• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

5.1 or 7.1?

I am currently looking for a sound system for when I go to college next year along with my room for about a year. 37"-42" LCD, would like 7.1 but they are kind of pricy.

What kind of brands should I look at.
And what sites for good deals on new sets should I look at?
Thanks!

Will be watching movies and playing ps3 on this!
 
Register to hide this ad
I cant imagine any but the richest college kids having a room large enough to actually need 7.1 let alone be able to take true advantage of its benefit, I am in a 14X24 room and its barely justifiable. I would get a cheaper used 5.1 and let the market go through its growing pains while you focus on school, when you get out god only knows what will be out there and even todays truely hi-end gear will be for a song used. I have been burned by premature purchase in my youth so I hope to save others from putting the cart before the horse.
 
5.1 is the better (and cheaper) investment, mostly for the fact you will be playing PS3. I have yet to see any game support 7.1.

That being said, most receivers, even budget ones support 7.1 now, just make sure you get one with HDMI that will actually decode audio from HDMI.
 
well im in no way rich, Im paying through best buy, no interest paid off in 2 years, id say range is 1200-1500

that being said, the tv will be 800-1200

so around 300-400 for surround sound, my room most likely will not be big enough for 7.1, but I mean why not? I wont have to upgrade when I get out, but I assume its cheaper as said

:)

so any suggestions on brands and set ups you recommend
 
Sometimes folks confuse true 7.1 support with actual benefit in performance, the surround info is matrixed and sent to the additional surrounds from any digital 5.1 source so there is a definite benefit on any Dolby Digital 5.1 material and more so for the ES encoded material.
Yes there isnt really any "true" 7.1 material but that doesnt mean you wont get a fantastic 7.1 experience that is a step up for 5.1, but its a question of space in the room.............you cant get around a small room not really ideal or pracitcal for 7.1 use.
 
I agree that 7.1 channels is not a mandatory thing.

The sound difference between 5.1 and 7.1 is not huge. Yes, it's audible and 7.1 is better, but 5.1 is darned great.

The problem with setting up a system with more channels is that you then have to spread your budget even thinner to afford speakers for every one of those channels. I'd MUCH rather have great speakers in a 5.1 configuration, than OK speakers in a 7.1 config.

As far as surround receiver suggestions go... Of the mass-market brands, I would stick with: Denon, Onkyo, Pioneer, Yamaha, Marantz. Everything else is not worth bothering with. Denon is my personal favorite.
 
If I could sound like an old man then please understand when I say

IF YOU DONT HAVE CASH DONT BUY IT!!!!!! Your making a potential mistake that too many younger folks make, we all like nice stuff but credit is debt and at this point in your life thats the last thing you need. If for any number of reason you cant or wont pay it off in time (and too many think they will and dont so dont take offense) you will be paying for an obsolete piece of gear for a long time and at a much higher price than original MSRP.
Its your life and do what you want but its way to early to start out with one foot in the mud, especially for something that in college you dont really need.

OK so anyway, good luck with whatever you decide, sounds like your set on 7.1 regardless of room size...................enjoy!
 
You're going to have a heck of a time putting together a decent 5.1 or 7.1 system for $300-$400.

Of course, "decent" is relative to expectations and previous experience.

I really can't think of any recommendations at that price level for a complete system except to shop around for some used stuff. If you're buying new, even the better HTIB setups eclipse that budget by a fair margin, and just a new receiver that does HDMI repeating will essentially suck up the whole amount.
 
To the poster above, I am in no shape of form already set on 7.1
I'm not looking for this "top of the line" system out of the gate.

and Im making enough money that I can set aside each week for car troubles/insurance, etc. and then some disposable income (smaller than the other group) but enough each month to make the payments!

I remember I was told dont get a whole "set" system, get a good receiver and then different speakers, but Im still listening to ideas.

I just know I want some sort of surround sound, even if its used, to take down to college
 
Consider the Pioneer VSX-817-S from Amazon for $140. It's 7.1, 110W/chan, has auto-calibrarion and -equalization for 5 bands. (Contrary to what was said above, you do not need to use all channels -- only two, the Left and Right. All else is optional.)
 
so do what do you recommend I get new (warranties and such) or what do you recommend I get used?

Ive extended (due to birthday money) the range from 700$
 
I'd put more money into the speakers then, you could always upgrade electronics later. I'd just get a decent 5.1 receiver (haven't owned one so I can't make recommendations), and build a set of speakers for it.

A couple of these: http://zaphaudio.com/BAMTM.html would be a good little setup for games and movies.
 
Yes, speakers more important. Find a receiver on craigslist. Well, you can buy speakers on CL, too, but my point is you don't have to go to Best Box and buy the latest doo dad.
 
If I could sound like an old man then please understand when I say

IF YOU DONT HAVE CASH DONT BUY IT!!!!!! Your making a potential mistake that too many younger folks make, we all like nice stuff but credit is debt and at this point in your life thats the last thing you need. If for any number of reason you cant or wont pay it off in time (and too many think they will and dont so dont take offense) you will be paying for an obsolete piece of gear for a long time and at a much higher price than original MSRP.
Its your life and do what you want but its way to early to start out with one foot in the mud, especially for something that in college you dont really need.

OK so anyway, good luck with whatever you decide, sounds like your set on 7.1 regardless of room size...................enjoy!

Couldn't agree more. I'm 35, and have just paid off my school-supply/car repair/eating out credit card from grad school. Almost everything on it was long gone, but the bill remained. It was mostly stuff I had to have to live, as I couldn't work and go to the school was I was going to due to the workload of classwork, but not all of it was, and later on, when I actually had money, it was no fun paying off my already-gone Sony pro-logic receiver that was out of date the moment my dolby digital hit maybe a year later. But I NEEDED surround sound.

With that out of the way...there are a bunch of used, formerly top-of-the-line 5.1 receivers on Craiglist, at least in my area. I would bet that a number of these would simply blow away a similarly priced new one. Not because old is better, but because much of what has been added to the surround-sound scene has been gimmicks. Blu-ray might be changing that fact, but until that all gets settled, I wouldn't be putting a lot of eggs in any surround-sound basket. Just my opinion of course. Perhaps it's already settled...I got bored with surround sound a couple of years ago and would gladly put my 2.0 system against 95% of the surround sound systems out there:D
 
Back
Top Bottom