• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Best options to augment bass?

Wes_in_VA

Super Member
In my listening room I use a pair of Aiko double mouth horn speakers using Fostex FE108e drivers. The drivers are rated to 80Hz and in room response with the speakers is likely something like 50Hz, maybe even a bit lower. The room is really small, like 11x13.
For a lot of the music I listen to this is okay. There's just a small sense of something missing and the strengths of the speakers make that worth it.
With music that has a lot of low-end energy...they're just not quite "there".

I had a cheap HT subwoofer so I plugged that in to the system and it showed me that I really need to address the low end.

My budget is tight so I'm thinking that I'll need to go DIY. A ready-made sub that's good enough to match up with the Aikos is--I'm assuming--out of my price range.

My plan is to use a Mini DSP as my crossover, and run either a plate amp or a nice class D amp to drive whatever I choose to build. (Keep in mind that this is my first foray into anything like this.)
I'm intrigued by the H frames, and the bucket subs look really good too.
I'm hoping for some input on what would give the best integration with the Aikos for the least cash outlay.

I actually have a 10" Klipsch woofer (from a pair of KG 4.2's) that I can use as a starting point.
Ideally, I'd love to build one bucket sub using the Klipsch driver and pair it with the YJHiFi TPA3116 100w amp. I just don't know if one bucket sub will integrate well and whether a 100w amp will control the woofer.

Any input is appreciated!
 
Register to hide this ad
Oh man...where to start. First, LF reproduction is so room dependent and I have zero experience working with a room that small so I'm hesitant to make any sort of recommendation even though I've built the H-frame subs, the bucket subs, and a few different sealed DIY subs (and I think you know my back story wrt acoustic treatments).

Let's start with the bucket subs since that's the direction you're kind of leaning right now. It appears I'm the first here on AK to build them and measure their in room response and I certainly couldn't get them to play flat down to 30Hz in my room like some have said they've been able to do. You might be able to get them flat down to 30Hz with EQ but no telling what type of distortion that'll introduce. I built two and each gets a slightly different response in my room since their locations result in a different boundary layer interaction. One peaks at 70-80Hz and is -2db from 50-70Hz, -3db at 40Hz, -6db at 30Hz. The other is -5db at 80, -3db at 70, peaks at 50-60 Hz, is -4db at 40 and -10db at 30. So you can see they're no different than any other sub in that their performance is going to be room and location dependent. I think they barely qualify as subs as I don't find their first octave performance all that impressive. They are pretty musical and definitely punchy so I think they're better served in a distributed bass arrangement with subs that have the first octave covered but maybe get a little sloppy in the second octave. But then again, you're not even talking about using the Peerless 8" driver so you're on your own there, Magellan.

I really like the H-frames for their speed and musicality. They don't have much output in terms of sheer SPL and they don't dig any deeper than 30 Hz but they sure do what they can do very nicely. They were the first subs that I could get to integrate effectively with my Maggies and Acoustats and really revealed to me a type of LF reproduction I'd never heard before. If you've only heard LF from boxes it's quite the treat to hear it done free of a resonating chamber. BrettA is the only guy I know of who has built them and didn't have the positive experience everyone else seems to. All that having been said, I'm not sure your room can accommodate them. I found about four feet from the front wall to be required in my room to get them sounding impressive and I'm doubtful this would work with your set up.

Conventional sealed or ported subs are what they are and you've already tried one so you have an idea what can happen in your room with one. They certainly have their place and I'm currently using sealed DIY units with the bucket subs in my distributed bass set-up. I think most would find it pretty impressive in power and musicality, but I long to get back to the freedom of boxless bass. Actually, I'm looking at building w-frame or ripole subs as my next project and they kind of combine OB, box and horn loaded into one package. If you're feeling adventurous I actually think this might be a good direction for you to look.

If you're hell bent on using that Klipsch woofer in a bucket understand it takes a bit of power to get the bucket subs going...not sure if 100w will do the trick. Most who have tried that kind of power say it's a little flaccid. One thing is for sure...I'd forget using a single. Go at least two, maybe three or four. Jump over to DIYaudio or PE's TechTalk forum and poke around a bit...maybe get a thread started on those like you have here. Way more cats over there who can suggest bang for the buck DIY ideas than I think you'll find on AK.

- Michael
 
Here are the H-frames Michael referred to paired with Fostex Tektons. Very musical and articulate bass if you have the space.

picture.php
 
My budget is tight so I'm thinking that I'll need to go DIY. A ready-made sub that's good enough to match up with the Aikos is--I'm assuming--out of my price range.

Ideally, I'd love to build one bucket sub using the Klipsch driver and pair it with the YJHiFi TPA3116 100w amp. I just don't know if one bucket sub will integrate well and whether a 100w amp will control the woofer.

