• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Are my ears deceiving me?

HAL_0

Member
I have a Luxman R-3045 receiver and have recently connected up some Sony front speakers SS-L90VH. To check out the sound I played Jeff Beck's "Lilac Wine" from his Emotion and Commotion CD. The vocals by Imelda May sounded good to my ears and Jeff's guitar work wasn't bad either. I know these are budget speakers but how much better sound can I expect from speakers costing hundreds of dollars more? Are these two matched up pretty well or are my ears just deceiving me?
 
Register to hide this ad
I know nothing about those speakers, but I do know that using words to describe sound, or how much better something might sound, is problematic. You will never really know without listening to other speakers. But once you do that, you may immediately want to upgrade, so that's a risky experiment. If it sounds good to you and you're not the kind of person who's always looking to upgrade, you might want to call it good until lightning strikes, in the form of better speakers that you may eventually run across.
 
Beauty is in the eye of the beholdes.

In spite of all the talking, arguing, specs and graphs, nothing is more decisive than what sounds good to your own ears.

If you like 'em, keep 'em, at least until you find something that's more satisfying and don't worry about what others say or think.

I dunno about you, or ayone else here, but i'm into this hobby for a system that pleases me, not to impress anyone else.
 
Glad your happy with the sound from your new system. Keep in mind, that most the people here have quite a bit of experince and have been there done that so sometimes advice from someone who has many years of experince regarding what consititutes a good system, speaks from knowledge based on past experince. Perhaps you found a good combination on your first try, but perhaps, it just because your put your feet in the pond of what is just the start of experiencing audio thats better than just some junky radio in a garage. Your set up although sounds good to you now, yet as you get more involved with really good audio equipment in the future you might find that your selection now, really was not that great compaired what your future sound system might be like. Just kind of thinking out loud based on my past experince.
 
In spite of all the talking, arguing, specs and graphs, nothing is more decisive than what sounds good to your own ears.

If you like 'em, keep 'em, at least until you find something that's more satisfying and don't worry about what others say or think.

I dunno about you, or anyone else here, but i'm into this hobby for a system that pleases me, not to impress anyone else.

Amen to that. I don't mind having gear that others think is crap or somehow, less than. I get much enjoyment out of my gear and wouldn't change a thing....until I see yet another piece I can't live without. :D
 
There are a lot of decent speakers out there that have no following at all and people will say "Oh....those were cheapo component POS's." or "That brand had fallen off so far by the time they made these." etc.... I have a later pair of "kabuki" Marantz that sound maybe not as good as my better stuff, but heck.....they sound good! If you like a sound that is all that matters. We can all get caught up in tech,model numbers and brands. (Very important for me.) In the end it is all about the music and the fact your enjoying the......MUSIC! (And most of us would enjoy it right along with you saying "Those things don't sound half bad????) Enjoyment always needs to trump the BS. A lot of folks do have "ears" and a solid comparison/critique is why they are into this...no prisoners. (That IS a "right"....but just one.) Some days a grilled cheese and tomato soup taste almost as good as "filet"....no apologies and no prisoners there either.
 
Last edited:
True, and I know people listening on their big horn, mono phonograph a hundred years weren't complaining about the sound reproduction, but rather they were kicken' it old, old school.
 
So your impression of the SS-L90VH is that they are better than... not using any speakers? I don't understand the question.
 
I'll throw in my two cents here.

When you say a couple hundred dollars, are you talking new or used? With used a couple hundred dollars could mean speakers that originally sold for thousands of dollars.. and let me tell you, it makes a big difference there! The cabinets are like the room you sit in in terms of how it affects the sound coming out. Of course the drivers and design do too but I think you get what I mean. I would look into speaker design and how they're made, and how a drivers specifications affect the way a speaker enclosure is made.

That kind of understanding really helped me to understand different types of speakers and what sort of impact they would have on the sound, what speakers were good for what sized rooms and all sorts of good information. Although it's very difficult to quantify sound, it's possible to at least get your own understanding of the way sound works and what you prefer.

In regards to your comments about the budget speakers, money in the audio world when it comes to used gear means nothing. I found a set of speakers at a thrift store for $8 and they sound VERY nice. A good matching amp to a good matched set of speakers will do a world of wonder to the sound performance. Sounds like you have a good match. With that amp though you have room to improve if you wanted to change the speakers out.

So in a nutshell it CAN make a big difference or it can't.. finding the speakers or solutions that do make that big difference require some fundamental understanding of how acoustics work and that can go a long ways to achieving your musical nirvana without experimenting with tons and tons of different equipment and spending tons of money (which is what it sounds like to me you are trying to avoid). Of course there's nothing wrong with experimenting, but if you have a budget to keep then it might not be a bad idea to do more research vs. experimenting. :)
 
Glad your happy with the sound from your new system. Keep in mind, that most the people here have quite a bit of experince and have been there done that so sometimes advice from someone who has many years of experince regarding what consititutes a good system, speaks from knowledge based on past experince. Perhaps you found a good combination on your first try, but perhaps, it just because your put your feet in the pond of what is just the start of experiencing audio thats better than just some junky radio in a garage. Your set up although sounds good to you now, yet as you get more involved with really good audio equipment in the future you might find that your selection now, really was not that great compaired what your future sound system might be like. Just kind of thinking out loud based on my past experince.

I'm learning that very quickly. I've jumped into this hobby with both feet in the last few months and I've *rocketed* through some stuff.
My first speaker purchase lo these 3 or 4 months ago was a pair of Sansui SP-X8000's. I LOVED those speakers. I thought they were just the coolest thing ever.
Since then I've stumbled across/hunted down 7 other pairs of speakers. Those "beloved" Sansuis are sitting unused at the moment.

I've decided to sit back and enjoy what I have for now until I find something that's a big upgrade at the right price for me. My point being that even in a few months, my perspective has totally changed.
 
The most important thing is to enjoy your process of growth. I've done work in homes where a group of equipment has more invested in it than my home....plus several of my neighbors homes! To my eyes it is absolutely ridiculous to see this with absolutely no appreciation curve going into it....then again, some folks do go through the whole process and upgraded as they went to this. (While rattling off specs, comparisons and....opening up there closet of old gear!) Enjoy what you have,remember the good work and study....SP-8000's! I could just sit and stare for hours at those!
 
My speaker awakening

I became an audiophile when I bought a pair of $40 JVC speakers off craigslist. They are three-way floor standing speakers from the 70s. They have disappeared in history; I can find very little information out about them.

But wow did they sound amazing! Detailed, rich, musical. I heard things I had never heard before. I'm sure many of you have had the same experience. After having gone through many speakers since, I would say that those speakers are easily worth $200. Could I sell them for that much? I am sure not. Unless, of course, someone who really knew speakers listened to them. But that's okay; I'm happy to have them in my house. :-)

Some speakers just have magic. Some don't.
 
Come on guys. Everyone has or knows someone who bought a pair of speakers for a very good price from GW or CL and thought they were the "schiit". As soon as that person hears a pair of higher quality speakers those first ones get sold or put in the closet. Thinking that ones first purchase of half way decent speakers is the be all end all is looking at things in a very myopic way.

The first pair of speakers is a lot like your first sex. Even if it was bad it was still fantastic. Later in life you know better. Although you still look back at the first with a lot of fond nostalgia you know it got "greater later".
 
Your absolutely right! Within three days of your post I bought a pair of Rogers LS4a speakers, attached them to my Luxman and haven't listened to the Sony's since. I've been too lazy to reconnect the Sony's so I can't objectively say whether the Rogers sound THAT much better but I guess having paid ten times as much for them I've convinced myself they are. They certainly look better together.:D
 
To the OP:

I'll put it this way. If I were to make any upgrades, I would go with the speakers. I'd say they are the weak spot in relation to your Luxman. If you spend $100 on the right pair of used speakers, you can improve your sound quite a bit. When you decide it's time to upgrade, that's where I would start. Then I would look at your source unit, whatever that may be (CD-player, PC, DVD-player, etc.), and determine whether an outboard DAC would help your digital sound. And if you were listening to a lot of vinyl, then you'd want to look at the quality of the turntable and the cartridge. If I had your gear, that's the direction I would go (as my budget permitted).

When looking for used speakers, there are several things you need to consider: the material used for the woofer surrounds and whether they will need new ones, the age/condition of the caps inside and whether you'll need to replace them, and also whether or not the speakers will be compatible with your Luxman in terms of RMS wattage and whether they are 8ohm, 6ohm, or whatever. And equally-important, you'll want to consider the kinds of music you'll be listening through them.

In the case of speakers, heavy usually means good (Usually... It depends on the design as well as the build-quality, but usually you can't go wrong paying $10 or $20 for a pair of speakers with heavy, furniture-grade cabs).
 
Last edited:
Gang-Twanger, am I to assume you don't consider my NZD356 purchase of the Rogers an upgrade? This a tougher hobby than I thought!:whip:
 
Gang-Twanger, am I to assume you don't consider my NZD356 purchase of the Rogers an upgrade? This a tougher hobby than I thought!:whip:

Sorry, I missed your last post where you mentioned buying the Rogers speakers... I was referring to the Sony speakers, but it looks like you've moved on from them. Yes, I would absolutely-call that an upgrade. I'm a big fan of British speakers. They didn't skimp on quality, especially when it comes to the cabinets. The Brits knew how to build good speaker cabs.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the vote of confidence on the Rogers.:music: Before I can say I've really moved on from the Sony's I'd have to give them another listen. I really meant what I said about them when I originally started this thread. I guess this obsession is more than just about the sound. Cachet, rarity, reverence, nostalgia, and goodness knows what else seems to come into play when you finally get hooked.
 
Listen Around

You're on the path now.

Seek out others who enjoy audio and see if they'd like to invite you for a listen.

Years ago when there were still Audio shops around here (Syracuse NY Area - a mid-sized city) a couple of us would spend a weekday afternoon (when the shops wern't busy) Shop hopping and listening to all the new and cool stuff.

That stuff is now the "vintage" stuff you see so highly sought after by the AK community. By doing this, you will learn to listen, and better verbalize what you hear.

These days it's a lot harder, as dealer/Audio shops that have systems set up and will set up several sets of speakers for you to listen to before buying are getting hard to find. Back then the local shops would do it even if they knew you wern't buying --- just yet, and even just to impress you. - I know, I ran a couple of them in the 80's.

Away from Mega-cities Like New York or Los Angeles. these days I'm sad to say, in the US they're all but extinct. I have no idea if the New Zealand music scene ever was like it was here - who knows, you may have it better than we do here nowadays. I suspect you may be better off than most as I believe Auckland is one of the larger cities there? They may well have 2 or 3 audio shops (Hopefully).

What's important is that you are happy with your system, and part of the path there includes learning what else is out there, and what it sounds like, what you like and don't.

You'll be able to find what you like cheaper, faster and better. Nobody (well nobody I know) can afford to buy all the speakers (and inevitably other equipment) necessary to progress up to their "ultimate" system.

Enjoy the hunt, and have fun.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom