• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Bookshelf Shootout!

I had an epiphany today, about myself at least. When I am listening to speakers in a shootout situation, I often perceive to be errors in the tonality, which really turn out to be subtle personality/balance differences that are not a problem in the long run.

Just got another new pair of speakers today (universally admired Dynacos - if you care, my thread about them is here: http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?p=8071938#post8071938)

Anyway, as soon as I plugged them up I thought "wow, these are thin and midrangy!" That's silly. Now after one hour, I don't hear that at all.

So, doing the switch-box wall of speakers comparison might tend to draw a lot of attention to tonal/balance differences that are not at all the important ones.

Hmm.
 
I had an epiphany today, about myself at least. When I am listening to speakers in a shootout situation, I often perceive to be errors in the tonality, which really turn out to be subtle personality/balance differences that are not a problem in the long run.

Just got another new pair of speakers today (universally admired Dynacos - if you care, my thread about them is here: http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?p=8071938#post8071938)

Anyway, as soon as I plugged them up I thought "wow, these are thin and midrangy!" That's silly. Now after one hour, I don't hear that at all.

So, doing the switch-box wall of speakers comparison might tend to draw a lot of attention to tonal/balance differences that are not at all the important ones.

Hmm.
"Praise the Lord, he hath seen the light". OK, kidding aside, I run into this routinely with my speakers. If I start my evening off (or afternoon on the weekends) with speaker "A", switching to speaker "B" can be a horrible experience. But not always. Likewise, if I start off with speaker "B", things are wonderful and then speaker "A" sounds not so great when I switch to it.

The fact of the matter is our ears and brain are incredibly good at adapting. If you allow yourself to become immersed in what you are listening to, in time all will correct itself automatically. If, however, you can't "let go" even for 15-20 minutes of listening, then you will never arrive at a pleasurable state.

There are, however, some things that can't be adjusted to, like "feeling" the music, as in really sub sonic passages. Things like imaging, like listening to The Beatles "Sun King" where the music is constantly panning left to right. Seeming non existent on some speakers, subtle on others, and even more so with a few. And holes, boy can there be holes. This is where a crossover doesn't do it's job, or the drivers don't have adequate overlap in their raw performance. Holes are sounds or instrument that are clearly discernible with one speaker, and almost non existent in another. It's hearing a foot keeping rythym (like in "Clapton Unplugged") that is just obvious enough to give you that "live" feeling, that another speaker may not produce well or adequately.

Of course there is the tried and true standard, used to judge speakers for years, are you listening to rain falling or hands clapping? With some speakers that distinction is almost impossible.

But do keep in mind, the recordings used to sample such sounds really need to be engineered well. One of my biggest pet peeves is choral music. I don't listen to much, and likely it's due to the fact so many are so poorly engineered, sounding more like noise rather than voices in harmony with each other.

How much do I love music? I can sit in a room with a boom box and be content. But, when I have access to "better" equipment, it simply allows me to enjoy it more. I can't spend my life searching for "authentic" reproduction cause in my mind that "realism" will likely never be achieved, in my lifetime, or be affordable to people like me. So I kick back and enjoy the tunes, for me that is all it's about.

Trust your ears and brain, they are amazing at what they can do.
 
I don't listen to much, and likely it's due to the fact so many are so poorly engineered, sounding more like noise rather than voices in harmony with each other.

Yeah - Have a recording of Elijah (Atlanta Symphony Orchestra and Chorus, robert Shaw, TELARC -- I know, a very controversial label!) which I use to test speakers but not right away, more as an "Advanced" phase of the audition. It is not that choral music is poorly engineered but that it is often simply too sonically demanding to capture well. It makes an orchestra alone look like childs play.

The Dynacos handle the final chorus of Elijah well. I am still occasionally hearing some midrange that is forward, but the low end is clearly etched - and I can hear a genuine difference between low organ pedals and cello/basses which is unique. I can also hear the difference between the sopranos and the children's choir, who sing in unison in the final chorus -- amazing! never hear that before.
 
I had an epiphany today, about myself at least. When I am listening to speakers in a shootout situation, I often perceive to be errors in the tonality, which really turn out to be subtle personality/balance differences that are not a problem in the long run.

Just got another new pair of speakers today (universally admired Dynacos - if you care, my thread about them is here: http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?p=8071938#post8071938)

Anyway, as soon as I plugged them up I thought "wow, these are thin and midrangy!" That's silly. Now after one hour, I don't hear that at all.

So, doing the switch-box wall of speakers comparison might tend to draw a lot of attention to tonal/balance differences that are not at all the important ones.

Hmm.

