• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

B & W Pics

old_tv_nut, your image is perfectly B&W to me, on several monitors, whereas the image before in this thread (michaelj's) has a blue/purple tinge and the one immediately above (hwirt's) has a definite brown tinge (I asked my partner if it looked B&W to her).
Is there a foolproof way of getting B&W from a colour file and should it be a RAW file not a jpeg for it to be reliable?
I really appreciate the advice on this as B&W is simply so beautiful, and I feel I've missed the creative opportunity.
 
old_tv_nut, your image is perfectly B&W to me, on several monitors, whereas the image before in this thread (michaelj's) has a blue/purple tinge and the one immediately above (hwirt's) has a definite brown tinge (I asked my partner if it looked B&W to her).
Is there a foolproof way of getting B&W from a colour file and should it be a RAW file not a jpeg for it to be reliable?
I really appreciate the advice on this as B&W is simply so beautiful, and I feel I've missed the creative opportunity.

The tints are deliberate effects that are added in the post processing. The default is pure black and white.

The advantage of working in post processing is that you can pick the relative brightness of different hues - you can make blue objects brighter than yellow or red, or vice versa, however looks best to you for your subject - kind of like being able to use a color filter on the lens, but you can change your mind at any time after taking the shot. If you simply set your camera to black and white and use its black and white version, the manufacturer has made those decisions for you.

You can do post processing on a jpg, but working with raw instead of jpg means you have a wider range of adjustment before you lose detail or see artifacts, because the raw file has all the data that the camera captured. The jpg file created in the camera has all kinds of adjustments like contrast and S curve and sharpness already applied, which means that some details you might want to see could be lost already and unrecoverable.
 
1239078_945767925448942_1539460130655912571_o.jpg
 
old_tv_nut, your image is perfectly B&W to me, on several monitors, whereas the image before in this thread (michaelj's) has a blue/purple tinge and the one immediately above (hwirt's) has a definite brown tinge (I asked my partner if it looked B&W to her).
Is there a foolproof way of getting B&W from a colour file and should it be a RAW file not a jpeg for it to be reliable?
I really appreciate the advice on this as B&W is simply so beautiful, and I feel I've missed the creative opportunity.

Just an FYI restorer-john, my image is of the homeless man SHOULD BE neutral black, not blue purple. I created the image on a monitor that was calibrated with a Spyder 3 color calibration unit. I do notice a slight shift in color on my jpegs in Photobucket where I store Jpegs, though. So, the shift to blue could be taking place there, but I am not seeing it here and it would be Very slight. I would check the color of your monitors. Just to be safe.

I always work in Raw. I shoot in raw, I correct and do Photoshop work in raw and when I am done I save in raw (or PSD if I have multiple layers) and when I am completely done, I save in either Tiff (if I am making large print) or jpeg if the image is for web use.

That's how I work. Others undoubtedly have a different approach.
 
Last edited:
I'm back playing with my Holga ($30 plastic film camera). It's never quite in focus, sometimes there are light leaks, the corners always vignette. But the images are always a bit surreal and fun. Tri-X medium format. Processed and printed in my home lab and scanned.





 
I recently returned from trip to Cincinnati. While there I visited the Over the Rhine (OTR) neighborhood of the city. Here are a few images:

 
Last edited:
I'm back playing with my Holga ($30 plastic film camera). It's never quite in focus, sometimes there are light leaks, the corners always vignette. But the images are always a bit surreal and fun. Tri-X medium format. Processed and printed in my home lab and scanned.


I like it, it's like a dream.
 
Back
Top Bottom