• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

PIO Capacitors, which one is best?

PR Audio

Super Member
I am in the process of buying new Paper in Oil (PIO) Capacitors to upgrade my Heathkit SA-2 (Int Amp EL84). I have found tons of stores on EBay that sell them, and the ones from the Old Soviet Block have very good pricing. I have never trusted that area of the world, but my cousin says he's bought from them in the past, and has never had any problems.

Anyways, I found that there are two types of PIO Capacitors, one is Metallized Paper in Oil (MPIO), and the other is simply Paper in Oil. The difference lies in the internal structure, where the PIO is two pure alum foil strips separated by oil impregnated paper, and MPIO is two similar strips of special paper, metallized by alum film and oil-saturated.

Has anyone used both types of capacitors, and if so, which one is sonically better??? Advantages of one over the other??? Price is no matter, as the price difference is not much.
 
Register to hide this ad
I have used the k40y caps and like them a whole bunch. McShane has them is the evilbay has you spooked. John
 
I second the k40y caps from Jim. I have them in both my Fishers.

I bought a lot of lower voltage vintage PIO online for my phono amp. It ended up that most of them were leaking oil and were no good. The caps that were not leaking sound good. Jims items are a sure deal.
 
K40Ys are a good way to go. It takes time and a fair amount of money to build up a stock of NOS American manufactured PIOs like Sprague Vitamin Qs, Asterons, Gudemans, Pyramids, Aerovox, Sangamos, Micamolds, rtc..

There are still some being manufactured by Dearborn and a couple other companies but they don't come cheap. This is besides the boutiques PIOs like Mondorfs and V Caps which are real pricey.

Obliggato is a more reasonable priced source for present manufactured PIO caps.

For the price the, the K40Ys are hard to beat.

Cheers

Lar
 
PIO caps

I have A fisher 400 that I did a lot of experimenting with different
coupling capacitors, it came stock with German ero ll caps, I tried
lots of other caps and always thought the German ero caps sounded
much better.
I saw these Russian PIO capacitors on ebay with A buy it now for
$12.00 for 20 caps, great price! so I thought I'd give them a try.
It did take about six weeks to get them and worth the wait, those
green pio caps sealed in glass are excellent and sound just as good
as the original German ero ll caps.
Just pick A seller that has A lot of positive feed back.

Robert
 
K40Ys are a good way to go. It takes time and a fair amount of money to build up a stock of NOS American manufactured PIOs like Sprague Vitamin Qs, Asterons, Gudemans, Pyramids, Aerovox, Sangamos, Micamolds, rtc..

There are still some being manufactured by Dearborn and a couple other companies but they don't come cheap. This is besides the boutiques PIOs like Mondorfs and V Caps which are real pricey.

Obliggato is a more reasonable priced source for present manufactured PIO caps.

For the price the, the K40Ys are hard to beat.

Cheers

Lar

I have A fisher 400 that I did a lot of experimenting with different
coupling capacitors, it came stock with German ero ll caps, I tried
lots of other caps and always thought the German ero caps sounded
much better.
I saw these Russian PIO capacitors on ebay with A buy it now for
$12.00 for 20 caps, great price! so I thought I'd give them a try.
It did take about six weeks to get them and worth the wait, those
green pio caps sealed in glass are excellent and sound just as good
as the original German ero ll caps.
Just pick A seller that has A lot of positive feed back.

Robert

Thanks for your opinions, great help. I found an EBay seller with lots of excellent feedback from all over the globe. He has the Russian PIO (mil spec, green sealed in glass), and is willing to put a package together for my amp, so I don't have to buy lots of 10 or 50.

He also mentioned that Teflon (TFE) capacitors offer even better sonic qualities than PIO. Any experiences with TFE capacitors??? Has anyone compared them???
 
I have used Audio Note oil caps in my tube power amp and they sound great. I think they are actually manufactured by Jensen. They were pretty expensive, but I think they were worth the cost.
 
Thanks, I easily solved the problem. After checking many forums, and independent reviews about caps, I have come to the conclusion that I would change to VCap, but after finding out VCap prices I kept reading, and found that the Russian PIO and Teflon caps are very good, and extremely similar to their expensive counterparts. So inexpensive, that in fact I have ordered a complete set of teflon caps and another complete set of PIO caps for my Heathkit SA-2. Looking forward to comparing one vs the other. All in all I spent no more than $100.00, two complete sets of different types for the price of 3 or 4 VCaps.
 
The green colored Russian caps are K42Ys and are not quite as good a cap as the K40Ys. They are a bit smaller so if size is an issue ... , still I would personally go with the K40Ys instead of the k42Ys. From all I've read and heard from several folks in the know the K40Ys are the better cap.

The FT3 and FT2 Russian teflons are also great caps. The FT3 are rather huge though and finding any sort of variety of values in the FT2s is difficult.

Just to complicate things Russia also make two other green caps the K75-24s and the K75-10s. The tens are huge but are supposedly great caps for crossovers.

Cheers

Lar
 
Last edited:
The Russian Teflons (FT-3s if I remember correctly) are awesome... I used them on my DIY single ended amplifiers. Quick, grainless and almost like DC coupling. They are honking big though and do not have normal leads - so keep that in mind if you are placing these on a circuit board.
 
I bought a whole bunch of the K40-Y capacitors a while ago and I'm finally running low on them. They're super useful and the 1000v maximum rating makes them usable in all kinds of circuits (as long as there's space...). All of them tested good for leakage on a cap checker. I think I bought mine from alexer1 on eBay.

I also bought a bunch of the FT-2 Teflon as coupling caps for my Fisher 800. I was expecting them to be just a bit larger than the K-40s but they ended up being about 3 inches long. D'oh! Luckily, I was able to shove them in there anyway.
 
That's kinda like asking which girl is the prettiest, matter of taste I guess. I have a lot of experience with the Soviet era tubes and caps. I use different caps for different purposes. If I had to choose between the K42s and the K40Ys, it'd be the K40Ys, hands down. For coupling duties I think the teflon FT-3s are better, but the best are the SSG silver and micas, really fantastic for coupling. For Parafeed, preamp output, and speaker crossover duties, where you need values between 1 and 8uf, the KBGs are the way to go. For the last stage in power supply and cathode bypass duties, where you need more C, I use the MBGOs, even better than motor runs.

BTW don't sweat the eastern bloc sellers, I have had over 100 auctions from them, with no problems. Sometimes shipping can be slow, anywhere from 10-30 days.

twystd
 
I've been quite fortunate securing NOS paper-in-oil caps (Sprague Vit. Q, Westcap, Gudeman, etc.) off of flea-bay, at reasonable prices.
Most have been used in guitar amps and as guitar tone caps.

Steve
 
I've never dealt with PIO caps but one popular company that makes them is Jensen.They are very pricey and I dont know if they are worth it but here is a link if interested. Scroll down and look on the left side for Jensen caps to view prices.I'd like to know if they are worth it. I buy a lot of other caps from these folks
.
http://www.referenceaudiomods.com/
 
Jensen caps are used in Cary amps, so I have to believe they are good, if expensive. Some in the Cary's are huge, so I would check the dimensions.
 
Kimber, Hovland, or Auricap, depending on what tone you are looking for. I gave up on the Russian jobs for various reasons.

Oh, btw, there is a new fancy cap out named "MOD" that AES is selling. They are junk.
 
Kimber, Hovland, or Auricap, depending on what tone you are looking for. I gave up on the Russian jobs for various reasons.

Oh, btw, there is a new fancy cap out named "MOD" that AES is selling. They are junk.

Could you elaborate on the problems you've had with the russian caps? I've just put some in in place of polyesters and things improved to my ears. Do you think there is big room for more improvement with some of those other pio's you mentioned? What's the best bang for the buck in your experience? Also can anyone expain a little about about the benefits of bypassing and how that works?
 
Back
Top Bottom