I hear you. I can pull out any set of old vintage speakers and listen to them after my ears adjust and would be content if that's all I had. But soon as I swap back to newer better speakers I tend to ask myself WTF have I been listening to. Everything is relative. Given a choice on what sounds better in the same setup and using the same music, you go for the best sound. If you took most of the speakers that are highly regarded on this forum and put them thru their paces in a comparative way as the OP did, then you'd find a lot of the standard recommendations aren't really up to par, but get recommended by those who don't listen to anything else.
 
I had an epiphany today, about myself at least. When I am listening to speakers in a shootout situation, I often perceive to be errors in the tonality, which really turn out to be subtle personality/balance differences that are not a problem in the long run.

Just got another new pair of speakers today (universally admired Dynacos - if you care, my thread about them is here: http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?p=8071938#post8071938)

Anyway, as soon as I plugged them up I thought "wow, these are thin and midrangy!" That's silly. Now after one hour, I don't hear that at all.

So, doing the switch-box wall of speakers comparison might tend to draw a lot of attention to tonal/balance differences that are not at all the important ones.

Hmm.

I've always thought this was the cause of 'burn in' especially for speakers since according to everything I've read after the first few seconds/minutes there is very little change in the measured performance characteristics of a speaker.

My personal experience was with Advent Legacy's. When I first listened to them I thought they were boomy. This was true only for the first few days. After that I didn't hear the excessive bass. While you could posit that bass might improve as the surrounds 'loosened up' I can't see the opposite happening where the bass tightens up.
 
Some shops still practice this comparison test. I had a lot of fun about a year ago helping some good friends (married couple) choose their speakers and components. Before stepping into a stereo shop, they said they trusted me and did not want to spend time listening to speakers and every component. Well, everything changed when they started to hear the differences from one speaker to another. They ended up choosing what I liked best and what I would have recommended for a small bookshelf speaker--PSB Synchrony One B.

Pricy @ $1,100 a pair!:yikes: $879 for refurbs.
 
I have the Gen 1 Pioneers. I also have the Axiom M2's. Those are the Cherry Polk RTi A3's. As hard as I tried, I just can't get used to the Pioneers. The treble to me just sounds too.....suppressed (like not amped loud enough). I don't like the Axiom's sound either.

Nearly every bookshelf I've used (even my much loved JBL Northbridge E30's), the treble on my receiver (Pio SX-D5000) has always been pushed to nearly 2 or 2 1/2 and bass kept at "0". When I got my Polk A3's, I loved how "clear" they sounded and I run the receiver "unbiased" with no tone controlling. I don't know how much the sound would change from the A1's since they are 5" woofers (instead of 6 1/4").

You might ask why this would matter. I also have some Polk Monitor 30's (the 5" cheap ones). They use the same exact tweeter. Most Polk entry/mid priced speakers all use the 1" soft dome (except the LSi's use that weird "rippled nipple" design). There is a huge disparity in sound between them (and we're not even talking about the bass). I think it's the fact that the RTi A series use a composite woofer instead of whatever the cheap series use. It could also be due to the curved enclosure, but the Pio's also adopt that and I still don't like them. I used to use the Polk 30's as my surrounds, but noticed that they didn't timbre match to the A3's (during PC games in surround), so I another set of A3's for the back. I put them upside down so the tweeters are closer to ear level :).

I agree with you and your son that the Polks are better than the Pio's. I know this sounds shallow, but I can't stand "black" speakers anymore after doing beechnut and cherry now.

SpeakersDuel.jpg


SpeakersPolk.jpg
 
Last edited:
I listened to an album the other night through a fair set of headphones... first time I'd used headphones in a LONG time.

When I took them off and switched back to my Epicure 150s... whoa. They sounded wounded and near death... flat, no depth, no resonance. Then as I continued to listen, my ears and brain adapted and once again they sounded great. Weird.

The Sense of Hearing is indeed so subjective. It occurs to me that the sense of sight is much less subjective than is hearing. Perhaps I'm wrong, but I don't seem to experience such startling differences when "viewing" different video sources.

oh well....
 
I listened to an album the other night through a fair set of headphones... first time I'd used headphones in a LONG time.

When I took them off and switched back to my Epicure 150s... whoa. They sounded wounded and near death... flat, no depth, no resonance. Then as I continued to listen, my ears and brain adapted and once again they sounded great. Weird.

The Sense of Hearing is indeed so subjective. It occurs to me that the sense of sight is much less subjective than is hearing. Perhaps I'm wrong, but I don't seem to experience such startling differences when "viewing" different video sources.

oh well....

A lot of research has been done in the past ten years about how we hear music, too. When we hear familiar music, our brains evidently fill in all sorts of details with memories of past performances. This is not to discount the qualities we hear in different speakers, but certainly complicates it.
 
Thanks for all of the positive responses.

I continued the shootout for the better part of the week. I even alternated the positions of each speaker to give them each a fair shot. The results were the same, at least to my ears.

In the end, I decided to return the BS-22's because I really don't have a place for them.
 
Back
Top Bottom