• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

AR XA arm damping question

gadget73

junk junkie
Subscriber
I'm doing some research on my recently acquired AR XA, and it seems the standard answer to tonearm damping is "remove it". It just seems to me a lot of effort went into building and implementing this feature. Is it truly that badly done that it works better without it, or is disabling it just easier than trying to replicate the teeny-tiny degraded foam washer that makes it work? I'm willing to try fixing it but only if its got a chance of working OK.
 
Register to hide this ad
I'm doing some research on my recently acquired AR XA, and it seems the standard answer to tonearm damping is "remove it". It just seems to me a lot of effort went into building and implementing this feature. Is it truly that badly done that it works better without it, or is disabling it just easier than trying to replicate the teeny-tiny degraded foam washer that makes it work? I'm willing to try fixing it but only if its got a chance of working OK.


That foam piece under the delrin washer on the pivot post is really a non issue here. The brass barrel in the pivot boss was supposed to be filled with 300,000 CST as a way to control drop until a certain level was achieved and then it would disable itself. It didn't work well as nobody refilled the device.
The pin that is in the brass barrel was to hold it in place while the outer boss roated around it. Without it riding on a film of heavy silicone, it binds against the brass barrel. Forcing you to adjust the pivot pins to a lower friction ( loose) That makes for a pretty rattle trap pivot assembly.
This is how I cure the problem, others have their ways. I fuse the brass barrel to the pivot boss in the position it would be in during play. ie flat side centered in the down position. I remove the delrin pivot cups and replace with sapphire V jewel cups. I polish the pivot pins through hand lapping to about a 1 micron finish at point. I fill the V cups with a heavy viscosity grease and set the pins to about 10mg of "friction". This makes for a very responsive arm. About the only type of vertical pivoted arm with lower (reactive)friction in that plain is a unipivot.
 
So can I simply clean the brass barrel off and refil it with the proper 300k silicone oil to restore proper damping, or is it still sort of a POS? I need to buy some of that oil to repair the damping on another table I have, so it wouldn't be a big matter to use it in two places instead of one.


I may consider upgrading the arm pivot bearings at some point, but at the moment I want to just get it operating decently first, probably in a very near-stock configuration. This is turntable #7 for me at the moment, so I'm not looking to spend big bucks on it unless I just fall in love with the thing.
 
...so I'm not looking to spend big bucks on it unless I just fall in love with the thing.

You'll be hard pressed not to and if you have Marc do some of his upgrades it will be almost guaranteed:yes:. I had him do an arm and got the spring perches. Love it...but then I've had it since 1971. Preston
 
truthfully half of why I got this was to compare it to my TD-160 since they are similarly designed tables. Thus far, the AR is grossly less complex than the Thorens. The arm is something mere mortals can actually take apart and work on. I will say I am not fond of having to pop the platter and shuffle the belt to do 45's, but considering I own exactly one 45 rpm record, thats not exactly a problem for me.
 
I will also add that you will not do the table justice trying to use the damping system as originaly intended:no:.

Before I had Marc work his magic on my AR's arm, I removed the pin, foam washer and delrin disk. It was an improvement...not as much as Marc's mods, which I respectively suggest you consider. Preston
 
I found years ago that pulling it apart and cleaning the old lube of and renewing it goes a long way. Pivot adjustment is critical and by this time I can not imagine any originals are not worn. Replacement is relatively easy.

While looking almost like a Rube Goldberg special, these arms when properly setup work rather well. Biggest shortcoming is lack of anti-skating that would not be a technological advancement for a couple of years. My old tech in my store used to use the wiring in a makeshift anti-skate by shifting it from being centered.
 
So can I simply clean the brass barrel off and refil it with the proper 300k silicone oil to restore proper damping, or is it still sort of a POS? I need to buy some of that oil to repair the damping on another table I have, so it wouldn't be a big matter to use it in two places instead of one.


