• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

anyone else running vintage Empire carts?

Thanks for those closeups!
Empire 400 TC-a1.jpg Empire 400 TC in headshell-a.jpg
These are the best photos I have that clearly show the taper of the cantilever. Compare and contrast. Note the size of the diamonds.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to be "Johnny Raincloud" but I don't want to give a false impression either.

If you look at the images in posting number 1649, this thread, the 1st is an image of a 999VE/X-ERD that came in an Empire Scientific factory replacement original package. The 2nd is one that came in an aftermarket repackage box. It is indeed an Empire 999VE/X replacement, purple with Empire logo in gold on the flip down stylus guard, but it is a diasa stylus rather than a true "nude".

I'm sure that it sounds wonderful, just like my Pfanstiehl packaged 1000ZE/X diasa, Empire logo in gold, factory replacement. I only mention this so that there are no issues when you receive your order.

By the way, the 999TE/X-ERD white replacements, purchased several months ago from Gary at tVOM, were in the 999TE/X-ERD Empire factory replacement boxes (just like the 999VE/X-ERD) and are true "nude" styli. I don't know if Gary has any left, but it wouldn't hurt to ask.

If you go to posting number 1379, page 92, this thread and click on the 1st thumbnail, you will see a "true nude" image of my 999TE/X, fresh from it's "S999TE/X-ERD Hand Polished Elliptical Diamond .2 x .7 mil" Empire factory packed box. Shipped direct from The Voice of Music.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for those closeups!

Empire%20400%20TC-a1_zps90re9nhl.jpg


These are the best photos I have that clearly show the taper of the cantilever. Compare and contrast. Note the size of the diamonds.

I'm having trouble comparing actual diamond size but I can see the obvious cantilever differences. You've got me wanting to set up a professional photo shoot over here. ;-)

 
I think the genuine 400 TC's cantilever is recognizably tapered (that's what the TC stands for), whereas the unmarked one is not. The unmarked's bushing and diamond are larger. Not that this means the unmarked S400TC stylus is bad, but it's probable that it was made by someone other than the original Empire company (which was sold many times over the years). The important thing is that it sounds good. There's more than one way to make a competent stylus.
 
Of course, it's never a bad idea to hunt for a 2000Z/T body (or one of the clones). We know where to find a good supply of the styli, whose capabilities exceed even the 4000Ds'.

Walt,

OK, looks like I will be keeping my eye's peeled for a 2000Z or 2000T engine at reasonable cost...any real life advantages of one over the other?

It's my understanding the 2000T is just a newer version of the 2000Z and that they both use the same "small shank" stylus replacement as far as fit is concerned. Also, what are some the body models of the "clones" you mentioned?

Thanks!
 
The 2000T's specs aren't quite as good as the original 2000Z's but the differences are negligible and it's doubtful they are audible.

Doug
 
Walt, my S400TC looks just like yours. enrico's looks like an aftermarket but, like said, it doesn't mean it's not good. If they got the basics right, it'll sound good.

And here I thought the "TC" meant "Too Cool".

Doug
 
The 2000T's specs aren't quite as good as the original 2000Z's but the differences are negligible and it's doubtful they are audible.

Doug

Doug, Walt and Stevedel,

Thanks for your insight. I have 45+ MM carts in my stable plus a few additional MC's. MM's are mostly AT, Shure, and ADC, but this is my first foray into the "Empire World". Don't know why it took so long, they certainly seem to have produced some fine cartridges.

It's another learning curve.:D For example...how would I know the below:

"Important note! Make sure that the 2000Z body you consider (or it's clone) takes the "small shank" stylus replacement. A little research will save a lot of confusion".

Thanks guys!
 
Your welcome, Kico.

It's a very small "give-back" on my part. If it weren't for this thread and the folks involved, I would seldom be listening to my record collection. I would have digitized everything and used computer files and CDs.

My turntables and listening habits have been given "New Life".

I am very grateful.

