• The move to the new server is done. There are some software and database maintenance updates in process. This has us passing the hat around to help out. We appreciate any donations. Seriously, even a dollar helps. The payment page may be found here - https://www.audiokarma.org/support.html

Cartridge for SL-1200MK2

brucered

Well-Known Member
Shure M97xE Cartridge @ $70US shipped to Canada
vs
Audio-Technica AT95E Crtridge @ 60US shipped to Canada

i'm looking at one of these 2 cartridges for my SL-1200MK2 to use for playing not scratching or DJ'ing and need some advise.

is it worth it to spend the extra $10bucks on the SHURE or are they comparable in quality?
 
Register to hide this ad
brucered said:
Shure M97xE Cartridge @ $70US shipped to Canada
vs
Audio-Technica AT95E Crtridge @ 60US shipped to Canada

i'm looking at one of these 2 cartridges for my SL-1200MK2 to use for playing not scratching or DJ'ing and need some advise.

is it worth it to spend the extra $10bucks on the SHURE or are they comparable in quality?

It's worth it. The AT isn't bad, but closer to entry level. The Shure is a serious cartridge, will allow for lighter tracking force, has a better stylus, and has the brush/damper attachement which is excellent for damping low frequency resonance in that s-shaped tonearm. Not to mention the excellent sound. Go for it.

Howard
 
according to this link :
http://www.tnt-audio.com/sorgenti/technics_sl1200_e.html
the effective mass of the arm fitted tot he technics is approx 12g

a humble nod for the poor man's cartridge...the at 95e is a lovely sounding cartridge if mated to the right mass arm and aligned properly.
It works well with medium to slightly heavish mass arms of which the technics arm is such...the cartridge has a claimed range of 8-14g which suggests it should mate well with the technics arm from a compliance point of view...

i've been a fan of the at95e for many years simply because it sounds much better than its price suggests and yet the stylus is very cheap to replace every 8 - 12 months when in constant use...approx £13 for a genuine new stylus

the shure i have no experience with but have heard many good reviews on this board about its performance...
an old review of the shure me97he which might be similar..suggests mating it with an arm whose effective mass lies in the range of 8-20g which according to article above makes the technics arm eligible...
if the shure you've mentioned has the same suspension then it should prove a good mechanical match too and sound good indeed..

choosing between either is a difficult call...the shure being a more expensive cartridge 'should' :scratch2: make better music than the at95e...but in my humble opinion the at95e takes some beating even at twice the price...
some reviews online have suggested that the linn k5 ( now discontinued) was basically a rebadged at95e and yup...it sold for twice the price

one factor to consider is the cost and availabilty of replacement stylus for either cartridge as a stylus will need changing at least once a year if you plan on using your deck daily for a few hours...or after approx 600-800 hours of use ...whichever is sooner...

whichever you choose...i'd recommend buying a spare stylus while you're making your initial purchase...their prices seem to keep creeping the 'wrong way' every year with more and more models becoming discontinued without notice :thumbsdn:
 
I've also heard good things about the AT95E, but it has a .4 x .7mil stylus compared to the Shure's .2 x .7. That's half as wide to ride deeper in the groove and pick up more detail. Also you can use a lighter tracking force with the Shure, saving wear on records. The higher compliance AT may be a better theoretical match, but I've tested the Shure with the brush down and it does effectively dampen the resonance. With the brush up the tonearm literally bounces around at 6-7 Hz. With it down--no detectible movement.
 
the shure seems to have a finer profile tip which should give a more detailed sound than the at95e... :thmbsp: both are really good budget cartridges from what i've read and either should give a good sound depending on your setup and music tastes...
 
So what happens when the Shure stylus wears out? And all the discussion here about cartridges, yet no one notes that Brian B offers excellent cartridges at decent prices to AK members (Venus HiFi)

Rob
 
merrylander said:
So what happens when the Shure stylus wears out? And all the discussion here about cartridges, yet no one notes that Brian B offers excellent cartridges at decent prices to AK members (Venus HiFi)
Rob

i think i found his site, but i don't see any cartridges listed. do you just contact him directly for pricing etc?
 
Back
Top Bottom