I had the same issues with my 1250. I had finished the repair and recap of all boards except the tuner. What the heck! So I recaped the tuner knowing I have a local Tech (Bobby) to fix or align if I needed it. FM/AM reception and FM separation seemed to be back in specs as well as the tuning functions (as well as the meter indications)! From the sounds of it I got lucky but this is the third tuner recap and only very miner adjustments were needed by Bobby to put it back into specs. The tuner board is very accessible and parts may add up to $15.00 at the most. I used MTF's list posted on Matts Thread (page 7).
Continue at your own risk!
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=420950&page=7
sx-1250,tuner,ok,,,,,,,
sx-1250,awe-068,C4,220,16,cea,,220,16,647-UPW1C221MPD
sx-1250,awe-068,C10,0.47,50,cea,,0.47,50,667-ECQ-V1H474JL
sx-1250,awe-068,C23,10,16,csza,,10,50,647-UKL1H100KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C24,47,16,ceanl,,47,25,647-UKL1V470MPDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C25,470,16,cea,,470,25,647-UPW1E471MPD
sx-1250,awe-068,C26,4.7,25,ceanl,,4.7,25,647-UKL1E4R7KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C28,10,16,csza,,10,50,647-UKL1H100KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C29,10,16,csza,,10,50,647-UKL1H100KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C32,100,16,cea,,100,16,647-UPW1C101MED
sx-1250,awe-068,C33,1,50,cea,,1,50,647-UPW1H010MDD
sx-1250,awe-068,C35,0.1,35,csza,,0.1,50,598-DSF050J
sx-1250,awe-068,C36,1,25,ceanl,,1,50,647-UKL1H010KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C38,1,25,ceanl,,1,50,647-UKL1H010KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C41,1,10,csza,,1,50,647-UKL1H010KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C42,3.3,10,csza,,3.3,50,647-UKL1H3R3KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C43,0.22,25,csza,,0.22,50,667-ECQ-V1H224JL
sx-1250,awe-068,C48,4.7,25,ceanl,,4.7,25,647-UKL1E4R7KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C56,10,16,csza,,10,50,647-UKL1H100KDDANA
sx-1250,awe-068,C59,0.1,35,csza,,0.1,50,598-DSF050J
sx-1250,awe-068,C60,220,16,cea,,220,16,647-UPW1C221MPD
sx-1250,awe-068,C61,47,16,ceanl,,47,25,647-UKL1V470MPDANA