And a very large "tip of the old derby" to Gary, at The Voice of Music, for keeping Empire replacement stylus costs affordable.

"Wherever you go, there you are." Buckaroo Banzai from Out There, Somewhere.
 
This is gonna get kinda geeky. Hold on, I'll get to the point eventually.

Kico said:
OK, looks like I will be keeping my eye's peeled for a 2000Z or 2000T engine at reasonable cost...any real life advantages of one over the other?
Here's my thinking: After poring over the spec sheets, measuring an EXL 30 and two 2000T bodies, and reading the reviews in German and English audio mags, I feel confident that the bodies are the same. If they both have the small shank, then they must use the same styli. If we assume that the goal was always flat response, and they use the same styli, they must be the same, or so close it makes no difference. After all, Empire deliberately made them that way; no other styli will even fit.

Doug G. said:
It's my understanding the 2000T is just a newer version of the 2000Z and that they both use the same "small shank" stylus replacement as far as fit is concerned. Also, what are some the body models of the "clones" you mentioned? Thanks!
I suspect the 2000Z, when it debuted, was rather expensive. It was likely hellaciously expensive for Empire to make, with a claimed 16-layer laminated core to be stamped out on their worn-out (we are told) tooling.

To boost sales volume, I suspect Empire resorted to a well-worn (heh) marketing strategy-- cull the best of production (ie, chop off the good tail of the bell curve) to be sold at a premium, then offer the rest as "lesser" models with different colors, etc.

Thus the 2000T, with very slightly lower specs. One test said the Z needed 0.9g to track a test groove, where the T needed 1.0g. Graphs were equally ruler-flat. And, as you say, the T probably arrived after the Z became a success.

Again, that list of bodies to look for (and there may be errors in this list as well as other clones that TTN hasn't found):

2000Z, 2000T, 2001MKV, 2001T, 2005/V, 2008, 2000/S, 204TE/X, 2204/ZH, 3000A, 3000E/Z, 3000PPC, 3100TE, 4004ZE/X, 5000MkV, 6000V, 600T, EXL30, QX5000/V, SERIES VII, XL1551E

A perfect example of Empire model-naming gibberish!

Doug G. said:
And here I thought the "TC" meant "Too Cool".
We should call GrampaDave, who decoded the TC and ID and other Benz-Empire marketspeak, "TC". Remember the old cartoon Top Cat?

Kico said:
"Important note! Make sure that the 2000Z body you consider (or it's clone) takes the "small shank" stylus replacement. A little research will save a lot of confusion".
Usually a seller will provide photos that tell the tale. If he/she doesn't, ask. I think we can mostly rely on TTN's list of compatible models. I don't have confirming photos of all of them (yet), but so far the errors in that list have been minor.

Here's a photo (by Doug G, iirc) of the two shankhole sizes:
Showing difference in shank sizes (1.5 v. 2.0mm).jpg
 
Last edited:
Just for you, Walt.

I had some time, this morning, so I got out the "Little Red Meter".

2000Z body #1 Out of headshell, Inductance: R=701 mH
L=722 mH
Resistance: R=1291 Ohms
L=1264 Ohms

2000Z body #2 Measured in headshell, Inductance: R=736 mH (Hmmm, this may explain the slight channel imbalance.)
L=842 mH
Resistance: R=1184 Ohms
L=1189 Ohms

EXL30 body Measured in headshell, Inductance: R=785 mH *(Same as above)
L=832 mH
Resistance: R=1262 Ohms
L=1252 Ohms

*I have just installed this cartridge (with silver stylus) in my Pioneer/Jelco turntable. It could be a slight response difference instead of volume. It could also be the anti-skate setting. Maybe it's just my hearing.

More grist for the data mill.
 
Last edited:
The picture really nails it. The small shank is pretty obvious.

Now as for this list: 2000Z, 2000T, 2001MKV, 2001T, 2005/V, 2008, 200S, 204TE/X, 2204/ZH, 3000A, 3000E/Z, 3000PPC, 3100TE, 4004ZE/X, 6000V, 600T, EXL30, QX5000/V, SERIES VII, XL1551E

I guess a search should be "Empire Cartridge" and sort it out every day. There is no rhyme or reasoning to the numbers.

Regardless, thanks for the list.
 
Yay Buckaroo Banzai!

G49: I'll play with a search string for the clones and give you a suggested string that won't drown you in extraneous results.

Stevedel: A hundred-milliHenry difference might be audible, but would be easily corrected. Your measurements are very similar to mine, which kept bumping up against the 800mH line. Thanks for doing them. Note that published spec is only 675mH. Shades of Shure's Era IV M95/97.

And yes, many thanks to Gary for making this an affordable adventure. No affiliation, though some might wonder.
 
Last edited:
G49: I'll give you a suggested search string that won't drown you in extraneous results.
This has been interesting. I kept running into a limit on the number of items in the string, which doesn't usually happen. So I broke it up into two separate searches.

It's a bit tough, because Empire is of course a common word used in historical collectibles, videogames and those Lucasfilm movies, and some of the model numbers look like years. Ach. Here we go..

#1
empire cartridge (2000Z,2000T,2001MKIV,2001T,"2005/V",2008,2000/S,"204TE/X","2204/ZH",3000A) -(review,ad,star,gun,ridgid,diesel,jade,belt,age,club) -(vhs,dvd,playstation,sun)

Copy and paste this into the search field, click SEARCH to get the results, then both expand and limit those results by going into Advanced Search and checking the boxes for Description and Price (set whatever limit you want) and clicking the SEARCH button on that same page.

Oh! Don't forget to save your search!

#2
empire cartridge (3000PPC,3100TE,"4004ZE/X",5000MkV,6000V,600T,EXL30,"QX5000/V","SERIES VII",XL1551E) -(review,ad)

Same directions as above. You'll get a lot of hits for replacement styli, but those are easy to ignore.

You may think you won't want to set a price limit, but when you see the outrageous prices some sellers put up, you won't want to put up with them.
 
Last edited:
...We should call GrampaDave, who decoded the TC and ID and other Benz-Empire marketspeak, "TC". Remember the old cartoon Top Cat?]

This made my LOL! Yeah, he's the most effectual... He's the most tip top, Top Cat!

And his buddies all called him TC! He was almost as sneaky as Empire and their model naming strategies.

Anyway, yes, the 2000Z was first and then the 2000T later. I also think the difference was all in the stylus and they wanted to use the ones not quite up to Z snuff instead of disposing of them. They both have very distinctive printing on the body, in lieu of the typical regular black on most models, with the Z having a big, red, stylized "2000Z" on it and the T having a big, blue, stylized "2000T" on it.

Steve, yes that difference in inductance could definitely account for a channel imbalance as long as it's the right channel that is quieter. Odd, that substantial difference in inductance when the resistance is only 5 ohms apart.

Doug
 
Anyone remember the hit song "Top Cat". Line: "And he was hit by a runaway garbage truck. Look out! Look out! Look out!". It was a parody, sung to the tune of "Big John" by Jimmy Dean.

It lasted about 12 minutes on AM radio. It was right up there with "There's an Old Tule Fog a Hangin' Around the Golden Gate Bridge in my Heart".

Yes, really.

I'm sure that they were both played with an 880 Empire on a Rek-O-Kut 12 inch transcription armed turntable.
 
Last edited:
Doug G. said:
Odd, that substantial difference in inductance when the resistance is only 5 ohms apart.
This is why we can really only be in the ballpark and make a good guess with only a resistance reading of a cartridge's coils. But, since not everyone has an inductance meter...

Arnold Stang, who voiced Top Cat by doing his Sgt. Bilko impression, also was the TV spokesnerd for a candy bar that was shaped like a flattened cube and was called.. Chunky.
 
Last edited:
Anyone else have the urge to track down a previous employee of Empire and ask them which styli are compatible for all the bodies?
 
Back
Top Bottom