• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What's more important, speaker efficiency or big power amps.

I was reading an issue of Stereophile the other day and the author was saying the dynamic range of CD's has been reduced from 16.3 db above the average power level to less than 9 db.

So I was thinking if the average person listens at 85 db with a point source speaker at 8 ft with a speaker of 90 db sensitivity the power required would be about 2 watts. Nothing extreme, but if you had one of the older less compressed CD's then you would need 100 watts.

I want more life like efficient speakers? What about you?



There is a fundamental flaw in your argument.
If the user plays the older disk that is 7.3 dB "hotter" on the peaks, the overall volume is also increased. Therefore, the user would tend to turn down the volume control to listen at the same average volume level. When the user then turns down the volume control, he lessens the power being fed to the speaker so the change from the old to new CD does not really require the power differential that you would suggest.

Instead of just making the loud parts louder, the increased dynamics also make the quiet parts quieter because you turn down the volume a bit.

Now, if your speaker is really efficient, you have to contend with more background noise, hiss, and hum from the equipment, and who wants to hear all that?
 
To clarify toddalin and E-Stat: Are you saying that you have eliminated efficient speakers from consideration for your systems? Do you consider high efficiency speakers to be a liability in system building?
 
No. Only that your reasoning is flawed.

I run big JBLs that are efficient, but I have to use really quiet equipment so as not to hear the hiss of inferior equipment that bugs the he-- out of me.

It was nice when I moved from the Yamaha DSP-A1 (very quiet) to the RX-Z9 (very quiet) and could get rid of the external equalizers (that are built into the Z9) and their accompanying hiss. I actually made my own patch cords to attenuate the signal by 10 dB to knock the hiss down from the Yamaha 31-band eq units.

I also use a Crown PSA-2XH (really quiet) for my sub and it's not all that efficient (JBL W15GTi) either.
 
To clarify toddalin and E-Stat: Are you saying that you have eliminated efficient speakers from consideration for your systems?
No. Efficiency just ranks lower on my priority scale than does overall sound quality where neutrality, transparency and coherency are most important. It would be wonderful if I could use Pass Labs SIT amps with my stats.

Do you consider high efficiency speakers to be a liability in system building?
Only in the sense that *most* in my experience (not all) achieve that goal via methods that compromise coherency and tonal neutrality. I abhor the midrange nasality and honking that accompanies many traditional horn designs. I would very much like to hear a Danley model like an SH-50 that radiates all frequencies from the same mouth with consistent directivity.
 
No. Efficiency just ranks lower on my priority scale than does overall sound quality where neutrality, transparency and coherency are most important. It would be wonderful if I could use Pass Labs SIT amps with my stats.


Only in the sense that *most* in my experience (not all) achieve that goal via methods that compromise coherency and tonal neutrality. I abhor the midrange nasality and honking that accompanies many traditional horn designs. I would very much like to hear a Danley model like an SH-50 that radiates all frequencies from the same mouth with consistent directivity.

Fair enough. I appreciate you elaborating on your system preferences.
 
No. Only that your reasoning is flawed.

I run big JBLs that are efficient, but I have to use really quiet equipment so as not to hear the hiss of inferior equipment that bugs the he-- out of me.

It was nice when I moved from the Yamaha DSP-A1 (very quiet) to the RX-Z9 (very quiet) and could get rid of the external equalizers (that are built into the Z9) and their accompanying hiss. I actually made my own patch cords to attenuate the signal by 10 dB to knock the hiss down from the Yamaha 31-band eq units.

I also use a Crown PSA-2XH (really quiet) for my sub and it's not all that efficient (JBL W15GTi) either.

OK. I understand your sensitivity (no pun intended) to noisy amps and efficient speakers. I agree and run tube amps that are properly designed so they have a low noise floor. Background hiss is not an issue.

Pardon my additional curiosity, but please enlighten me on where my reasoning is flawed?
 
OK. I understand your sensitivity (no pun intended) to noisy amps and efficient speakers. I agree and run tube amps that are properly designed so they have a low noise floor. Background hiss is not an issue.

Pardon my additional curiosity, but please enlighten me on where my reasoning is flawed?

Flawed in that you propose that the higher dynamic range necessarily translates to the requirement for proportionally higher power levels rather than working toward both ends (i.e., both a bit louder and a bit softer) to keep a similar listening level thereby not requiring this direct proportionality in amplifier power.
 
Flawed in that you propose that the higher dynamic range necessarily translates to the requirement for proportionally higher power levels rather than working toward both ends (i.e., both a bit louder and a bit softer) to keep a similar listening level thereby not requiring this direct proportionality in amplifier power.

Where did I propose that?

Just the opposite from my Quad ESL-57 example.
 
The correct answer is big efficient speakers and big amps..

You can't go wrong..

85db.. pffffft......
 
I had 1000 watt monos on Maggies and Apogees years ago. Loved that sound but I got a chance to listen to a 6 watt el84 SEP on some 104db speakers and there was something there that I wanted (without some of the artifacts of the 104's)

The best I've been able to do is a custom 2 way with an active x/o that is "very" SET friendly.

