I was reading an issue of Stereophile the other day and the author was saying the dynamic range of CD's has been reduced from 16.3 db above the average power level to less than 9 db.
So I was thinking if the average person listens at 85 db with a point source speaker at 8 ft with a speaker of 90 db sensitivity the power required would be about 2 watts. Nothing extreme, but if you had one of the older less compressed CD's then you would need 100 watts.
I want more life like efficient speakers? What about you?
There is a fundamental flaw in your argument.
If the user plays the older disk that is 7.3 dB "hotter" on the peaks, the overall volume is also increased. Therefore, the user would tend to turn down the volume control to listen at the same average volume level. When the user then turns down the volume control, he lessens the power being fed to the speaker so the change from the old to new CD does not really require the power differential that you would suggest.
Instead of just making the loud parts louder, the increased dynamics also make the quiet parts quieter because you turn down the volume a bit.
Now, if your speaker is really efficient, you have to contend with more background noise, hiss, and hum from the equipment, and who wants to hear all that?