• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Amp/speaker switch - DIY

To clarify: Is the recommendation to put a 100-150 ohm resistor across each amp's output (for example + and - on the amp's speaker wire socket) permanently so that it acts as a dummy load and protects the amp (specifically its output transformers) when the amp is on but speakers are not connected to it? But when the speakers are connected, the effects of these resistors are negligible and they can be left in place, no need to disconnect them?

I understand that these resistors can be incorporated on the switch side, but the amp side is more convenient as this way they only work with the tube amp and not any amp connected to the switchbox (or the input of the switchbox to which they are added).
The dummy loads are a good idea. I have not done this, but I always leave the preamp turned down all the way when I am not using it. So if I forget to change the switch, and I have many times now, as I turn it up slowly and nothing comes out, I stop immediately and correct the situation. As long as you don't crank it up high, no damage happens.
 
Can I chime in on this thread?

I just ordered a box that switches between 2 amps and 2 pairs of speakers.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B077JZFPR8/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o02_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Here is the inside:

IMG_3321.JPG IMG_3324.JPG
speaker switchbox.jpg

To me, it looks like there are just two DPDT switches. I can't figure out how it can work with only 12 contacts on the switches, and 16 binding posts?

and to reference the circuit diagram from someone else's post, pins 2 and 5 are connected to the same pins on the other switch.

Can anyone make sense of this?
 
I presume it is done that way by using common ground and switching just the "hots".

Like this, switching hots, with some arrangement (not shown) for common/unswitched grounds.

DPDT-2-in-2-out.png
 
Last edited:
Is there any downside to using common ground?

Almonds, with solid state common ground amps, no problem WHATSOEVER.

Actually, the switch you have is NOT common ground as we normally think of common ground. It ties all grounds together on the left and right channels, but does not tie the left and right ground together.

So is there a potential problem with this scheme? Yes, there is and a very big problem if you attempt to hook a non-common ground tube amp up to this switch.

Regards,
Jerry
 
I can see why they used DPDT and not 4PoleDT.. the price difference at my local parts supplier is like $2 vs $30 for the heavy duty 15 amp versions. I wonder if this is necessary. 200 watts into 4 ohms is only 7 amps.
 
Last edited:
there is and a very big problem if you attempt to hook a non-common ground tube amp up to this switch

Or a non-common ground class D amp. Or any amp that is susceptible to interference. Or is British. Basically this switch is not something I would want in my system. Even my Harman/Kardon HK6550 (a regular solid state amp) would sometimes go into protection when I tried a switch like that. It worked perfectly fine with the no common ground switch I made.

And they charge $99 for a switch that doesn't even have separated ground? To me this Nobsound is another switch that has nice enclosure and binding posts, but doesn't have what really matters.

the price difference at my local parts supplier is like $2 vs $30 for the heavy duty 15 amp versions

Look for a different supplier. I pay less than $4 for a 6A 250Vac 4PDT in a local store. But they're on ebay too.
 
Last edited:
Could anyone link me a switch that would allow for a dummy load when the amp is not connected to the loudspeaker? I want to switch between two amps and a single pair of loudspeakers.

Thanks!
 
Could anyone link me a switch that would allow for a dummy load when the amp is not connected to the loudspeaker? I want to switch between two amps and a single pair of loudspeakers.

Thanks!


I found it! What is needed is a 4PDT on-on-on (interestingly it's a three positions dual throw). I found switches from OTTO and NKK. I'll attach the files from the two manufacturers.

OTTO: K3xx1Mxx-xx (the x's are other parameters). One switch for channel is required. This is a rocker switch and seems similar to the one used on the switch box from www.homehifi.co.uk TC7210 that has a dummy load.

https://www.otto-controls.com/products/electromechanicalswitches/rockerswitches/k3sealedrocker

NKK: Toggle switch from the M series. M2044xxyy where xx is a parameter for toggle and yy is for brushings. Also one for channel is needed and separate dummy loads for each amp is possible.

https://www.nkkswitches.com/products/toggle/m-series-miniature-toggle-switches/#gref

These are all industrial switches, not the cheapest but reliable.

Regarding tube or valve amps, the problem is the output impedance matching transformers. These are, after all, inductors. From the equations, v=L(di/dt), or voltage equals inductance times the derivative of the current flowing through the inductor. When a loudspeaker is removed, the current goes from some value to zero almost immediately - and that produces a high value for the derivative and therefore a high voltage pulse on the output. This is the reason why I think the 100 to 150 ohm resistors should be connected to the input and not the output.

I must note that my observation are made from a safety point of view - specially safety for the amps! I'd always use dummy loads even with solid state amps and separate grounds. If I use a tube amp, I'd always put the ~100 ohms dummy load on the input. People who don't know these details will be using my sound gear and I always try to do things fool-proof. Also, I live in Brazil and what you pay for an amp I pay just for shipping!

Hope I could contribute to the discussion.
 
can anyone give me link for 100 to 150 ohm resistors and also where exactly to put the resister on the tubeamp ? I am planning to build A/B speaker but I am lost on the resister part. TY
 
And no loading but was only switching SS receivers with no adverse affects.
Mite be a diff story with tubes.

I didn't add loading for unconnected amps because I don't use tube amps, solid state only.

It's worth noting that even some SS amps require loading of some sort. The H-K 330B, for example, specifically mentions this in the OM. I'm guessing that this might be relevant to capacitor-coupled outputs, like the Marantz 1060.

330B_segment.jpg

By the way . . . there's something kinda comical about how they've worded that. If you don't plan to ever use it in stereo . . . go ahead and blow the other channel? :dunno:
 
I realize this is an older thread, but no less useful. I put one of these into a 4" wooden pencil holder, but ended up designing a back cover for it. If for nothing else, I couldn't find any other suitable materials laying around the house lol

3D printers are getting increasingly accessible, so in the odd chance this is useful to anyone else, here we go https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:4184642
 
I realize this is an older thread, but no less useful. I put one of these into a 4" wooden pencil holder, but ended up designing a back cover for it. If for nothing else, I couldn't find any other suitable materials laying around the house lol

3D printers are getting increasingly accessible, so in the odd chance this is useful to anyone else, here we go https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:4184642


Yes lots of possibilities with 3d printers. My son has one... and I have already built a few things,. Not audio related yet but I will probably make something for my SA9500 speaker binding posts.
 
Back
Top Bottom