• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Japanese vs. English vs. American - Building a 5.1 Chanel Surround Sound System

BaronKatz

Member
Hello There,

I am looking to buy a Receiver OR Processor/Amp and set up my own 5.1 Channel system and was wondering if I can get some recommendations of models to search for. Here are my options and requirements:

Requirements:

1. Extremely well built and has to be made in Japan, Europe, or the US/Canada (No Chinese made or outsourced models PLEASE).

2. Used/Pre-owned and recent vintage (within the last 15 years).

3. $200-$300 budget, I could stretch it to $400 for something amazing but I still have to buy the speakers.

4. At least 2 coaxial and 1 toslink input.

5. Something versatile enough to work with a multitude of various speakers (I haven't decided what speakers yet but I will have two towers/floor standing speakers, a decent sized center channel and might use satellite/bookshelf of wall hanging speakers for the rear). The speakers might have different wattage ratings but I am trying to get at least the front two and center channel to match (at least in terms of the manufacturer). So far I have been looking at things that sometimes people have to move fast on Craigslist but is high quality: Linn, NHT, Dynaudio, Magneplanar, Mirage, etc... I don't really like the idea of having a complete satellite system and a good 5.1 package is out of my price range so I have to buy this way so I can get excellent stereo music and decent 5.1 surround.

6. Something that is very good at not only surround sound but also 2 channel audio for music. I know it's often better to get a separate two channel amp for music but this is not an option for me and I want something that would work well in both modes.

Optional but would be nice:

1. Component Video Switching built in (must meet or exceed my Inday switcher and be capable of showing 1080i smoothly). I am not sure if I need upscaling as I believe that I have a built in upscaler in my Loewe Aconda (Anyone care to confirm this?)

2. Analog Audio input for 5.1? I have a Pioneer BDP-51FD which I will be using this with and it has analog 5.1 channel out. I might want to give it a try. Is this mostly for receivers that don't have the DTS decoding for soundtracks from Blu-Ray discs, if so that would give me a chance to buy an older one? Anyone know how different it would sound compared to toslink or coaxial?

3. Would prefer something with DTS decoding for Blu-Ray discs.

Options and What I've found so far in my price range:

1. The Japanese Route: KENWOOD KC-Z1 KM-Z1 (Looks awesome and amazing quality but no DTS and no component video), Onkyo NR-TX series (would love a 9xx or 1000 but these seem a bit high in my price range). Denon AVR (anniversary is amazing), Pioneer Elite (anniversary is amazing), even Sony's higher end, etc...

2. English Route: So far I have only found Arcam receivers in my price range that were still made in the UK. Meridian is a possibility as I have seen some people on craigslist selling them but this would lead to a processor/amp combo which I don't mind either. Any other suggestions for British made? Linn is amazing but out of my price range and I have only seen 2 channel?

3. American Route: So far I have only seen B&K but I have heard bad things about a lot of their receivers. Any other American made receivers to consider?

4. Any other European, Japanese or American/Canadian receivers? I have seen some JAMO ones made in Denmark but compared to Arcam and some of the higher end Japanese ones this might not be the best option?

If people can give me their opinions on what would be best and what specific models to search for that would be great (I.E. Luxman xxx, etc...)

Thank you!

P.S. I have also posted on the Speaker Forum about what tower/floor standing speakers to buy so if you could recommend those there that would be great :-)
 
Register to hide this ad
For a budget as small as that I would suggest used. Look on craigslist.. if you don't need hdmi you will score something real nice for not much. I picked up a denon 3803 for $80. It sounds great. Really nice... Before that I bought new and for $300 got a low end onkyo tx Sr304... Which I sold later for $70... What I'm saying is be patient scour craigslist and for the money you will get something that punches far above the money you paid. $400 new is entry level. $400 used can be top of the line...
 
Last edited:
For a budget as small as that I would suggest used. Look on craigslist.. if you don't need hdmi you will score something real nice for not much. I picked up a denon 3803 for $80. It sounds great. Really nice... Before that I bought new and for $300 got a low end onkyo tx Sr304... Which I sold later for $70... What I'm saying is be patient scour craigslist and for the money you will get something that punches far above the money you paid. $400 new is entry level. $400 used can be top of the line...

Yeah I am only looking for used and don't need HDMI (I have a Loewe Aconda which only has Component 1080i anyways). Used is one of my requirements on the list:D Exactly - I can get the highest end for 10% of the original price if it's say 10 years old, etc...

Can't be done on that budget unless you want several generations back - receivers I mean.

