• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wes_in_VA's "frankenbucketsub" project

Wes_in_VA

Super Member
I started writing about this idea over in a thread about looking for bass augmentation for my Aiko speakers. I had been asking about ideas and wondering whether bucket subs would be good choice since they're easy to make and look like fun. I had been pondering ideas of how to do the project on the uber-cheap.
Here's what I posted in that thread about the genesis of this mad scientist idea of mine:

Okay, so crazy idea here:
My room is quite small so I'm thinking that 2 bucket subs using the Peerless 8" woofer would be overkill. One standard bucket sub probably not so good.
So here's where it gets crazy:
I love the performance of these little 6" woofers in the Epicure 11's that I've mentioned. It got me to thinking...
What about "mini buckets" using a 3 1/2 gallon bucket and the woofers from those Epicures??? (Yes, I've gone off the deep end...)
Those woofers were used in both ported and sealed enclosures so that's no problem.
The 11's were rated down to 38Hz which according to my ears is about right.
I think a 3 1/2 gallon enclosure is about the right size.
The truly crazy part is that I think I'll start out driving them with a pair of Eico HF20 monoblocks. Those have driven the Epicures well in the past so I think it's worth a shot, and soon the Eicos will be pulled out of my living room system living them feeling all lonely and unloved.
I have a Mini DSP on the way to began the mad experiment.

Please, don't call the padded van on me yet. I think this could be fun.

I've had a bit of time to start actually pondering the details of my madness.

First of all, I have two main goals with this: 1) I want to learn and 2) I want to have fun.
I'm actually pretty thrilled with the sound of my system right now, so if this ends up being better than what I have so be it.
Since learning is #1 on that list, please, comment, educate me.

I started looking into the TS parameters of the recommended Peerless driver for the bucket subs versus the numbers that Human Speakers provide for their replacement driver for the 6" woofer in the Epicure 11. (I couldn't find numbers on the original so this is the best I can do.)
First thing I realized is that my guess that the 3 1/2 gallon bucket would be good was way way way off. The volume numbers for the Peerless versus the Epicure driver were actually pretty close with the Epicure needing slightly larger. I'll stick with the 5 gallon buckets.
The other numbers are pretty good for these Epicures, as I understand them...and I may be WAY off in my understanding, so educate me at your will.
The Epicures have a lower Fs at 32Hz vs 42 Hz for the Peerless.
The Epicures are more sensitive: 89 vs 86
Total Q of the Epi's is .55 vs .66

With my very limited understanding of all this, it seems to me that this project is worth a try even if the only goal is better sound. Whether my thinking that the smaller driver of the Epicure woofer is better suited to my small room I have on idea. That thinking could be horribly flawed but I'm okay with that. Life has taught me that we're lucky if only 49% of our thinking is flawed. :D

My Mini DSP shipped yesterday and I should see that late this week or early next. I'll pick up the buckets and other materials this week and build the subs this weekend. I'll post updates along the way.

I'm mad, I tell you, MAD!! Bwah hah hah hah hah!!

attachment.php
 
Register to hide this ad
For the first time in a long time, I got spend some quality time in my listening room. I spun several album sides which is something I haven't had the time to do in a while: lately it's been a few songs or one side if I'm really lucky.
This is with my system consisting of the setup in my signature plus a single Epicure 11 powered by a plate amp from a cheap HT sub. The Epicure is actually immediately behind my listening chair simply because that was convenient at the time I set that up. The sub kicks in at 80Hz IIRC.

I listened to:
Strength in Numbers-The Telluride Sessions
Miles Davis-Agharta
Allman Bros-Live at Fillmore East

Here's why I'm posting all this in this thread about my frankenbucketsub project:

My setup seriously kicks a** to my ears.

I sat there and just enjoyed the hell out of the music. I can't imagine it getting much better which is why it relates to this thread: I think my project has a tough row to hoe to beat the way things are now.
 
I've been moving along with this project very slowly. I finally got a chance to assemble the buckets and get the concrete poured.
While that's curing I decided to also paint them so they'll look all fancy and stuff. I went with a nice gloss red...since that's what I had laying around in the way of spray paint. It also happens to go pretty well in my listening room. Pics soon.
 
