I alternated the dark and white meat.
Yeah - I'm thinking the chicken is the problem here. Like I said - I switched the boneless breasts out a while ago - and they always come out nice. Today - I googled - rubbery chicken + the brand - and the first two hits - both mentioned how gigantic the breasts were.
I'm done with this brand - I'll buy a whole organic chicken and cut up before going back.
I like it a bit charred on the outside - this last 10 or so minutes is over direct heat with the lid off - just basting and flipping ever few minutes (about four flips/bastes @2-3 minutes each) - never been a problem before.
My dogs are happy as hell about it.
Edit - ok one thing I noticed was the 40 minute indirect heat time that I winged - I rechecked the recipe I usually follow - and it calls for 25 minutes of indirect heat - so perhaps I just over cooked them. I'll give the 3 pack bone in breasts another chance as they usually are pretty damn good and really convenient.
Thanks!
.Yeah, we've had that a few times here. And it's always in the larger chicken breasts. But what kind of choice do we have here? $1.99/lb for the normal chicken, or $5.99 for an upmarket brand? Chicken isn't supposed to be expensive, yet we might be forced to pay that just to get something edible. Seems like one in three bags of chicken we buy has one of those woody breasts in it.I thought my chicken was tough due to overcooking (in the original post above) - nope - it is a known issue: woody/white stripped chicken.
Yeah, we've had that a few times here. And it's always in the larger chicken breasts. But what kind of choice do we have here? $1.99/lb for the normal chicken, or $5.99 for an upmarket brand? Chicken isn't supposed to be expensive, yet we might be forced to pay that just to get something edible. Seems like one in three bags of chicken we buy has one of those woody breasts in it.
If it looks questionable, I'll use it for ground chicken. If not, I have a tenderizer I hit it with. Still not ideal but at least dinner isn't totally ruined.
.....I realize I'm preaching mostly to the choir, and there's plenty of experienced grillers here who have their own ways....but, to some who read this thread that would like to grill outside and don't have any experience or equipment, I'm going to say, "I assure you, you can't miss with a Weber 22 inch kettle cooker for a hundred bucks from Wal-Mart".....
.....after an initial cooking, enough charcoal is left for the bottom layer of the next coal bed effort....just close all the vents when done....I spray the fire with a hose and let the partial briquettes dry for a couple of days.....
.....stop pouring whole bags of charcoal into a charcoaler hoping part of it will catch....build a one foot diameter, round, 3-4 layer coal bed in the middle for searing and making smoke....close the bottom vents for searing as the fire can get nutty quick....open them full to bake with the top on.....
.....all chicken pieces seared....making chicken fat smoke for the baking phase.....
![]()
I'm not Mulester, but (if I haven't done so yet earlier in the thread) here is what I do on my kettle.When your baking....roasting, what percentage do you leave the vents open ?? Top and bottom...
I sure miss Mulestar. Vents should be wide open on the weber - both bottom and top - especially the top - perhaps the bottom is tunable - but the top needs to be wide open from what I've read.When your baking....roasting, what percentage do you leave the vents open ?? Top and bottom...
Haven't posted in a while - ran into rubber chicken last Friday. When the chicken breast was raw - it felt like a thick rubber puck - very hard (fought back when I tried to pound it out.) Mystery is now solved - this is a known industry problem:
https://www.ciwf.com/blog/2017/02/chicken-has-changed-for-the-worse-and-the-proof-is-in-the-stripes
I thought my chicken was tough due to overcooking (in the original post above) - nope - it is a known issue: woody/white stripped chicken.
Very disappointing. Watch out for it - avoid white stripes - feel the meat - make sure it is soft - and look for smaller breasts.
Cheers.
Those look great - nice coloring.Wow thanks for that link. Here is some BBQ I just cooked before the Masters today.
I will be watching out for the white stripes in the future.
View attachment 1157887
Best-
Boozehound