• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Bank Drafts

guitarman50

Super Member
I'm selling a very expensive turntable on Canuck Audio Mart. I got contacted by someone tonight that requested I call him at his cell number. I talked with him for a bit and he agreed to buy my table and didn't even try to talk me down. Although the price is quite fair and I wouldn't have lowered it anyway.
He said he was more old school and didn't do the online EMT payments. He said if I sent him my mailing address he'd mail me a bank draft for $1,000 (slightly less than a third of the selling price) and he'd pick it up in about 2 weeks and pay me the balance. He's coming from Windsor. So I sent him my mailing address but I can't help but feel a little uneasy about a bank draft.
Maybe I'm just being over paranoid but after reading about bank drafts on the Internet it seems they're easy to commit fraud with.
However I talked with the guy on the phone at length and he definitely knows his high end audio. I'm in to high end audio as well so I know thats not something you can fake.
I also read his profile on Canuck Audio Mart and he has all positive feedback except for one, which he explained to me.
So am I being over paranoid or should I be wary of a bank draft from a stranger? How long does it take for a bank draft to clear so you can be guaranteed its legit?
 
Register to hide this ad
None of the banks here will touch a bank draft. One guy at my bank said "oh, yeah, I read about those in my history of banking class." Unless you know your bank will honor it, stay clear and insist on some other means of payment.
 
None of the banks here will touch a bank draft. One guy at my bank said "oh, yeah, I read about those in my history of banking class." Unless you know your bank will honor it, stay clear and insist on some other means of payment.

Thats strange I did not know that about bank drafts. I paid the balance of my car loan off (with Honda Canada) and I was instructed to go to the bank, get a bank draft and take it to the dealership, which I did.
 
I ended up just texting him and telling to never mind the bank draft. I said if he's interested I'll hold it for him till April 15th and he can just bring the entire balance in cash. He agreed so I marked my ad as "SOLD PENDING PAYMENT".
 
Not sure what the problem is ... bank drafts are pretty much guaranteed payment, as the money has to be in the customer's account at the issuing bank and that amount is frozen until payment (pending any time limits printed on the draft).

If you're worried about a scam, you can always call the issuing bank and verify it's theirs ...
 
Maybe I'm just being over paranoid but after reading about bank drafts on the Internet it seems they're easy to commit fraud with. ?

That's because they're easy to commit fraud with. However, if you talk to your bank they will accept the deposit and then tell you when it has completely cleared. Usually several days at least. From your additional remarks--and the time he's willing to wait--your buyer sounds legit. I'd let him mail you the check, with the proviso that it has to clear.

Not sure what the problem is ... bank drafts are pretty much guaranteed payment, as the money has to be in the customer's account at the issuing bank and that amount is frozen until payment (pending any time limits printed on the draft).

If you're worried about a scam, you can always call the issuing bank and verify it's theirs ...

Once upon a time that was true, but even 15 years ago my bank (Citibank) informed me when I deposited a certified bank check (over $25K) that it still had to clear just like a personal check. They can be stopped and they can be forged, among other things. I was on tenterhooks for seven days while my car and title were long gone. Fortunately it cleared.
 
I was on tenterhooks for seven days while my car and title were long gone. Fortunately it cleared.

Even though it would clear by the time he came to pick it up I don't want to have to think about it or worry whether its going to clear or not. I'd rather just wait for him to come down by April 15 and make it clear to bring cash, which is what I did.
The only thing that made me a little suspicious is that he didn't want to send the deposit via EMT as he said he did it once and screwed it up. I'm the least adept at things like that and I've been able to do it successfully. Its very easy.
 
Nah. It’s 2018. For the protection of both buyer and seller, electronic services like PayPal are the only way to go for stuff like this. I don’t know what a bank draft is but I have seen the fake check/money order scam before. If you flip it and reverse it, you always wonder why folks would take such a risk sending somebody money in a manner where it’s so easy to get burned. Simply, they wouldn’t.
 
Last car I sold, the buyer and I used the same bank. We drove tot he bank in the car; transferred the money from their account to mine; signed the title, and left with photo copies of all documents curtesy of the bank. I wish every transaction was that simple and safe.
 
you can call the bank with the draft details and have them verify it's OK.

or go to the bank and cash it with the buyer.
 
There is a profound difference between a cashier's check (bank guarantees payment other than under very unusual circumstances) and a bank draft (issued against some account or another, and "drawn through" will be printed on it somewhere). Bank drafts can be as worthless as the paper they're printed on. While cashier's checks can be stopped - if the payment that purchased them was later challenged or shown to be illegal/fraudulent for example - that is a very rare occurrence. You cannot go back to a bank that issued (sold) you a cashier's check and tell them "I changed my mind" or "the item wasn't as described" and get them to void the check, prevent payment, reimburse you etc. Ain't going to happen.

I would never take a bank draft for anything, but I'd take a cashier's check any time - but, I'm still giving that time to clear my bank AND the issuing bank, before the goods change hands. Same for postal money orders.

John
 
There is a profound difference between a cashier's check (bank guarantees payment other than under very unusual circumstances) and a bank draft (issued against some account or another, and "drawn through" will be printed on it somewhere). Bank drafts can be as worthless as the paper they're printed on. While cashier's checks can be stopped - if the payment that purchased them was later challenged or shown to be illegal/fraudulent for example - that is a very rare occurrence. You cannot go back to a bank that issued (sold) you a cashier's check and tell them "I changed my mind" or "the item wasn't as described" and get them to void the check, prevent payment, reimburse you etc. Ain't going to happen.

I would never take a bank draft for anything, but I'd take a cashier's check any time - but, I'm still giving that time to clear my bank AND the issuing bank, before the goods change hands. Same for postal money orders.

John

Theres very strong differences of opinions on this subject. And thats really the hassle I'm trying to avoid. If I took the bank draft I'd be worried about it, for who knows how long.
He originally said he'd be able to pickup the table with in 2 weeks so I didn't mind giving him that much time to just come and get it. I gave him my word that I'd hold it till April 15 and he agreed with that. His Canuck Audio Mart feedback seems fine and I talked with him on the phone.
I did receive another offer yesterday but I will abide by my word.
 
I've run into misunderstandings about "cleared". Just because the bank honors the instrument of payment and hands you the money doesn't necessarily/inherently mean the instrument is 100% A-OK.
 
Theres very strong differences of opinions on this subject. And thats really the hassle I'm trying to avoid. If I took the bank draft I'd be worried about it, for who knows how long.
He originally said he'd be able to pickup the table with in 2 weeks so I didn't mind giving him that much time to just come and get it. I gave him my word that I'd hold it till April 15 and he agreed with that. His Canuck Audio Mart feedback seems fine and I talked with him on the phone.
I did receive another offer yesterday but I will abide by my word.
I think you're doing the right thing by being a good guy. He should be beyond happy about that.
I'd let the other offer know what is going on, if it were me.
 
I've run into misunderstandings about "cleared". Just because the bank honors the instrument of payment and hands you the money doesn't necessarily/inherently mean the instrument is 100% A-OK.
Yeah.
I could go down to the basement and rip out a page from a Dr Seuss book, deposit at the instant teller saying it's a $1000 cheque, and pull that money out. Doesn't mean they won't call me on it a day or two later.
Extreme example, but the scammers know how to play this game.
 
Theres very strong differences of opinions on this subject.

The difference between a cashier's check and a bank draft isn't down to opinion, it's factual. If you're getting different descriptions from people, it's because they don't know what they are talking about which could certainly include your potential buyer. Step 1 would be to find out exactly what kind of check he plans to give you.

I've run into misunderstandings about "cleared". Just because the bank honors the instrument of payment and hands you the money doesn't necessarily/inherently mean the instrument is 100% A-OK.

That's why I posted "I'm still giving that time to clear my bank AND the issuing bank" - once it has cleared the bank that issued it, the chances of that transaction being reversed are extremely low as mentioned. Just clearing your bank isn't enough, as the bank that issued it could return it to them if they had been given sufficient reason to void it - but that becomes much harder/less likely once they themselves have honored the check.

BTW, it doesn't matter all that much if you cash a cashier's check vs. depositing it, if the transaction that purchased the check turns out to be fraudulent or criminal, they would still have recourse - though it means coming after you the hard way vs. debiting whatever account you might have with the bank where it was deposited. Can still happen, though.

Found this site that discusses these and other related check types: https://money.stackexchange.com/que...certified-check-a-cashiers-check-a-money-orde

John
 
Note that OP is from Canada. I think bank drafts are a little more reliable within the Canadian banking system. When I worked as a stockbroker in the Canadian brokerage industry, we would have no difficulty accepting a bank draft from a recognized Canadian chartered bank, but drafts from American banks would require many levels of verification.
 
Last edited:
Good points both. I was drawing (no pun intended, but I'll take it) on what I was taught in teller school lo these many years ago, which was definitely US-oriented.

John
 
Back
Top Bottom