I use a 300b SET on the mid/woofer and a 2a3 SET on the tweeter and am getting excellent dynamic contrasts. Might be my Holy Grail.
 
Where did I propose that?

Just the opposite from my Quad ESL-57 example.

"So I was thinking if the average person listens at 85 db with a point source speaker at 8 ft with a speaker of 90 db sensitivity the power required would be about 2 watts. Nothing extreme, but if you had one of the older less compressed CD's then you would need 100 watts."

I contend that you would not need proportionally more power to accomodate the greater dynamic range because some of the extended dynamic range would go toward making the music softer as well as louder so that you still listen at about the same average level. That's all.
 
Last edited:
"So I was thinking if the average person listens at 85 db with a point source speaker at 8 ft with a speaker of 90 db sensitivity the power required would be about 2 watts. Nothing extreme, but if you had one of the older less compressed CD's then you would need 100 watts."

I contend that you would not need proportionally more power to accomodate the greater dynamic range because some of the extended dynamic range would go toward making the music softer as well as louder. That's all.

Please look again. Your quote is from the thread originator's opening post:

I was reading an issue of Stereophile the other day and the author was saying the dynamic range of CD's has been reduced from 16.3 db above the average power level to less than 9 db.

So I was thinking if the average person listens at 85 db with a point source speaker at 8 ft with a speaker of 90 db sensitivity the power required would be about 2 watts. Nothing extreme, but if you had one of the older less compressed CD's then you would need 100 watts. In the days of LP's electronics for recordings were capable of capturing 24 db peaks. I use to measure 20 db peaks all the time with a storage oscilloscope from the output of my 300- 2/4 and Ag 350. Even my little F4460 could capture 20 db peaks. So that would mean you would need 200 watts. If you are an audio phile or recording engineer or producer that listens at an average level of 90 db that would mean you would need about another 6 db of power or 800 watts. Now how many folks can afford 800 watt power amps or own speakers that are linear with an 800 watt input signal?

I am of the opinion we need more efficient speakers if you like to listen to linear recordings that are uncompressed either from CD's or vinyl. If you were listening at 90 db and a 16 db peak came along and you had a speaker with 98 db efficiency, then you would only need a 50 watt amplifier for an audiophile and maybe 16 watts for the average person.

Doesn't that make more sense. So how do we achieve these goals. The amps, that's easy. The speakers, well horns come to mind ,but that requires some real engineering! A path main stream designers have chosen not to follow lately. JBL has its K2 and DD series, and Klipsch its Heritage speakers, Altec is still around at Great Plains Audio, Volti, and other small independents are available. But what about something reasonably priced for the masses that are craving great sound.

I want more life like efficient speakers? What about you?

TubeHiFiNut (that's me) did not chime in until later.....

So, to clarify, is it my reasoning that you are questioning or the originator of this thread?
 
I am lucky to have some very nice 300 watt tetrode/200 watt triode VTL monoblocks to drive the Sound Lab U-1s. :)

As much as my listening bias runs to (well engineered) tube amps, I got to live with some Paracas 125A transistor monoblocks that were updated by the factory to put out 350 watts at 8 ohms and a lot more at the 2 ohm dip the M-L CLS takes.

My amp of choice for the CLS is an ARC D-160 running KT-90 tubes in triode. VERY sweet and really complements the CLS. The CLS/D-160 Triode combo will not play that loud but talk about clarity, dynamics, etc. WOW.

The absolute only amps that ever tempted me beyond reason were these Paracas amps. Had this pair not already been promised to someone else, they would have been mine.....all mine.

Still have a Paracas Sierra preamp. Very nice for transistors. ;)
 
Please look again. Your quote is from the thread originator's opening post:


TubeHiFiNut (that's me) did not chime in until later.....

So, to clarify, is it my reasoning that you are questioning or the originator of this thread?

I am referring to twiiiis first post.
 
I am referring to twiiiis first post.

Thank you for clarifying. One of the shortcomings of this form of communication is that we do not have the advantage of visual cues or the ability to clarify things real time.

I just wanted to make sure that I had not misstated my position or caused any confusion.

It seems that you and I do agree regarding the ability of less efficient speakers to convey a very real sense of dynamic contrasts when mated with an appropriate amp.

Seems that certain of the foibles of very efficient, especially horn, speakers seem to impact your preferences more than they do mine.

It's good, in my opinion, to have these conversations so that we have a common point of reference and understand each others listening biases.
 
My preferences for speakers have always been low sensitivity ones (acoustic suspension and the like). I'm a classical music lover and that type of speakers always gave me the most realistic recreation of live music concerts with acoustic instruments (I'm an active concertgoer, in particular for chamber and solo piano performances). For that reason I always start with speakers in the AR class in the vintage and ATC in the modern days domains. Then I have to choose beefy amps to sustain those low sensitivity speakers. I've never been seduced by the sound of horns and SET setups for classical music reproduction (but perhaps those woud be great for jazz or blues, I don't know). When I was a teenager a friend had a system with big Klipschorns and a HK Citation 1 and 2 tubed set powering them. His listening room was huge (about 11 x 25 meters). That was the only setup with horns that I could enjoy, but the speakers were quite far away from the listeners.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom