• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Are "0 Feedback" (Solid State) Amps Better?

If You think zero feedback is difficult in SS amps, its impossible in Spouse's.
It's funny you said that. I'm home today because my AC went out last night and had to be here for the repairman. As soon as it was fixed (bad cap), My wife was giving me "feedback" about how I should be doing something else instead of trying to figure out this dual servo, unreturned, 0 feedback circuit stuff.
 
0 feedback - how do you do that? Even your speakers will feedback both electrically and as sound pressure waves. Maybe in outer space you could get some sort of linear gain system w/o feedback, but not down here :scratch2:
 
Here is my understanding of this. Bare in mind I do not have the technical knowledge EchoWars has. But I studied Japanese corporate culture and hold a BA in Sociology. Maybe my different aspect might contribute somewhat to this topic.

Here it goes.

Dr. Matti Otala never rejected NFB or promoted the hype about zero NFB as something inherently superior.

He and Harman were against badly designed Japanese amps from the 80s and 90s with large global NFB that sweep the rubbish under the carpet and hype with low THD figures.

Neither Harman or Dr. Otala made a zero feedback amp.

Ironically despite TIM, IIM and low NFB aimed against the Japanese manufacturers marketing once again those specs became their own challenge. Japanese manufacturers began making SS zero feedback amps with immense complexities, high slew rates, short rise times, huge damping factors, wide bandwidth etc etc.

If anyone knows anything about corporate structure and organizational culture in Japanese companies he should know why this was the case.

Doesn't matter how, specs and budget constrains given by management are like laws handed by God himself and need to be met by middle management and the workers at a given date. Period.

With corporate culture like that what do you expect except 0.00000001% THD into 4ohms, unpublished NFB specs, insufficiency output devices per channel, saturating little transformers, insufficiency capacitance banks and rubbish topologies. Yes the end result sucks in real life but make it sound good on paper so it sells.

Those were sweatshops such as the ones you find today in China. If the factory brigadier says we must have 1000 DF, then workers must produce it, does not matter how. No one must fail or consequences apply.

Much more different culture happened in special labs for special local market projects in Japan. There they had very flexible budgets, only the most knowledgeably circuit designers and no middle management to sweat all over the engineers blueprints.

Projects like the Pioneer CZ-1 were made in those labs. My Pioneer A-400 was made with one transistor pair per channel in the sweatshops. Some amps came out wonderful like the A400 and some were dreadful. Such mass production culture means inconsistencies in the product line.

Ever wondered why a 30WPC Naim sounds so powerful and composed compared to much bigger Japanese amps? Engineers at Naim even to that 30WPC amp made a regulated PSU. Which was something to lust about in most amps with double or triple the size from the Far East..

Was Harman trying to fight for its life on the US market? Yes. Were they fighting dirty? Yes.

Is Douglas Self onto something new and enlightening? No.

Thank you for reading the first half at least. :wave:
 
Last edited:
0 feedback - how do you do that? Even your speakers will feedback both electrically and as sound pressure waves. Maybe in outer space you could get some sort of linear gain system w/o feedback, but not down here :scratch2:

I have no problem with feedback that is inherent to a device, be it solid or hollow state. I just see no need to introduce "man made" negagative feedback, global or local.


This space for rent.
 
Nelson Pass's PassDIY site may also have some interesting articles about the evils of NFB. Many of his designs use little or no global NFB (i.e. going from the final amplification stage back to the first stage), though they usually use some form of local NFB (i.e. going from the end of one stage back to the beginning of that stage).

There is the opinion that amps (solid-state and tube) that use little NFB can more accurately track very complex and fast-changing signals, as whatever transient distortion is introduced by the NFB circuit is inconsequential to the output. Or, if you have no NFB, there is nothing to consider. Use of negative feedback also reduces the gain of a circuit compared to its open-loop gain (sometimes by half).