I read halfway and was going to suggest a bucket sub. As far as using the Klipsch driver, I don't know if that would work in the design or not. Get the Q and Vas specs for the driver in that design and compare them to your driver. I don't suppose there is any harm in experimenting, but you may end up buying the driver they recommend.
 
Several old acoustic suspension speakers (large Advents come to mind) had very good LF response. If placed near near room boundaries they might be enough in a small room. Lots of plate amps out there that contain the required crossover electronics...
 
Several old acoustic suspension speakers (large Advents come to mind) had very good LF response. If placed near near room boundaries they might be enough in a small room. Lots of plate amps out there that contain the required crossover electronics...

Hmm....that's an interesting concept and one I hadn't thought of. As a starting point, I have a pair of Epicure Model 11's that I'm not using. :scratch2:
 
Thanks to kirk57's input, I decided to do a very simple and fun experiment:
I have a pair of Epicure Model 11's that I haven't been using, so I pulled the plate amp out of the cheapie Yamaha sub and wired up one of the Epicures to it.
The results were much better than I expected, and it blows the Yamaha sub away for supplementing the bass in the Aikos. It's tighter and much better defined. The only area where it seems to lack is in the lowest of the lows.
I haven't had a chance to play with placement yet so it will be interesting to see what better placement will do.
 
If you can find an old M&K volkswoofer, they are in beautiful walnut cabinets, they are priced at a reasonable level, they can be brought in at very low volume so they don't override your main speakers, and they are particularly musical.

If you could get a friendly AKer to ship you this one, it might be perfect!

http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=562583



In my listening room I use a pair of Aiko double mouth horn speakers using Fostex FE108e drivers. The drivers are rated to 80Hz and in room response with the speakers is likely something like 50Hz, maybe even a bit lower. The room is really small, like 11x13.
For a lot of the music I listen to this is okay. There's just a small sense of something missing and the strengths of the speakers make that worth it.
With music that has a lot of low-end energy...they're just not quite "there".

I had a cheap HT subwoofer so I plugged that in to the system and it showed me that I really need to address the low end.

My budget is tight so I'm thinking that I'll need to go DIY. A ready-made sub that's good enough to match up with the Aikos is--I'm assuming--out of my price range.

My plan is to use a Mini DSP as my crossover, and run either a plate amp or a nice class D amp to drive whatever I choose to build. (Keep in mind that this is my first foray into anything like this.)
I'm intrigued by the H frames, and the bucket subs look really good too.
I'm hoping for some input on what would give the best integration with the Aikos for the least cash outlay.

I actually have a 10" Klipsch woofer (from a pair of KG 4.2's) that I can use as a starting point.
Ideally, I'd love to build one bucket sub using the Klipsch driver and pair it with the YJHiFi TPA3116 100w amp. I just don't know if one bucket sub will integrate well and whether a 100w amp will control the woofer.

Any input is appreciated!
 
Like the OP, my speakers have Fostex full range drivers. They are fast and need fast bass augmentation to keep up with them. I like the idea of H-frames, but if you want to go with a subwoofer you can't go wrong with a Rythmik FV12. They are servo controlled, musical, very versatile, and do not sound like any of the typical home theater subs. They do go very low, but you will not get boomy or flabby bass response. If I was to recommend another type sub, I would say to stick with a non-ported acoustic suspension design as a second option.
 
place the sub in your preferred seating position and then go around to room and find where it sounds best, you can then put your sub there.
 
Okay, so crazy idea here:
My room is quite small so I'm thinking that 2 bucket subs using the Peerless 8" woofer would be overkill. One standard bucket sub probably not so good.
So here's where it gets crazy:
I love the performance of these little 6" woofers in the Epicure 11's that I've mentioned. It got me to thinking...
What about "mini buckets" using a 3 1/2 gallon bucket and the woofers from those Epicures??? (Yes, I've gone off the deep end...)
Those woofers were used in both ported and sealed enclosures so that's no problem.
The 11's were rated down to 38Hz which according to my ears is about right.
I think a 3 1/2 gallon enclosure is about the right size.
The truly crazy part is that I think I'll start out driving them with a pair of Eico HF20 monoblocks. Those have driven the Epicures well in the past so I think it's worth a shot, and soon the Eicos will be pulled out of my living room system living them feeling all lonely and unloved.
I have a Mini DSP on the way to began the mad experiment.

Please, don't call the padded van on me yet. I think this could be fun.
 
I once used a pair of U3 Large Advents underneath a pair of Magneplanar MG-Is. The large advents were on their side. It served two purposes, it raised the MG-Is high enough off the floor so that I could hear them when I was standing up, and filled in the frequencies below 50HZ nicely.

I used an old Yamaha AV Receiver to power them, set on CD and with the input set to "Straight" (i.e. no effects and flat).

Wayne
 
Back
Top Bottom