I may consider upgrading the arm pivot bearings at some point, but at the moment I want to just get it operating decently first, probably in a very near-stock configuration. This is turntable #7 for me at the moment, so I'm not looking to spend big bucks on it unless I just fall in love with the thing.

Trying to get the arm to work as originally designed isn't going to work. AR on the later model XA's came with a pivot post that didn't have that contraption . AR also "up-graded" existing arms by changing the pivot post/vertical bearing assembly. Even the change of post didn't address the total issue of the vertical bearings/pins. Those delrin cups are probably not very round, and I bet have little chunks of the contact area of the pin embedded in it. The pins even in original condition were of poor polish and surface structure. PM me for additional information, or contact me via email.
BaMorin@AOL.com

Marc
 
Trying to get the arm to work as originally designed isn't going to work. AR on the later model XA's came with a pivot post that didn't have that contraption . AR also "up-graded" existing arms by changing the pivot post/vertical bearing assembly. Even the change of post didn't address the total issue of the vertical bearings/pins. Those delrin cups are probably not very round, and I bet have little chunks of the contact area of the pin embedded in it. The pins even in original condition were of poor polish and surface structure. PM me for additional information, or contact me via email.

Marc

Marc - re the upgrade to existing arms you mention here. Did that do away with the brass barrel arrangement and just have a rectangular block that held the delrin cups and a post that is attached (not screwed) into the block?

Thanks
 
Marc - re the upgrade to existing arms you mention here. Did that do away with the brass barrel arrangement and just have a rectangular block that held the delrin cups and a post that is attached (not screwed) into the block?

Thanks
yep, exactly
 
Thanks - given a choice which I now have is it better to go with the upgrade version? Any issues with it?
 
Thanks - given a choice which I now have is it better to go with the upgrade version? Any issues with it?
if it's still of the original build, delrin inserts, taper pin, it's not real accurate. it however has less things to rattle around with free play than the original pivot system.
 
The damping in the AR arm was designed back in the day when cartridges typically tracked in the 2-4g range. Even when new, it was problematic with tracking numbers under 2g, and the closer you got to 1g, the worse it got.
 
The design is from 1962-63. There were lower tracking cartridges at the time, but a lot of them had issues at the lower end of their ranges, which is why so many people pulled the pins on their arms.
 
I'm new to this forum and the XA, so please be kind ...
Does anyone know where I can find some photos or step-by-step details for servicing the tone arm? I've recently cleaned and reassembled the post and vertical barrel assembly, but I'm not convinced that I've done the job completely.

What I've Done:
- Removed, cleaned and lubricated (Super Lube - synthetic multi purpose) the platter and tone arm posts
- Cleaned both of the post wells ... There were little clumps of tape at the bottom of the tone arm post, presumably there to elevate the tone arm to accommodate a retro-fitted Stanton EEE cartridge w/ attached brush?
- Disassembled, cleaned and lubricated the outer surfaces of the barrel assembly.
- Cleaned belt contact surfaces on the platter and motor drive wheel
- I replaced the tape in the tone arm well with a .219 ball bearing and replaced the head shell and and cartridge with an original head shell and an ADC 250XE cartridge ... I simply took these items off another XA that I recently purchased.

Concerns
- I'm sure I didn't "refill" anything with 300k high viscosity oil
- The tone arm does not lift smoothly when the post is completely threaded into the assembly, I've backed it off just a fraction of a turn to achieve smooth movement
- I'm getting a ton of "flutter" or bounce at the needle, this can only be resolved by setting the counter weight quite close to the barrel assembly and removing any neutral balance of the tone arm
- There's a significant amount of noise coming through the system when I turn the volume up, while the tone arm is in the cradle

Any guidance or links to detailed information is certainly appreciated. I'm amazed by the depth of knowledge in this forum and I'm hopeful that some of it will rub off over time.
 
Welcome to AK! Definitely the place to be for AR expertise.

This is where I'm having a hard time finding the right words. Our foremost expert, Marc Morin, is battling a very serious illness at this moment and can no longer work on turntables. Forum members @StuartB (not Stuart B with a space, that's somebody else) and @Hose53 live near him and have been trying to learn as much from him as they can during repeated visits. I think they may have a backlog of requests right now as they try to be there for Marc and his family.

Most of Marc's contributions over the years are probably in the big AR thread:
https://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/offical-ar-turntable-owners-thread.595003/

The format is unwieldy, for sure, but at least the Search function in this forum works very well.

Other good sources, which have been up in one form or another for a looong time and cover the basics quite well:

http://johnsweather.com/Turntable.html (lots of pictures, the damping mod is about half way down the page)
http://www.laaudiofile.com/backissu.html (scan of a 1987 newsletter--this is what I followed over 20 years ago with my own AR, yes, it was already online back then!)
https://vinylnirvana.com/ar-turntable-resources
 
Funny this topic should come up, I actually plan to keep this tone arm drop damping to one of my AR's just to compare . But it will have the V jewel bearings .

I am doing just to see and or verify what was discussed here in the Vinyl engine post.

AR XA Tonearm reveals its secrets .

Some interesting theories here.

Athanasios
 
Welcome to AK! Definitely the place to be for AR expertise.

This is where I'm having a hard time finding the right words. Our foremost expert, Marc Morin, is battling a very serious illness at this moment and can no longer work on turntables. Forum members @StuartB (not Stuart B with a space, that's somebody else) and @Hose53 live near him and have been trying to learn as much from him as they can during repeated visits. I think they may have a backlog of requests right now as they try to be there for Marc and his family.

Most of Marc's contributions over the years are probably in the big AR thread:
https://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/offical-ar-turntable-owners-thread.595003/

The format is unwieldy, for sure, but at least the Search function in this forum works very well.

Other good sources, which have been up in one form or another for a looong time and cover the basics quite well:

http://johnsweather.com/Turntable.html (lots of pictures, the damping mod is about half way down the page)
http://www.laaudiofile.com/backissu.html (scan of a 1987 newsletter--this is what I followed over 20 years ago with my own AR, yes, it was already online back then!)
https://vinylnirvana.com/ar-turntable-resources

Thanks very much for the reply and information. My apologies for the delay in responding ... Things have been a bit unusual lately!

I'm familiar with Marc's health problems, it was certainly upsetting to read about his ongoing health issues. It's clear that he's a beloved member of the vintage audio world.

I'll be working my way through the links that you've both shared and see if I can't make sense of the issue(s) I'm running into.
 
I've been tinkering with yet another XA and refreshed the damping system just out of curiosity. It works, and I can see why it might have seemed a real positive to potential customers who worried about hand cuing. But it does depend on a couple of grams of tracking force to operate completely reliably without ever getting hung up, and it is somewhat cartridge height dependent. Obviously it introduces some compliance into what would, ideally, be a rigid path. It can be perfectly easily lived with, and it is remarkable how good the arm can sound even with it, but what Marc says about the bearings is obviously true.
When I was in college, many of my peers had them, and almost all of them had problems with the bearings - the delrin seems to stick a bit, and so over time the pins backed themselves out a bit, often to the point that the arm was sitting on the pivot block. When the owner screwed the pin back in, most often they missed the pivot hole and drove the pin into the side of the delrin. This actually worked - the material is soft enough that the pin makes its own bearing, but the angle was wrong and the friction was high. I fixed a lot of these, but my fix was simply to get the pin into the correct location. By then, of course, the hole was even less perfectly round since it was distorted by the previous mashing. None the less, we enjoyed listening to the tables - they were clearly better sounding than most of the competition.
Nowadays, of course, the competition has upped its game, and it has been made clear just how much better the AR can be with mods like those Marc offers.
 
Back
Top Bottom