Many amps that claim not to use negative feedback do indeed use it. They simply do not used global NFB, but still use some local NFB.

Nelson Pass does indeed use global negative feedback:

http://www.firstwatt.com/j2.html

Ironically, one of the things the J2 is especially noted for is accurately reproducing very complex and fast-changing signals. The subject isn't quite as cut-and-dried as the anti-NFB crowd would have us believe.
 
Here is my understanding of this. Bare in mind I do not have the technical knowledge EchoWars has. But I studied Japanese corporate culture and hold a BA in Sociology. Maybe my different aspect might contribute somewhat to this topic.

Here it goes.

Dr. Matti Otala never rejected NFB or promoted the hype about zero NFB as something inherently superior.

He and Harman were against badly designed Japanese amps from the 80s and 90s with large global NFB that sweep the rubbish under the carpet and hype with low THD figures.

Neither Harman or Dr. Otala made a zero feedback amp.

Ironically despite TIM, IIM and low NFB aimed against the Japanese manufacturers marketing once again those specs became their own challenge. Japanese manufacturers began making SS zero feedback amps with immense complexities, high slew rates, short rise times, huge damping factors, wide bandwidth etc etc.

If anyone knows anything about corporate structure and organizational culture in Japanese companies he should know why this was the case.

Doesn't matter how, specs and budget constrains given by management are like laws handed by God himself and need to be met by middle management and the workers at a given date. Period.

With corporate culture like that what do you expect except 0.00000001% THD into 4ohms, unpublished NFB specs, insufficiency output devices per channel, saturating little transformers, insufficiency capacitance banks and rubbish topologies. Yes the end result sucks in real life but make it sound good on paper so it sells.

Those were sweatshops such as the ones you find today in China. If the factory brigadier says we must have 1000 DF, then workers must produce it, does not matter how. No one must fail or consequences apply.

Much more different culture happened in special labs for special local market projects in Japan. There they had very flexible budgets, only the most knowledgeably circuit designers and no middle management to sweat all over the engineers blueprints.

Projects like the Pioneer CZ-1 were made in those labs. My Pioneer A-400 was made with one transistor pair per channel in the sweatshops. Some amps came out wonderful like the A400 and some were dreadful. Such mass production culture means inconsistencies in the product line.

Ever wondered why a 30WPC Naim sounds so powerful and composed compared to much bigger Japanese amps? Engineers at Naim even to that 30WPC amp made a regulated PSU. Which was something to lust about in most amps with double or triple the size from the Far East..

Was Harman trying to fight for its life on the US market? Yes. Were they fighting dirty? Yes.

Is Douglas Self onto something new and enlightening? No.

Thank you for reading the first half at least. :wave:

This is the picture that the western hifi society wanted us to belive (so they could survive). Since the japanese hifi often where cheaper for the same specifications the european and americans had to come up with something else the answer was marketing of things that was difficult too measure, like musicality.
 
That's another bit of audiophile nonsense, though. The "musicality factor".

An amplifier is a technical device, not a musical instrument. It works based on electrical principles which have been known for years and years and which are based upon physics and those properties. The aim should be for it to reproduce a waveform coming into it at an amplified level, unchanged otherwise.

The "musicality" happens when this is accomplished at nearer and nearer perfection.

In my opinion, this musicality thing with audiophiles is merely an amplifier (or other reproduction devices) producing various forms of distortion that are pleasing to particular ears. It is not about accuracy at all.

Doug
 
Firstly to agree with Doug G. 'Musicality' is taste, therefore depending on what an amplifier or system adds that was not originally there. In that sense the possibilities are endless. But hi-fi started off as providing an output that was the exact replica of the input, irrespective of what it sounded like. In fact, the quality of sound has nothing to do with the quality of an amplifier - as Doug Self said. That is why the test is relatively easy: Compare the output to the input, and if the difference is inaudible, the goal has been achieved. (I use the term "inaudible"; presumably we are not talking of instrumentation amplifiers.)

