If it did not have the motor noise I likely would not have done the sound dampening. I do enjoy tinkering, have removed the preamp and added RCA jacks.
If I could go back 5-6 years and there was a LP140 and I knew what I know now, yes I would probably make a different choice.
I have a Project RPM1.3 and a Pioneer PL-530 so I have a couple other examples to compare noise.
When I first got the 120 I don’t think it made the noise or maybe I didn’t realize it until I had the others to compare. It seemed like it started after I had it running for an extended period of time on a non level surface.
Like I said you could clearly hear the motor noise from 10’ not hooked up to amplification, now hardly from 1’. I get if a person has a quiet version of the table it would be hard to understand all the fuss. 5 years ago in Canada this is a $500 turntable, the new version is $399 now so worth it to me to put in the effort.(You should see what I did to a perfectly good Fender Blues Junior guitar amp)
When you say motor noise, are you referring to that cogging sound when starting up, or the actual noise, from the electric motor? Mine had a faint cogging sound, for a split second or two when the platter was starting up, but then it would get perfectly quiet afterwards.
And right, of course. Everything I said earlier was just my personal opinion. Although I'm personally against removing the internal preamp & cutting all the wires inside it, which is what most people seem to be doing (at least according to YouTube). There is a much better way to deal the with noise filter, simply by removing the low pass filter on the output gate. Requires some soldering & making a "jumper" across the SMD plates but gives you the ability to use the internal preamp (and the USB even) without filtering anything. The only downside to this is having more "noisy" digital output through USB, but still it's a win-win scenario if you ask me.
Regarding the noise - aside from owning LP120 (and owning LP140 now), I also have an old-er Dual from around 1988. Nothing exciting, fully automated table powered by the wall wart. And I have to admit, the signal output from Dual is noticeably quieter than the one on 120/140. Not terribly much, but enough to spot the difference. However, Dual is having whole other issues such as noticeable wow & flutter, and/or permanently set VTF & AS which cannot be adjusted, so regardless of its sound features I still prefer 120/140 due to their precision & quartz lock drive (but I'm using both of them, depending on my mood or the situation)
Don’t understand why this is not mentioned more on these audio blogs. I guess no love for the 140XP. I think it’s been pegged as a dj table by the reviews on line.
Because people don't really know (much) about LP-140XP in the first place. I remember talking about 140 right here on AK back in January, I mentioned that I'm thinking about buying one & maybe doing a review and someone answered me back, asking if maybe I meant "LP1240", because they never heard of LP140... IMHO, Audio Technica completely failed with LP140 - not because of the build quality or design, but because of targeted audience & marketing towards DJ crowd.
Again, this is entirely my own, personal opinion but I don't find 140 to be a good DJ table. For starters, the motor is just too weak for "DJ abuse" as I call it. Then there's a design thing, with the dust cover & SL-1200 look. Again, perfect for HiFi, lame for DJs who will want to pack it inside the suitcase & carry it around the night clubs & all those late night parties. For both of these, the LP1240 makes much, MUCH better choice. Some people even go as far to consider it better than SL-1200 itself but I wouldn't go that far, nor do I really care much about DJ stuff to begin with. But it's a fact yes, that "DJ" theme on 140 is scaring people away from it, and driving them towards LP-120X and/or LP-5X.
The cart I have on the table now is an AT130E with ATN120E stylus, it sounds very good.
Seems like a more detailed and clear setup than stock, but to be fair the stock AT95E(stock stylus) had quite a few hours on it’s stylus. When comparing the AT130E(ATN120E stylus) to the AT95E(with LP gear shibata stylus installed) I would have to say I could not say which sounds better.
I sold a turntable with the AT95E cart installed......
Need to get another AT95 cart to use my Shibata stylus, if anyone has one kicking around with no stylus they don’t want.......
Get in touch with Audio Technica support (depending on your area, either US or UK) and ask if they can give you one for free ... most likely, they will.
I had somewhat similar situation, myself where I had two styli (ATN-95E & ATN-95EX), but only one cartridge, generator body. And since I had to get in touch with tech support because of something else, I used the opportunity & asked them if they would be willing to sell just the generator alone without the stylus. Their answer was no (especially since they no longer support AT-95E, it is discontinued in favor of VM-95 series but still in production for third-party companies ... just like AT-3600) BUT they offered to send me one for free. No questions asked, I only had to provide them the address & contact info.