I missed this "Big" thread the first time around. My big speakers are the new Altecs in my avatar. Took me six months to build with a lot of encouragement from guys here and technical advice from the Parts Express Tech Talk forum. They weigh in excess of 200 lbs each, and stand four feet tall.
To me, 40Hz sounds much better thru a 15" woofer than from a 8 or 10" woofer. And horns, properly equalized and integrated, are simply delicious. Honestly, if you've heard
good-quality horns that sounded bad, they were not integrated correctly. Done right, they have an intimacy and immediacy that I've rarely heard elsewhere. (None of the praise I've dealt here should indicate that I simply do not like cone/dome-based bookshelf speakers. I do. A lot. But the horns and big woofers win out for me. )
For anybody who may care, my entire build process - warts and all - can be found here:
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/altec-606-inspired-build-using-a-7-components.766911/
They are being powered by a newly-restored Dynaco PAT-4 preamp, and two restored Dynaco Mk. IV tube monoblocks. My gear is by no means modern, hi-tech, or expensive, but it delivers exactly the sound I've chased for all these years. I'm happy.
GeeDeeEmm