Closer to the original question (and pardon some repetition), I am always somewhat irritated by generalisation. Just because there are examples of misuse of something, it does not mean that it may not be used. The example of mediocre designs slapped into some shape by a superfluety of nfb is well-known and sadly too often gracing our sound shops' shelves.

1. Nfb is the single most powerful tool available to the audio designer with which to achieve his goal.

2. It is impossible to design an audio amplifier with no audible distortion/artifacts, without some form of nfb. This is basic audio technology, irrespective of the status of whoever claims the opposite.

3. Because of the "power" of nfb though, it can easily also be the most abused tool in audio design (and sadly is). One does need to respect basics. (How many very effective medications contain elements which would be deadly in the wrong quantities? Does that make their correct application anathema?)

When this is recognised, I have no problem with whoever wants his amplifier with 10% distortion should that sound please him - it is his money and his privilege. (Thus then, my reply is not universally an answer to the OP. It depends on the design; anything is possible these days. But let us beware of basing principles on specific applications.)
 
Ironically, one of the things the J2 is especially noted for is accurately reproducing very complex and fast-changing signals. The subject isn't quite as cut-and-dried as the anti-NFB crowd would have us believe.
Read the third quoted paragraph in post #4. And my after-statement:
Lesson here is that what appears to be complex to us is just another signal to an amp. No biggie.

Four-year-old thread, ladies and gents.
 
Otalla mistakenly blamed NFB for TIM. Bob Corrdell set him straight way back in 1980, yet the NFB mythology persists to this day. Amazing.

Audio
February 1980

This article was published in Audio magazine in February, 1980 at the height of the controversy surrounding Transient Intermodulation Distortion and its relationship with negative feedback. The article discusses the origins of TIM and the transient nature of music that can bring it on. It points out that amplifiers with inadequate slew rate margin are the ones prone to TIM. Moreover, the article demonstrates that large amounts of negative feedback, when properly applied, do not in any way contribute to TIM. The bad rap that negative feedback gets to this day is largely a result of that misconception.

http://www.cordellaudio.com/papers/another_view_of_tim.shtml
 
So basically it is not valid that NFB produces TIM but it can hide bad designs that produce TIM and IIM. Blame the lazy designer/greedy manager, but not NFB as a tool.

Am I understanding this right?
 
Four-year-old thread, ladies and gents.

.... and yet myths are still perpetuated by self-appointed 'experts'. Thus confusion is kept alive enough to make it relevant for questions to be asked by those desirous of clarity.

Pandovski,

Yes - I would say that about sums it up.
 
.... and yet myths are still perpetuated by self-appointed 'experts'. Thus confusion is kept alive enough to make it relevant for questions to be asked by those desirous of clarity.

Pandovski,

Yes - I would say that about sums it up.

So back to my original point. The only difference between two well designed amplifiers, one with 60db, other with 12db of global NFB is that the 12db has nothing to hide. Does not mean it sounds better, its just reassurance for the buyer.

However...

There is also the fact some manufacturers will publish low global NFB but hide the fact they use massive local NFB to hide flawed circuitry, cost cutting etc.

These are marketing specs wars, has nothing to do with actual EE design.

Question.

Is it easier or more difficult to design a good amplifier with very little NFB? Or its the same as doing a large NFB design?
 
It is more difficult in that the amplifier before NFB has to be 'cleaner' (i.e. for the same "blamelessness" at the end).

Somewhat technical: One needs to keep in mind that as NFB increases there comes a point that total distortion is no longer reduced; harmonics of harmonics being generated etc. This is easily shown with the aid of a spectrum analyser. That is why the THD figure gets increasingly meaningless with a high NFB factor. An amplifier with 0,2% distortion consisting of only 2nd and some 3rd order components is far more acceptable than one with 0,02% distortion, consisting of a string of high order harmonic components.
 
Back
Top Bottom