• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Anti-massive cabinet mods???

Copa1934

My ears are bleeding
Ok, so posts have been "...port the good drivers to a larger cabinet..." "...extend the back/front of the cabinet...." "...add a port to the cabinet..." and on and on. Obviously many of these ideas, and more, are sensible and practical, etc., however there are people, myself including wondering "are there less conspicuous ways of doing this?

Many of the mods, obviously, are for improvements like extending bass response, knowing of course there may be adverse affects.

So, have any of the following mods ever been approached and how successful were they?

1. Add volume by way of the speaker terminal opening. Remove terminals, extend into outboard enclosure, relocating terminals into outboard enclosure. Since the enclosure will in a sense be hidden (from front view) and the enclosure and be modified at length for volume with no impact on the "main" enclosure AND no extensive mods may be required of the terminal opening, seems like a viable option to retain original box?

2. Knock holes in base of cabinet, mount onto additional volume made to look/appear like a speaker stand using PVC or other pipe material to join enclosures. The massive mod would be limited to just the base of the cabinet and can be reversed (if one chose to do so).

Again, these mods are meant for someone who might want to keep the original cabinets, for whatever reason, but not subject too many visible mods.
 
Register to hide this ad
Ok, so posts have been "...port the good drivers to a larger cabinet..." "...extend the back/front of the cabinet...." "...add a port to the cabinet..." and on and on. Obviously many of these ideas, and more, are sensible and practical, etc., however there are people, myself including wondering "are there less conspicuous ways of doing this?

Many of the mods, obviously, are for improvements like extending bass response, knowing of course there may be adverse affects.

So, have any of the following mods ever been approached and how successful were they?

1. Add volume by way of the speaker terminal opening. Remove terminals, extend into outboard enclosure, relocating terminals into outboard enclosure. Since the enclosure will in a sense be hidden (from front view) and the enclosure and be modified at length for volume with no impact on the "main" enclosure AND no extensive mods may be required of the terminal opening, seems like a viable option to retain original box?

2. Knock holes in base of cabinet, mount onto additional volume made to look/appear like a speaker stand using PVC or other pipe material to join enclosures. The massive mod would be limited to just the base of the cabinet and can be reversed (if one chose to do so).

Again, these mods are meant for someone who might want to keep the original cabinets, for whatever reason, but not subject too many visible mods.

I've done both on these JBL L200 cabinets to add ~3/4 cu ft. The rear extension is actually to accomodate the longer L300 horn, but adds some volume. The bottoms were done by cutting out the existing bases with a sawzall, extending the old pedistal with a piece of 1" x 2" enclosing the new bottom, and adding 3/4" "skids" under the new bases. This also raises the tweeters to the proper ear level and reduces floor bounce boom from the woofers. In the second pic you can see that I had already raised the bases (to clear the bricks around the fireplace), but had not enclosed them. The old base line is fairly evident due to the glare from the flash.

New_Revised_L200.jpg


You can compare how much height was added:
DSC_0069.jpg

Revised_L200_v4430.jpg


H92_The_Build011.jpg
 
Last edited:
OK, so, did you design the base to angle back as well (not sure from the images). More importantly, did it make a difference?

If you didn't know JBL well you probably wouldn't be the wiser. Looks cool.
 
OK, so, did you design the base to angle back as well (not sure from the images). More importantly, did it make a difference?

If you didn't know JBL well you probably wouldn't be the wiser. Looks cool.

1) No, the L200 cabinets already have that angle above the pedistals.
speaker1.jpg


2) Yes, it helped the bass. The L300 cabinets actually have about 1/2 - 3/4 cu ft more internal volume than the L200 cabinets. When the L200 cabinets were first designed, they were not intended for the 136A/2234/2235 foam woofers. The L300 cabinets always were and the increased volume seems better suited to my AlNiCo "2235" replacement woofers.

Also, the L200 cabinets are known to have "internal dimensional" problems and this seems to help that also.
 
http://www.ai-audio.com/home.html

I've thought about applying this idea to DIY bookshelfs, hiding the external ports as part of the 'speaker stand'.
One of the arguments against this is loss of power handling, but for me power handling isn't as much an issue as getting more bottom end. Some speakers, of course, won't benefit in the least, but where they do it's worth the effort. And if for the most part it can be concealed all the better.
 
Just a question. If you increase the volume of a ported cabinet like a JBL for instance, do you not have to increase the length and/or diameter of the port? For acoustic suspension, the increased volume should have direct improvements up to a point.
 
Just a question. If you increase the volume of a ported cabinet like a JBL for instance, do you not have to increase the length and/or diameter of the port? For acoustic suspension, the increased volume should have direct improvements up to a point.
Based on other posts I would think your logic makes sense with ported systems. As for the AS systems depends on whether or not the volume was correct from the beginning. My Mach One's have a Q (QTS?) that is too high for the size cabinet it's in. It is believed that this was done for probably a number of reasons, one of which is more power handling. I don't need that since they are too efficient for my needs, i.e. I'm out of the room before the volume is turned half way up, and that's on my Yamaha. I'm not even going there with my Fisher.

I have spare cabinets to experiment with. I've been holding off due to a post that is/was supposed to be made by Videolady201 in the Mach One thread. Unfortunately VL's whereabouts are unknown and haven't made a post in some time. Personally I'm growing concerned as VL has had some health issues, so I hope that VL is OK.

Anyway, I was doing research separate from that thread in case the mods aren't posted or as an option if I choose not to use the posted mods.
 
Back
Top Bottom