Like I said in my posting I am only looking for used and upto 15 years old (preferably around 10 would be ideal) so a few generations back is no problem. I bought my Pioneer BDP-51FD Blu-Ray for $50 including shipping on eBay (It was $600 originally) and my Loewe Aconda for $40 on Craigslist ($3500 originally) I also got a pair of NHT A400s at goodwill for $11 ($100 originally) so I know I can get amazing things at great prices if I look hard enough and I have enough choices. This is why I want to make an extensive list and search daily until I find something of a deal like the ones I have gotten in the past.:thmbsp:
 
I didn't read your whole post, but it can be done on the used market.
I have a denon, it sucks. i have a Yamaha it doesn't suck. i have had Onkyo, it doesn't suck.
I have had sony, it sucks. i have had jvc, it sucks. some pioneer is ok.

look in my ebay special in the members system forum, i doubt i have 400 bucks in my system.
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=452060
 
Last edited:
Look for denon 3805. I have the 3803 which I'd recommend but the3805 is better and comes with room correction software. You can get these for 100-200. Stay away from onkyo 605 or 705 series and some other of their models as they have hdmi board problems... Though if you don't need hdmi maybe you can pick up a broken one for nothing
 
I didn't read your whole post, but it can be done on the used market.
I have a denon, it sucks. i have a Yamaha it doesn't suck. i have had Onkyo, it doesn't suck.
I have had sony, it sucks. i have had jvc, it sucks. some pioneer is ok.

look in my ebay special in the members system forum, i doubt i have 400 bucks in my system.
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=452060

Why do you say Denon sucks and those other ones do too?

Take a look at the ONKYO Integra DTR series I have seen these used for as little as $120.00

I don't like the Integra DTR series, most of them are made in China, would rather buy something like the higher end NR's...

Look for denon 3805. I have the 3803 which I'd recommend but the3805 is better and comes with room correction software. You can get these for 100-200. Stay away from onkyo 605 or 705 series and some other of their models as they have hdmi board problems... Though if you don't need hdmi maybe you can pick up a broken one for nothing

I found a lot of 3803 and 3805s, I found one 3803 for as little as $75... The Onkyo 605 and 705 series are Made in Malaysia, not Japan, perhaps explains some of the failures and lack of quality control. I was thinking more in the 900 series range for the Onkyos or the 1000 if I can find it for that price...
 
Last edited:
I'd buy a Denon 3805 or something similar. These were well made in Japan, not Chinese made like the new Denon models. I've had Denon amps and receivers since the late 1980s and had a problem with only one AVR2808CI that got heavy use as a HT/Game system, well used by my kid and his friends. The center channel went out and was repaired by a local shop for $80. The 1980s stereo amp still runs fine, and the AVR3808 is still in service. That doesn't suck.
 
My denon and others i have heard sound like crap, the music sounds like its in a tunnel. some people may like that hallow sound, i don't.
Jvc suck's in sound a quality, so does sony. sony sounds very dead/flat.

I have had Onkyo, i had the 515 pro pushing two CV vs120's and vs80's, very nice unit and never an issue. lost it in a house fire.
I have a Yamaha R-V703, its way better than my denon 1802 and any other denon i have heard locally.
Granted, i haven't heard every denon receiver, but mine sucks. i would not buy another denon based on the way mine sounds.
I don't own any pioneer, but have heard some good and some bad.
Same with Yamaha, some of the newer models are having issues, mine is a 90's model.
 
Last edited:
My denon and others i have heard sound like crap, the music sounds like its in a tunnel. some people may like that hallow sound, i don't.
Jvc suck's in sound a quality, so does sony. sony sounds very dead/flat.

I have had Onkyo, i had the 515 pro pushing two CV vs120's and vs80's, very nice unit and never an issue. lost it in a house fire.
I have a Yamaha R-V703, its way better than my denon 1802 and any other denon i have heard locally.
Granted, i haven't heard every denon receiver, but mine sucks. i would not buy another denon based on the way mine sounds.
I don't own any pioneer, but have heard some good and some bad.
Same with Yamaha, some of the newer models are having issues, mine is a 90's model.

Well some of the units you mentioned are lower-mid grade so you cannot compare it. A Sony E9000ES and Denon 5800 might be way better than the Yamaha and Onkyo you have, although perhaps not better than an Onkyo TX-NR1000 or 5000E or say a Yamaha RX-Z9, etc... Unfortunately the Onkyo you mention is made in Malaysia as is the Yamaha.
 
Pull the trigger on the 3803 for 75 bucks. Then you'll have more money to put towards your speakers. I have no regrets about the Denon. Lovely sound... Even my wife said something nice about it and she never says anything nice abbot my audio gear
 
Well some of the units you mentioned are lower-mid grade so you cannot compare it. A Sony E9000ES and Denon 5800 might be way better than the Yamaha and Onkyo you have, although perhaps not better than an Onkyo TX-NR1000 or 5000E or say a Yamaha RX-Z9, etc... Unfortunately the Onkyo you mention is made in Malaysia as is the Yamaha.