Yeah, yeah, I know: I need a new camera

So the pis of the actual sub kind of stink. I know it. My nice camera died and I've been spending all of my spare cash on vinyl. Can you blame me?
Anyway, here are some pics of the subs (actually only one) as they stand now:

attachment.php


attachment.php


You'll notice that the driver is just resting on the top. I haven't gotten the binding posts yet, so for now the drivers are just rough fit. These are really just to show how the red buckets came out. I dig 'em. The wife says there's still no way in hell these will ever live upstairs in our living room. :D

Here's some info on the drivers I'm using, or at least as close as I can get. My drivers are original Epicure 11's and the info is on the Human Speakers replacement. I'm posting this info as any justification other than I saw some specs that were close enough that I figured what the hell. If anyone wants to comment on how these drivers will really--at least on paper--stack up performance-wise, please do. I won't take offense. This project has been about having fun and using stuff I had around as much as anything. (The driver recommended for this project is the Peerless on the right)

attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • photo-16room 29.jpg
    photo-16room 29.jpg
    84.1 KB · Views: 201
  • room.jpg
    room.jpg
    95.8 KB · Views: 200
  • specs.jpg
    specs.jpg
    60.1 KB · Views: 197
I've been having a hard time getting this project finished but it all finally came to fruition early this week.
I got the 2nd sub finished up last weekend and then finally got a chance to play with the Mini DSP. I have to say the software is super easy to use, and the support on their website (including the forums) is fantastic. In fact, it was so easy I thought I was doing things wrong!

Anyway, I don't have everything dialed in placement-wise or looks-wise so no pics for now and no detailed thoughts. Suffice it to say that I'm happy, particularly considering the money I spent (less than $225 including the Mini DSP and the 78" interconnects I needed to buy)
 
Why just the other day at work I came across some real thick green plastic/fiberglass pipe. Not sure what it was used for. I thought about you and your posts about bucket subs as I was loading a piece of that pipe in the back of my truck! It's about 30"-36" long. And will easily house a 12" sub. I wish it was big enough for one of my 15" Eminence subs though.
 
Ya'll thought I abandoned this thread, didn't you??

Nope. Just too damn busy to spend much time listening or posting thoughts.

I've had a good chance to ply with the location of the subs and I think I'm okay with where they are as a valid starting point.
For now I'm running the Aikos full range and using the Mini DSP as a low-pass filter with the buckets coming in 110Hz with a 48dB/octave slope. I chose that simply because it seemed to make sense for augmenting the Fostex drivers which have a stated low-freq response of 80Hz and an in-room response something like 60Hz.
I'm running the Aikos full range since I absolutely love their sound and hate to think of changing it for the worse, but I'll be messing around with taking some of the low freq heat off of them sometime...just not now.

attachment.php


I'm very happy with how this has worked out. The Aikos were just barely lacking to my ears, so the paired buckets with the little Epicure woofers has done the trick. I can see where having amps that can control the woofers a bit better would be an improvement but I love the sound with Eicos driving them and for now can't imagine feeling a need to invest in anything else.
The bass is not room-shaking, and that's not what I wanted. With the music I listen to most--acoustic stuff, jazz and bluegrass mostly--it's really very nice. The bass is quite realistic, as if you're sitting 10th row center instead of 3rd row. I like that; it's easy to just get lost.
 

Attachments

  • buckets.jpg
    buckets.jpg
    65 KB · Views: 108
I've got a 32gal. trash can that the top has crumbled to pieces. If I can work on that without the wife catching on....
You guys are a bad influence.
 
Wes,
I finally finished my Aiko build and I've got a pair of foster fe-103's in them. They are quite a cabinet. I ran them alone for a while, but then coupled them with a LF speaker and am quite satisfied. They are such treats to listen to!!!!! Thanks so much for sharing your story with them. I will be experimenting with bi-amping for the LF and keeping the Aiko's on tubes! Keep us posted on how things develop.
 
Back
Top Bottom