Mike Gibson
Your Sir, are correct, once it's below 40, there ins't a lot of heat to extract from the outside air.
I am really hesitant to contine to respond to this thread.. I fear that I may be coming across as an "know it all egomanic", which if not the case, as I know very little.
But considering most anyone on AK is a gadget freak, & interested in the theory on how things work, and in hope that perhaps someone will glean a little useful information from my limited knowledge, I shall press on.
Refrigeration does not create "cool", it removes heat. Kind of a moot point, until you come to heat pumps. In the summer, the AC removes heat from the interior of the house and exhausts it to the outside. In the winter, the heat pump reverses cycle, and removes the heat from the outside and exhausts it into the dwelling. We won't go into the sizes of the evaporator/condensor coils, which has an effect.
If there is no "heat" outside, the heat pump can't very well exhaust it into the interior of the house. In other words, they don't work very well in cold climates.
The exception to the rule are the ground source heat pumps. As they are working with a constant temperature of app 55-60F, they only have to move app 15F from one direction to the other. However, they have their own drawbacks.
IMHO, the most miserable device one can own is an electric furnace. If you look inside at the heating coils, they look like an overgrown toaster. And bear in mind, you are buying watts from the power company, don't matter if it's 120V, 220V, three phase, you're still buying watts.
Use one of those cheap assed 3,000 watt portable heaters, and see what it does to your electrical bill. All the heating element is, is a dead short, that's why they create heat. Get one too light, it will burn in half.
And I will be happy to be corrected by others more knowledgeable on this subject.
Charles