Yeah,
They all have been in the 400 to 500 dollar range, which is all i can ever afford.
But, its not like the only price range i have listen to.
After my purchase and disappointment in the sound of the denon, i set out to some local exclusive home audio dealers. i was wanting to know if the sound i was hearing from the denon was common, to my surprise it was.
Like i said though, some people like the hallow sound, i do not.
It seemed that denon and Yamaha was the lowest priced units in two of these dealers i went to. they had some units i never heard of for money i would never see in my life.
I want to add this as well,
None of these dealers had sony, jvc, kenwwod, Onkyo, Harman/Kardon, and only two elite series in the pioneer brand.
Its your money, and its you that will be listening to the system you are going to build.
I would try and seek out the brands i was interested in locally and have a listen. you may not find the exact model of receiver or speakers, but it will still get you close in what sound you like.
I like the sound of my Yamaha, it's loud and clean, but someone else may not hear like i do.
 
Last edited:
It's a fair point, different people like different things. I liked the sound of my Onkyo, I then bought a Yamaha AX-596 and I liked the sound of that, I then bought the Denon and the other two didn't compare at all.

Depends on your other equipment, and what kind of sound you like. I think the Denon sounds warm, the Yamaha was a little brighter but had a bit more power. Some people like bright, some people like laid back, some people like warm, you won't know what you like until you hear a bunch of gear, so audition anything you buy if you can. Though the good thing about buying used is you can sell it and get your money back. I made a little selling the Yamaha, if I sold the Denon I would probably double what I paid for it. I lost money on the Onkyo because I bought it new. Trading through things is fine as you'll end up with what you want and probably won't lose money, though you'll save yourself a lot of time and fiddling if you spend time listening to other peoples stuff.
 
It's a fair point, different people like different things. I liked the sound of my Onkyo, I then bought a Yamaha AX-596 and I liked the sound of that, I then bought the Denon and the other two didn't compare at all.

Depends on your other equipment, and what kind of sound you like. I think the Denon sounds warm, the Yamaha was a little brighter but had a bit more power. Some people like bright, some people like laid back, some people like warm, you won't know what you like until you hear a bunch of gear, so audition anything you buy if you can. Though the good thing about buying used is you can sell it and get your money back. I made a little selling the Yamaha, if I sold the Denon I would probably double what I paid for it. I lost money on the Onkyo because I bought it new. Trading through things is fine as you'll end up with what you want and probably won't lose money, though you'll save yourself a lot of time and fiddling if you spend time listening to other peoples stuff.


Yep,
We all hear differently, otherwise there would be one manufacture for home audio.
My Yamaha is less power than my denon, but the Yamaha is way louder, and i do mean a lot louder.
I found specs claiming my R-V703 is 70w's for the front three channels, and found specs claiming it's 80w's per channel.
The denon states 80w's per all five channel's, i don't believe this. or the Yamaha is under-rated drastically or has a better distortion level.
I don't think i could call the R-V703 as bright either, i have to turn the treble up at least 3/4's before i would say that thats to bright. i have the treble on the denon full now and still need more.
The denon is a clean unit, just wish i could figure out why They sound hallow.
 
Last edited:
I ended up getting the Denon AVR-3805 for $100. It's well built (although not as well built as the 5800), was $1000 just a few years ago and was in amazing like new condition (minus the remote). It's made in Japan and will hopefully serve me well. Cheers to all the people who told me it can't be one in my budget and that I would have to buy Chinese, etc... It has everything I need including the component switching and even upscaling to 1080i from S-Video/Composite sources supposedly. :D

That's not to say I won't upgrade to something better as soon as I find an amazingly hot deal like this one on a 5800 or Arcam or somethig else :p

Thanks to all who have contributed but please don't stop recommending things on this forum post since I will upgrade soon enough and give this one to my dad ;)

Onto the speakers, might get those Monitor Audio R952/MDs, they look great, were top of the line and will go to check them out this week hopefully... How do they compare to the KEF Q50s? Any other suggestions for speakers that might work well with the amp in both stereo for music and surround sound for film? If I only had the money to buy some Meridians or Linns :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
If it sounds good to you, then you got a good deal.
Not a bad looking unit, plenty of connections and speaker out-puts.
 
Back to the OP:

You can find some of the early 2000s flagship Denon gear that ticks all the boxes for a song.

Check out the AVR-5800 (our maybe even a 5600) if you're looking for a battleship of an amplifier with solid Dolby Digital processing as well as the dts-es and Dolby Digital EX 7.1 formats (not available on the AVR-5600)

I'm also a big fan of the old Yamaha DSP-A1. An impressively biult, great sounding machine.

My favorite for almost no money though is still the Kenwood VR-4900. DAMN that thing had a nice sounding amplifier in it...and is available for a song these days. Just make sure you get one with a remote! (On second thought, this MAY have been Malaysian built...not that it matters, but you indicated that was important to you in the OP)


---Sorry, just saw your response! Congrats on the find, it's an excellent receiver!-----
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom