• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Can tubes be preheated before rolling?

tomlinmgt

Lunatic Member
Lets say one has a variety of different tubes one wants to compare in a piece of tube gear. Can one preheat them, say in an oven set to 150 F or so, to get them warmed up so the whole warm-up time to get them into their true sonic character is eliminated?

Tube newbie here so go easy on me if this is a ridiculous idea for reasons I'm not aware.
 
Register to hide this ad
Don't think it would hurt, but I question whether it would help. Make sure you wear gloves or something when swapping them.
 
Hmmm. Interesting idea. I wonder if it's really that beneficial? My first reaction is that the guts of the tube are working hotter than 150 and the temp vs. time between oven removal and amp power up doesn't change the normal way internal time to temp very much. :dunno:
 
Morgan Jones cautions against soak temperatures above 100C, in his comments on preconditioning NOS tubes. Apparently the base tends to disintegrate on some older types. I have no idea whether thermal soaking would do anything to help the tube comparison process, but I would love to see some hard data on this topic.
 
Well, reason I ask is I picked up a AMC tube pre and have only been able to listen to it for a total of about four hours and want to roll in some Baldwin/Sylvania 12AU7s and some GE 12AX7s (all tested) for the factory supplied JJTesla and TungSols (can't remember which pair is U and which pair is X). I don't expect to hear a world of difference and if I have to wait twenty minutes for the American tubes to warm up I may not be able to hear a difference at all since I'm not thoroughly familiar with the sonic character of the Russian tubes.
 
Just a guess, of course, but I'd think that the "hot" parts of the tube run a lot hotter than 150F when fully warmed up, and probably pass through 150F pretty quickly after start up. My guess is that preheating to 150F might save 30 seconds or so on the warm up curve. As I said, it's just a guess and I'd be interested in what you find out if you give it a try.
 
150 degrees is not even close to a good temperature for tubes.

"giving it the ability to emit sufficient electrons at about 2000 degrees Celsius. The "dull emitter" types also possess a tungsten filament, but it is coated in a mixture of calcium, strontium and barium oxides, which emits electrons easily at much lower temperatures due to a monolayer of mixed alkali earth metals coating the tungsten; these only reach 800–1000 degrees Celsius."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_tube
 
150 degrees is not even close to a good temperature for tubes.

"giving it the ability to emit sufficient electrons at about 2000 degrees Celsius. The "dull emitter" types also possess a tungsten filament, but it is coated in a mixture of calcium, strontium and barium oxides, which emits electrons easily at much lower temperatures due to a monolayer of mixed alkali earth metals coating the tungsten; these only reach 800–1000 degrees Celsius."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_tube

I had concerns whether 150 F would be hot enough or not, but 1000C? :saywhat:

Man, you realize that's over 1800 F, right?. The typical gasoline combustion engine operates with an exhaust gas temperature of around 1300-1500 F measured at the exhaust port of the head. I find it hard to believe a tube is getting several hundred degrees hotter than the exhaust gases from a gasoline combustion engine. Unless the gases inside the tube have an extraordinarily low thermal conductivity value I just don't see how the guts could be generating temperatures as high as you (or the Wikipedia quote) claims. :headscrat
 
Looking at it rationally, I cannot hold my hand on any of my output tubes after fifteen minutes of operating time. There is nothing in the glass envelope that produces heat, therefore the plates operate at temperatures well in excess of 150 degrees. This would mean a preheat at that temperature would not reach normal operating temperatures.:thumbsdn:
 
Remember, I'm talking about a preamp....not power amp.

After an hour of listening to my tube pre last night I could touch the tubes with minimal discomfort.

Looks like I need to take the infrared pyrometer home tonight.
 
as mentioned earlier a transformer and a nice box with sockets wired just for the heaters might be a viable idea .
 
Doesn't an oven operate by heating the air? Since there is no air inside a vacuum tube how would that heat get transferred to the internal structures of the tube? Maybe through the pins? Seems like radiant heating would be the way to go.
 
This might be for power amps instead of preamps but...

I seem to recall reading that you do NOT turn the system off and then abrubtly, back on. Something about needing to let the tubes cool down before reheating them or they might fizzle out?

If that is correct, how does that play with prewarming?
If it is not correct, then I suppose I need to zip my mouth. :D
 
Doesn't an oven operate by heating the air? Since there is no air inside a vacuum tube how would that heat get transferred to the internal structures of the tube? Maybe through the pins? Seems like radiant heating would be the way to go.

Only if there is air movement inside the oven...like a convection oven (with fans). Otherwise the oven uses radiant heat generated from the heating element.

If heat generated from inside the tube can heat the glass, then why wouldn't external heat be able to transfer to the tube's internals? Again, I guess one needs to know how effective a thermal insulator the gas inside the tube is.

Definitely taking my infrared pyrometer home tonight.
 
This might be for power amps instead of preamps but...

I seem to recall reading that you do NOT turn the system off and then abrubtly, back on. Something about needing to let the tubes cool down before reheating them or they might fizzle out?

If that is correct, how does that play with prewarming?
If it is not correct, then I suppose I need to zip my mouth. :D

Its actually related to the rectifier. If you shut something down and flip it back on before the rectifier cools enough to stop conducting, it can arc over because the main filter cap is drained.
 
Back
Top Bottom