• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

How much difference does the amp make in sound reproduction?

flavo

New Member
OK, so maybe that's a shifty way to get you in here, but the question stands. I'm about to buy my 3rd tube amp and am looking for some insight. My 1st was an onyx SP3 http://www.highfidelityreview.com/onix-sp3-integrated-tube-amplifier.html and I sold it because I didnt really see anything special about it over my cheap SS amp and cheap ebay little bear pre amp. Next and very recently I purchased a new set of speakers - Tekton Lores http://www.tektondesign.com/lore.html(very efficient) and an AricAudio KT88 http://aricaudio.com/products.php?product=KT88SE12ax. For all I know it's fine. i definitely enjoy it over my ss amp ebay pre but I kind of want to be sure I'm getting all I can for my money. I have no friends in the area to swap or test gear with. So I want to purchase a new amp in the sub $2k range that I can be assured will sound incredible to a non pro ear, with the only thing holding me back being something other then amp/build quality. I listen to mainly classic rock or female vocalists at normal volumes.

I can tell you that I enjoy the bass response better of my onkyo ss and ebay tube pre over the aricaudio kt88.

So, I was thinking of building a
Bob Latino ST-120 (he's local) http://www.tubes4hifi.com/bob.htm
decware mini torII http://www.decware.com/newsite/minitoriise.htm
Denis Had Inspire
Wright audio Lolita http://www.wrightaudio.us/lolita.htm
Ultra Valve http://www.avahifi.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=250&Itemid=235

With the above thoughts, can I not go wrong? As long as I buy a decent/known amp am I setting myself up (amp wise) for that spooky, 3d, amazing sound I hear folks going on and on about?

With my efficient speakers and lack of bass from my current set up should I be looking into a larger amp? Like maybe building the ST-120/150?
Or adding a sub?
Or My current amp just don't cut it and I need a higher quality amp?

Sorry I'm so lost here. I hope you can help point me in the right direction. :tresbon:
 
Register to hide this ad
Try a tube rectified amp. Didn't look at any of your links but IMO, tube rectifier gives an extra serving of tube goodness over solid state rectifiers.
 
I'm waging you know more then me. But the paramours have been defunct since 2006 from what the website says. The main complaint I have read about them as well is that they lack bass. Ebay has a pair for around $500 currently that I had considered. I could certainly buy and resell if I don't like them bu I'm trying to have my next amp be the amp I keep.
 
Try a tube rectified amp. Didn't look at any of your links but IMO, tube rectifier gives an extra serving of tube goodness over solid state rectifiers.

Let's not forget that the circuit section that follows the rectifier is the filter network, the purpose of which is to remove all traces of the rectification process.
 
I've been reading quite a bit and you've thrown that rectifier bit out of left field seemingly. Got a link to a recommended one?
 
Let's not forget that the circuit section that follows the rectifier is the filter network, the purpose of which is to remove all traces of the rectification process.

Which I believe would add color and extra process to the music, Thereby removing some of the 3d and naturalness I'm looking for?
 
The difference between tube and solid state rectification is insertion power loss. Tubes tend to have it unless very overrated, solid state not at all. There's no single magic bullet for good overall design engineering.


Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk
 
Which I believe would add color and extra process to the music, Thereby removing some of the 3d and naturalness I'm looking for?

No. 400 volts of pure DC out of the filter network of a solid state rectified power supply is identical to 400 volts of pure DC out of the filter network of a tube rectified power supply.

400 volts DC is 400 volts DC. Period.

The difference between tube and solid state rectification is insertion power loss. Tubes tend to have it unless very overrated, solid state not at all. There's no single magic bullet for good overall design engineering.


Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk

This is correct, and is a separate topic. Power supply design is a real "thing", and the importance of good power supply design cannot be overstated.

It. Is. Important.

Among all the audiophiles that I know, who have a preference for one type of rectification over another, I do not know of a single person who has listened to a power supply with one type of rectification, changed the rectifier, (with any other necessary circuit mods, obviously), and then listened to the power supply with the other type of rectification.

It's always two entirely different amps, and the differences in sound are somehow always "it must be the shoes".
 
Isn't the basic purpose of rectifiers to supply clean DC voltage, the cleaner the better? I thought tube rectifiers only made a desirable difference in guitar amps. I was under the impression they didn't (or shouldn't) affect the signal path except where sag was involved.

edit: question answered^^^
 
OK, so maybe that's a shifty way to get you in here, but the question stands. I'm about to buy my 3rd tube amp and am looking for some insight. My 1st was an onyx SP3 http://www.highfidelityreview.com/onix-sp3-integrated-tube-amplifier.html and I sold it because I didnt really see anything special about it over my cheap SS amp and cheap ebay little bear pre amp. Next and very recently I purchased a new set of speakers - Tekton Lores http://www.tektondesign.com/lore.html(very efficient) and an AricAudio KT88 http://aricaudio.com/products.php?product=KT88SE12ax. For all I know it's fine. i definitely enjoy it over my ss amp ebay pre but I kind of want to be sure I'm getting all I can for my money. I have no friends in the area to swap or test gear with. So I want to purchase a new amp in the sub $2k range that I can be assured will sound incredible to a non pro ear, with the only thing holding me back being something other then amp/build quality. I listen to mainly classic rock or female vocalists at normal volumes.

I can tell you that I enjoy the bass response better of my onkyo ss and ebay tube pre over the aricaudio kt88.

So, I was thinking of building a
Bob Latino ST-120 (he's local) http://www.tubes4hifi.com/bob.htm
decware mini torII http://www.decware.com/newsite/minitoriise.htm
Denis Had Inspire
Wright audio Lolita http://www.wrightaudio.us/lolita.htm
Ultra Valve http://www.avahifi.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=250&Itemid=235

With the above thoughts, can I not go wrong? As long as I buy a decent/known amp am I setting myself up (amp wise) for that spooky, 3d, amazing sound I hear folks going on and on about?

With my efficient speakers and lack of bass from my current set up should I be looking into a larger amp? Like maybe building the ST-120/150?
Or adding a sub?
Or My current amp just don't cut it and I need a higher quality amp?

Sorry I'm so lost here. I hope you can help point me in the right direction. :tresbon:

Dennis Had would be my recommendation, in regards to what you listed.

If your speakers are at least 89dB efficient, I would recommend a Dynaco SCA-35 refurbished. You will have richness of sound you've never heard before!! I used to be mostly a solid state guy, and it hooked me!
 
I'm waging you know more then me. But the paramours have been defunct since 2006 from what the website says. The main complaint I have read about them as well is that they lack bass. Ebay has a pair for around $500 currently that I had considered. I could certainly buy and resell if I don't like them bu I'm trying to have my next amp be the amp I keep.


BH Paramounts, sorry. I run a Stereomour and IMO the bass is full. I feel it in my legs.
 
Have you considered vintage? Integrated?

flavo,

Have you considered a vintage tube amp?

Have you considered an integrated tube amp instead of a pre-amp/power amp? $2k is a generous budget - you could get a nice vintage integrated tube amp, with an allowance for professional restoration for $2k. For example, if you buy smart you could get a Scott 296 or maybe a Fisher X-1000. (These TOTL line integrated amps both would take some patience to find, and the Fisher might stretch your budget.) Given the 98 dB rating of your speakers and “normal” listening levels – and if your room is modest size – you could probably get away with less power – which means there’s a lot of options. (And, you’ve tried 6L6 and KT88 amps and apparently didn’t like them.) 7189 based amps (e.g., Scott 222C or 299B) can sound really sweet. (Or get the same amp in a 399 receiver.) A 7591 based amp (Scott 299C or Fisher KX-200) would provide a bit more power, and has a different sound. (And Fisher 500C and 800B receivers have the 7591s.) Tone controls are an emotive topic – I like them – many don’t. But they’re certainly a way to tailor the tonal balance – and all of the vintage integrate amps (and receivers) have them.

If you specifically want a power amp, perhaps a Scott LK150, which uses KT88s –however you’d have to be patient – they’re fairly rare. A Pilot SA-260 (EL34) would be well within your budget and is capable of great sound – but again somewhat rare – it would take some patience. The McIntosh tube power amps are probably beyond your budget. (And the Marantz tube amps certainly would be.)

I run all of the amps listed above (except Marantz tube amps), plus others. They’re all capable of great sound, IMO – given efficient speakers and reasonable room size and listening levels. And there’s a market for all of them – so you can try something and if you don’t like it resell it. (Scott and Fisher have other power amps that I'm not familiar with that would be within your budget.)

Bottom line, if you you've never heard a 7189 amp – you might give that a try.

Also, if you disclose your location, there might be an AK member in your area who could help you out.

Just a thought.
 
My tube rectifier idea got shot down pretty good.:D Anyways, if you have a chance to hear MC60 and MC75 side by side, you will be able to tell the difference.
 
P.S. There’s a Pilot SA-232 (fully restored) power amp on ebay. It has EL84/7189. There's also two Fisher SA300's (EL34?). (I have no affiliation with either Seller.) Have you considered something like this?
 
You've been spending time with push pull tube amps which employ negative feedback to gain greater power. Many pp tube amps sound no better than ss.

You should try a SET amp with the Lores and the Bottleheads are a good example. My Paramours had plenty of bass with the Omens and the Lores use the same driver.
 
You've been spending time with push pull tube amps which employ negative feedback to gain greater power. Many pp tube amps sound no better than ss.

You should try a SET amp with the Lores and the Bottleheads are a good example. My Paramours had plenty of bass with the Omens and the Lores use the same driver.

So you think I should pull the trigger on those ebay ones rather then buy one of the ones I have listed? Because they will sound just as good at a fraction of the price? Or they will sound nearly as good at a fraction of the price?

flavo,

Have you considered a vintage tube amp?

Also, if you disclose your location, there might be an AK member in your area who could help you out.

I havent given it much weight because the aforementioned Dynaco that was considered to be a pretty great amp has been updated several times and now is considered a much better amp, from what I gather. I'm assuming the same for the rest of the gear. I've read from more then one account how the ST-120 happily replaced and sounded better Mcintosh gear costing several times more.
And my address has been addressed :-)


BH Paramounts, sorry. I run a Stereomour and IMO the bass is full. I feel it in my legs.

You recommend the paramounts over the stereomour only because of the extra wattage and I'm willing to spend the extra $?
You don't recommend the ones I mentioned because you know the Bottlehead is excellent and haven't heard the others?


Dennis Had would be my recommendation, in regards to what you listed.

If your speakers are at least 89dB efficient, I would recommend a Dynaco SCA-35 refurbished. You will have richness of sound you've never heard before!! I used to be mostly a solid state guy, and it hooked me!

You recommend the dynaco over the Inspire? Why please. In which case I would be better off moving up to an updated version of the dynaco like the Latino or Ultra Valve I listed?





I really appreciate the advice and hope nobody takes offence my writing/thinking style.
My original question was never really answered. I just got a bunch more amps to look at. Haha.
Or maybe Poutlry did sorta? I need to focus on SET's (in general, as a beginner) for the magic I'm looking for? Is that why the low wattage amps are considered so great when any one could just as easily get a more powerful tube amp for a tiny bit more money?

Thanks so much folks!
 
Reading your first post and last I don't think anyone can just hand out magic and base with awesome sound and know it's right in your environment. This will need to be done by you and you only sampeling units and working with your system.

That said it's far harder getting tubes to drive a lot of speaker really efficiently. Also some speakers just can't do it all in all enviorments.

Have you thought about things like bi-amping your speakers or adding a power sub?
 
^^^^^^^^^^^^^this.
I have had a ASL pp EL34 based amp for 10 years. I recently purchased a BH Stereomour from a member here and drive Cornwalls and that's my extent with tubes. As far as sound goes, the ASL sit's.
 
Back
Top Bottom