sure which the lettering is gone. I bought this one here to replace one I had bought on eBay but had a bad channel, the seller refunded the price and shipping, let me keep the mounting clip and told me about the body from turntableneedles.com

I mounted the original on one of my HK/Rabco arms and used my cartridge alignment tool, the stylus I put on is one of the Astatic ED103-em and set at 1.0 grams...working extremely well!!! I think the output of my original S2000E/III is slightly higher than the other one I have. The combo sounds full bodied, very clean, clear and detailed. I am playing more of the Bruce Springsteen Live 1975-1985 album set now on album 3 side 5. This is almost like being there!!! I am leaving this cartridge assembly on the table and using as my dailey favorite for now. My other favorite for dailey use is a well thought of Stanton 681EEE with a Pfanstiehl 4822-DEE that took some time to properly dial in which has gone from harsh sound to a wide dynamic sound very much like what I have achieved with my Empire set up.

I keep thinking..."I am so happy I kept my album collection" and "accepted albums from friends when they decided to get rid of theirs!" I am spoiled by what I am hearing now!

I now have a back stock of spare stylus:)

OEM S2000E/III Clear body
OEM S2000E/I Green body

Aftermarket:

Astatic EM103-ed x 3 Translucent Blue body
EVG? or possibly Pfanstiehl 4237-DEC x 2 Clear body

Saving the OEM's and using the Astatic's for dailey use. To my ears the Astatic's are performing as well as the OEM's which is a great thing! I can enjoy great sound and not wear out my records in the process.

Rockin On!
 
Ah. Thanks for settling that. I wonder where certain vendors got the idea they were magnets?

Somebody guessed wrong and the rest followed.

Here's my reasoning:
After reducing the moving mass, they had to strengthen the magnetic circuit to restore output voltage. They didn't go to stronger (bigger, heavier, more expensive) magnets, so instead, they tightened up the air gap.

Dave
 
Did we ever establish that the later 4000X bodies are low inductance like the 4000D bodies. Jim, did you ever measure yours?

I know I am being lazy in not looking back through the thread.

Doug
 
You measured it for us very nicely back in May of '13: 330 and 317 milliHenries. Technically not as low as the 4000D bodies (~250mH), but low enough to use the 4000D styli without a big penalty.
 
Last edited:
Hello ! I was interested to read the topic about cartridges Empire . I learned a lot about the Empire from You . Thank you very much ! But I have a question . I use two cartridge Empire - EXL-10 and BROADCAST ONE . They sound different . Cartridge EXL-10 for me everything is clear - needle type specified in the manual . But cartridge BROADCAST ONE I do not know the brand of the stylus . I read that the magnetic system of the BC ONE is the same as the cartridge 2000Z . This is obviously so - I measured it inductance and resistance . They are similar to the data 2000Z . But the needle cartridge BC ONE - conical , it was cartridge for radio stations . Can You tell me what type of stylus better suited for the BC ONE ? Please excuse my English - I use the translator . http://www.vinylengine.com/turntable_forum/gallery/image_page.php?album_id=128&image_id=25479 and http://www.vinylengine.com/turntable_forum/gallery/image_page.php?album_id=128&image_id=25476
 
EMPIRE Broadcast One
1. Inductance - L = 827 mH ( 685,7 mH / 10 kHz ) . R = 872 mH ( 692,7 mH / 10kHz ) .
2. Resistance - ( DC ) - L = 1,25 k . R = 1,23 k . ........... I like the sound of this cartridge . But he found no information about the replacement of the needle . I still use native needle . Use the diy phonoamp with adjustable resistance and capacitance . I will be glad to hear recommendations on replacement of the needle . Your opinion is very valuable .
 
Last edited:
salamander. you can use any of the styli made for the 2000 series cartridges and their clones. If you go to the turntableneedles.com website, those are the 237 and 239 prefix styli.

You can't use styli made for the 2000Z or 2000T cartridge or their clones because the shank which inserts into the cartridge body is 1mm on a side instead of 1.5mm per side as on the 2000E (and many other Empire "blob") series. On the turntableneedles website, these are designated as "mini".

And welcome to AK!

Doug
 
Doug G. - thank you for info ! I also assumed that you can apply the stylus from the 2000 series . But I didn't know 2000Z/T other shank . The cartridge BC ONE is almost no information and I no one never saw them . My friend brought over from Sweden a year ago .
 
Oh, and thanks Walt and Jim for the 4000X info. I had always wondered if Empire kept the X series the same, electrically, as the D series. It seemed they would being they are both 4000s but we are, after all, discussing Empire. :D

And I bet that 4000 (now D/II) looks great on that HK ST-8 (hint for picture :D).

salamander, I have done petty much the opposite of what you are proposing. I have put a Broadcast 1 stylus in my 2000 E/III body and it sounds fine.

And if you go back in the distant past of this thread, you will discover a picture of the two different "blob" bodys - the smaller hole "Z" body and the larger hole "E" body.

Doug
 
Last edited:
It would have been logical to keep the 4000X the same as the 4000D, but no, this is Empire we're talking about, so the answer is, Of Course Not! But they're not that different, so not a big deal. When I get back from dinner we'll get GrampaDave in the conversation and tackle the Broadcast One.
And by the way, I think GrampaDave's take on the UFR stylus's little metal bits is spot on. Flux focusers. They couldn't let any of that flux get loose.
.
 
Last edited:
I only have a Broadcast One stylus. I run it in an EXL-10 body. I believe that's the same as a BC1 except for markings. I got my SBC1 stylus at the Garage-A-Records retirement sale.

I'll measure my EXL body tonight, unless measurements are already out there.
 
Crazy '888's

45 years ago when I was ~4, I apparently grabbed the headshell on dad's Garrard AT-6 and twisted off the tone arm. In all probability I was attempting to imitate his actions cueing up a rekkid. In the process, I tore off the arm and mangled the original Empire '88' cartridge. After warming my a$$ with the broken arm, he had it fixed and installed a new '888' cartridge.

This cartridge was my introduction to hifi once I was again allowed to run his 'table. It always sounded very nice running into the Eico HF-81 and Goodmans speakers. Dad's system was the envy of most of my school age friends since it was an unusual component system (where most folk had consoles, or maybe Sears combo receivers with TT on top) and that it sounded excellent (I have everything to this day).

Just the other day when I was over for dinner, he presented me with the original '888' box, the cartridge, and a NOS brown (conical IIRC) stylus that had never even been fitted. It says it was made in Switzerland. Any idea by whom?

Might just have to hang it on the PX-3 for a try.
 

Attachments

  • 888.jpg
    888.jpg
    111.4 KB · Views: 81
  • 888 stylus.jpg
    888 stylus.jpg
    100.7 KB · Views: 77
salamander said:
...But cartridge BROADCAST ONE I do not know the brand of the stylus . I read that the magnetic system of the BC ONE is the same as the cartridge 2000Z . This is obviously so - I measured it inductance and resistance . They are similar to the data 2000Z . But the needle cartridge BC ONE - conical , it was cartridge for radio stations . Can You tell me what type of stylus better suited for the BC ONE ?

First, welcome to the AK turntables forum, and thanks for measuring the Broadcast One's inductance. I think we're all surprised to find it that high! I think we can find a stylus better suited to your purposes that will work in the Broadcast One body.

Since the 2000Z, 2000T and some clones have unique internal construction, including laminated pole pieces, I'm afraid there is no perfect solution, since I have no evidence that the Broadcast one has the laminated magnetic circuit.

Still, aside from the Broadcast One's original stylus, the only Empire styli that were designed to give flat frequency response inside an ~800mH body (@1kHz) are the 2000Z, 2000T and S915E styli. But as Doug G. told you, the brass "shank" or tube of the 2000Z stylus is smaller than the hole in the Broadcast One's body.

So, if I were the one with this problem, I would get a 2000Z/T or S915E stylus, insert the shank loosely, then glue the plastic grip to the outside of the Broadcast One body with a little silicone glue. It may take some trial-and-error adjustments to get the channel balance correct. Overall output may be lower as well.

I couldn't guarantee that the frequency response curve would be flat from 1kHz out to 20kHz. Instead, I would expect the graph to tilt downward toward 20kHz. This could be corrected, at least partially, with a tone control or with 100kohm loading at the input to the RIAA stage.

Alternatively, you could use the best styli from the 2000E series (S2000E/III/II/I), which were designed for bodies having ~600mH inductance. Again, you'd have to deal with a frequency response curve that was not flat, but wouldn't be too far off. I'd expect a broadcast cartridge to have a "shaped" response curve anyway.

Do either of these kluges appear appropriate to your problem?

GrampaDave: Sorry, I somehow thought you had the whole package. I think the EXL 10 is only around 350mH, though the spec sheet doesn't... specify. Do you have an LCR meter handy?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom