Sound off: "Real wood" receivers, amps and tuners!

Rosewood on my MX-2000
DSC_8240.JPG

Very pretty and, judging from the growth rings, from a really good sized log! I made some solid walnut end plates for a Yamaha CD player, same titanium finish. It looked pretty darned nice.

John
 
Rosewood on my MX-2000
DSC_8240.JPG
Looks the same as the Sony TA-N77ES (belongs to a friend). One of the sides has a light chip which exposed....you guessed it...errr maybe not....yes veneer on particle board.

People who believe they have real wood need to examine the grain on the tops and ends. If they are NOT cross grain then they are laminated or veneered. Veneered will have grain that runs length wise along the long edge. I can't make out the grain in this image on my monitor but it appears to be veneer. As stated earlier this is not a BAD thing as real solid wood is just not suitable for these applications.

If you think you have solid wood don't be offended, it's really not a big deal. Veneer isn't cheap, especially the more exotic types. Be happy and do take care of it.
 
If you think you have solid wood don't be offended, it's really not a big deal. Veneer isn't cheap, especially the more exotic types. Be happy and do take care of it.

If I point out that you are wrong, don't be offended.

I know for a fact that those are solid Rosewood panels.
 
If I point out that you are wrong, don't be offended.

I know for a fact that those are solid Rosewood panels.
Not offended at all. Image is difficult to make out on my monitor. Solid wood is really rare on equipment (never personally seen any myself) as you can tell by the responses here.
 
some of the best wood veneer finish i've ever seen on an audio product comes from the british company Castle who make speakers..
i can't say what the base material is..probably mdf..but the finish they achieve with the top layer of real wood veneer (especially the grain matching and fit at the edges) is so seamless its easy to mistake the entire box for solid wood...

http://www.castle.uk.com/VeneersTechnology/Veneers/tabid/72/language/en-US/Default.aspx
 
Man what an education, thanks everyone! Naively I presumed veneer was a cheap solution but now I understand it is the best solution when seeking both beauty and stability, uniformity and longevity.
 
I made the same misconception when I first joined AK. It's understandable. And yes, the same goes for speakers. I must admit that my heart sank a bit upon discovering that my old Wharfedales were walnut-veneered rather than solid-walnut through and through ("NNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!"). There are a VERY-small number of high-end speaker companies who are using real-wood, but I would have to guess it's merely to satisfy the uneducated hi-end audio snobs more than a case of sound-quality (but that's merely a case - Some might be using the 'tonewood' philosophy that's prevalent among guitar-manufacturers).
 
Last edited:
wards airline. pics in profile:banana:

Wait a minute, their guitars weren't even real-wood...:saywhat:

That red guitar that Jack White plays is made of plastic. Probably-not even plastic - Might be 'plastique' or something like that.

*Edit* - Just looked at the pictures. Damn, that thing is cool! Real wood or not, that's a fine-looking unit.... especially for a Montgomery-Ward offering. All-tube, right? How does the thing sound?
 
Last edited:
KLH Model 8 radio. Solid wood.

That being said I will further qualify that while monolithic, the stock used to make the cases may have been glued up edgewise.

I know this because the speaker of our unit sat on the receiver for decades and did develop a slight split.

True HiFi and solid wood, yes sir.

What do I win?
 
Looks the same as the Sony TA-N77ES (belongs to a friend). One of the sides has a light chip which exposed....you guessed it...errr maybe not....yes veneer on particle board.

People who believe they have real wood need to examine the grain on the tops and ends. If they are NOT cross grain then they are laminated or veneered. Veneered will have grain that runs length wise along the long edge. I can't make out the grain in this image on my monitor but it appears to be veneer. As stated earlier this is not a BAD thing as real solid wood is just not suitable for these applications.

If you think you have solid wood don't be offended, it's really not a big deal. Veneer isn't cheap, especially the more exotic types. Be happy and do take care of it.

Sorry but I'm sporting solid wood over that amp...
 
Ramblin's about wood

Solid wood sides on audio equipment is not necessarily impossible, but given the availability/unavailability of "proper" wood, any number of problems may become apparent, especially with respect to abrubt heating and cooling. other enviornmental also affect the behavior of wood, not the least of which is changing air pressure, changing humidity and changing temperature.
To understand this, one has to have a little understanding the nature of the wood.
First, wood is a product cut from a tree (a living thing). Growth happens as concentric circular rings which are added to the outside circumference yearly.
Secondly, (in most instances) the outermost layer is alive, the next set of layers conducts "sap" up and down to feed the tree, and the "heart is almost "dead wood". Due to compression from the outer layers and reduced sap conduction, the heart is mostly harder and denser (except in some species).
Third, enviornmental conditions affect ring thickness. Good years allow more growth (larger rings), lean years cause less growth (smaller rings). Small rings make for stronger denser wood.
Forth, different species of tree have different growth patterns. Some may even allow the heart to rot while the tree is still alive and healthy, while some will exhibit in the sapwood layers.
The next things that affect wood products is how they are sawn, and how the are dried.
The method most used is slab or plank sawing, which is essentially squaring the log and slicing slabs from the square. This yields the widest planks, but looked at from the end, it is apparent that the smallest rings are on one side of the board, largest rings on the other. The smallest side is sometimes called the right side, the other the wrong side. Generally, depending on the thickness of the wood, the "plank" will tend to be convex on the right side, concave on the wrong side. Related to plank sawn is flitch sawn wherein the log is not squared, but planks are sawn from the round log. Flitch is mostly used for boat planking. The preferred method cor cabinet and fine furniture wood is the quarter sawn method. The log is cut into quarters, then the quarters are cut so that the growth rings will be perpendicular to the wide faces of the plank. This method yields planks that are more narrow than the other 2 methods, but the end product is less prone to cupping and warping.
Drying is next part of the equation. Most lumber in common lumber yards (and even some specialty yards) is kiln dried. Cut wood is put in a kiln of a certain temperature, and the moisture may or may not be drawn from the kiln. This wood is mostly not suitable for cabinets in it's plank form for cabinet making, although sometimes suitable pieces may be picked from the lot. The other method is air drying which entails stacking the wood in sheds with spacers between each layer and gaps between each board to allow natural drying. Boat lumber and fine furniture woods tend to be dried this way. These woods are the least inclined to behave badly under changing conditions.
Last, and perhaps most importantly is the wood specie. Black walnut tends to be stable and beautiful, but American black walnut has become very expensive. Certain varieties are also desirable, but expensive.
Anyway, thats my ramblin's
 
The RG Pro 16W dynamic range expander has solid walnut sides. I have one somewhere and they're the real thing.

You're right. You got me wondering so I had to go and check. I had assumed they were veneer but upon looking over my RG16 I found they are solid walnut side panels.
 
I have a pioneer sx440 that has a real wood case, can't recall what species though. It may not be silver faced but it certainly counts as vintage.
 
Tivoli Model One. Case looks to be solid wood, not 100% sure, but it doesn't look like veneer. Just picked it up at the GW, so haven't had it apart yet to check :D

100_3530.JPG
 
If you're counting speakers, the ones on the little JVC FS-7000 Executive Micro System are solid cherrywood.

fs-7000_front.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom