• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Current production 6CA7 tubes

Thanks for all the replies, really! I think the takeaway is that there's really nothing negative to report about the EH. The things I like about the old stock Sylvania seem to be mirrored with them, especially the low-end punch and control compared to EL34s. The bias voltage observation is interesting and is something I will consider. I'm sure that there is amp-dependence in how different the two tube types sound in any situation, but this is at least the second amp where I keep.coming back to the 6CA7 when I A/B.

Just as an FYI for posterity, the reason I asked about "true 6CA7s" is that it's fundamentally a different tube than the EL34 (tetrode vs pentode). They SHOULD sound different. The only reason you see a lot of tubes labeled with both IDs is that they are mostly drop-in compatible with each other. All true 6CA7s are fat bottles as far as I know, at least for old-stock, and pretty much vice-versa for EL34. I'd be very curious to learn about any exceptions to this.
Most of the Japanese 6CA7's are slim bottled, they mostly look like EL34's apart from the NEC, and I think some of the Ei were 6CA7'S despite being labeled EL34.
 
Then you run into old stock tubes labeled "EL34/6CA7". Without looking closely at the internal structure and connections who knows what they really are. I do wonder about these Chinese tubes. Some of the EL34's and 6CA7's may be the same tube? Then there are all the different 6SN7's. Various bottles shapes, some clear glass, some smoked. Different bases, etc. Are they all really different inside? The fancier the bottle and name the higher the price. I'm sure there are some nice sounding Chinese tubes, but I just don't trust the life span of the tube. I'm using a TAD brown base 5AR4 in my ST-70 at the moment. It's Chinese made, but supposedly tested and made to TAD's specs. So far it has far out lasted the JJ 5AR4 I originally put in the amp when I built it.
 
Just to chime in, I think there's 4+ different types of EL34 (EL34, EL34II, EL34L, 6CA7) that JJ currently offers, and some versions don't get talked enough about. You might want to speak to Eddie at Euro Tubes about what your looking for and the differences, they sell JJ tubes; and are also the JJ distributor into the US, so they have very good knowledge about all the different JJ's that may not be available on the other tube web stores.
I'm not saying the EH34 is not better, obviously they're good and quite a few people do like them; but there's 4 distinctly different sounding versions of JJ EL34's, actually 5 if wanna include their KT77; and they may have what you're looking for? Again, I'm not taking anything away EH EL34's. I think its also important to ask yourself what kind of sound & needs you're looking for; as an example, I'm very much not into the 6550 tube sound, a little too clinical sounding for me, that I could get with a good class A/B amp but many others love it; its just different strokes, for different folks. So listen for yourself.

The good news is, there's seems to be an ample selection of good new EL34's currently being made by several different tube manufacturers, and we will not be in short supply or hurting in the near future.

Has anyone here tried the JJ "EL34II" version?

Link, go down to 2nd row to see versions: https://www.eurotubes.com/shop/tubes/power/
 
Just to chime in, I think there's 4+ different types of EL34 (EL34, EL34II, EL34L, 6CA7) that JJ currently offers, and some versions don't get talked enough about. You might want to speak to Eddie at Euro Tubes about what your looking for and the differences, they sell JJ tubes; and are also the JJ distributor into the US, so they have very good knowledge about all the different JJ's that may not be available on the other tube web stores.
I'm not saying the EH34 is not better, obviously they're good and quite a few people do like them; but there's 4 distinctly different sounding versions of JJ EL34's, actually 5 if wanna include their KT77; and they may have what you're looking for? Again, I'm not taking anything away EH EL34's. I think its also important to ask yourself what kind of sound & needs you're looking for; as an example, I'm very much not into the 6550 tube sound, a little too clinical sounding for me, that I could get with a good class A/B amp but many others love it; its just different strokes, for different folks. So listen for yourself.

The good news is, there's seems to be an ample selection of good new EL34's currently being made by several different tube manufacturers, and we will not be in short supply or hurting in the near future.

Has anyone here tried the JJ "EL34II" version?

Link, go down to 2nd row to see versions: https://www.eurotubes.com/shop/tubes/power/
The JJ EL34 ll and the EL34L seem to be the better two of the lot, with the EL34L having a fuller boom end and better headroom. Or so I've read.
I'm using JJ KT-77's in a single ended amp I built since I had them on hand.
I may try the JJ EL34L's.
 
I have gone through a bunch of EL34/6CA7 tubes....

The EH 6CA7 is very good for the price but there are better tubes out there.

Going through the tubes that I have tried, my preferences from best to worse... This is according to my use with the Willsenton R8 amplifier paired with my Polk R700 speaers and Oppo BDP-95 player. Tubes will sound different with other brands of tube amplifiers and their circuitry design, so take the ranking with a grain of salt.
  • Mullard EL34 XF2* - The best of the rest, superb sonics and soundstage, Extremely hard to find tubes that are in good condition. Most tubes on eBay are well used and not worth the price but occasionally good ones do appear at a decent price. Going rate, $1500/quad for good tubes.
  • Matsushita 6CA7* - Made in Japan with Mullard tooling. Very good tubes, not quite as good as the original Mullards. Pricing going up as supply diminishes. Tubes have reliability issues and do not have a long operating life. All the ones bought from different sources had low measurements. A couple in sealed boxes had vacuum leaks with white getters. About $500/quad.
  • GE 6CA7* - Very good vintage tube, smooth and warm but getting hard to find. About $600/quad
  • Psvane EL34PH - Psvane's best EL34-type tube, their knock-off of Amperex tubes. Better sonics than their newer ART and Treasure series, has good soundstage. But the tube is very sensitive when paired with different pre-amp tubes. Goes best with Ken-Rad VT231/VT229 or Sylvania VT231/229 tubes or Sylvania 6SN7-GTW metal base and vintage smoked glass Tung-Sol 6SN7/6SL7 tubes. IMHO, probably the best current EL34 tube when paired with good front-end tubes. This tube really sounds mediocre with some front-end tubes (e.g. new Tung-Sols, GE). ~ $420/quad
  • Groove Tubes EL34M* - vintage tube but can be found. This tube is the Groove Tube knock-off of the original Mullard EL34 made by Shuguang. Nice smooth, warm sound. Soundstage average. Note that GT made several variants of the EL34s, only the EL34M are worth considering. . This tube has been harder to find since Groove Tubes ended production in 2008. (NOS tubes can still be found at Watford Valves in UK)... ~$300/quad for NOS
  • Mullard EL34 - Probably the best EL34 in production, which is not saying much. Pretty reliable, warm, average soundstage ~$160/quad
  • Tung-Sol EL34B - Just as good as the above Mullards, but sounds more like a solid state, detailed, clean and crisp. Average soundstage and sonics. ~ $200/quad
  • EH 6CA7 - Good tube for the price, more musical than the following tubes. When I started out with tube amps, I really liked this tube until I started rolling others. Still a good tube. ~$130/quad
  • EH EL34 - Not as warm as the EH 6CA7, clean sound. ~$140/quad
  • Psvane 6CA7-T3 ART - Detailed, clean but not worth the high price. Slightly weak bass. ~$250/quad from China (you gotta pay the tariffs)
  • Psvane 6CA7-Z Treasures - I had high hopes for this tube but I had a couple red-plate within a couple of months. ~$200/quad
  • Psvane EL34-UK - Supposedly it's the Chinese knock-off of Mullard tubes, but it's just okay. ~$160/quad
  • Willsenton EL34 - came with my Willsenton R8. It's bright, thin. Looking at it, mine is a Psvane EL34-C. Yours may be different as Willsenton just buys a bunch of cheap tubes from different OEMs and have them relabelled. The Psvane EL34-C are $100/quad.
  • Sovtek EL34 - A New Sensor tube, weak and thin. ~$180/quad
Note that the Electro-Harmonix, Mullard, Sovtek, Svetlana, Telefunken, Tung-Sol and Genalex (Gold Lion) are all made for New Sensor Corporation sourced from the Russian Saratov in the 1990s. While it is nice that the tubes are still being made, they have not released any updated designs since then. At least the Chinese manufacturers like Shuguang and Psvane have been releasing newer tube designs, but they are getting more expensive.

I find that the Russian tubes are generally more reliable than Chinese tubes. I read that Chinese EL34s normally last about 700-1200 hours and Russian tubes double that but that depends on the tube you get, some tubes may die shortly after purchase or last quite long.
 
Last edited:
Then you run into old stock tubes labeled "EL34/6CA7". Without looking closely at the internal structure and connections who knows what they really are. I do wonder about these Chinese tubes. Some of the EL34's and 6CA7's may be the same tube? Then there are all the different 6SN7's. Various bottles shapes, some clear glass, some smoked. Different bases, etc. Are they all really different inside? The fancier the bottle and name the higher the price. I'm sure there are some nice sounding Chinese tubes, but I just don't trust the life span of the tube. I'm using a TAD brown base 5AR4 in my ST-70 at the moment. It's Chinese made, but supposedly tested and made to TAD's specs. So far it has far out lasted the JJ 5AR4 I originally put in the amp when I built it.
For the sake of history, I had to pull out and take a pic... This is one of the tubes I pulled from my stock ST-70 (when I acquired it). Those were a bit tired, but 2 of them still test strong... Apparently Mullard had labeled some of the EL34's as EL34/6CA7 just as you say.
 

Attachments

  • 20251125_192120.jpg
    20251125_192120.jpg
    127.1 KB · Views: 24
I'm not sure if my memory serves, but I thought I had read somewhere that the American tube manufacturers (Sylvania, maybe RCA) designed the beam tetrode 6CA7 in response to Philips having a patent on the pentode designed EL34. It kind of confusing, but I am assuming if the tube is labeled EL34/6CA7 with the skinny bottle, it is a true pentode.

I have an RCA "6CA7" that is a Mullard XF2 EL34.
Is your tube a fat bottle?
 
Most of the true Mullard EL34 tubes sold on eBay are well used, indicated by the small getter flashing on the top of the tube.

for example:
These four tubes are at the end of life... The getter flashing is almost gone. The getter flashing slowly dissipates as the tubes are used.
The seller claims the tubes test strong which may be true, but tubes do not die slowly.
They are like light bulbs and can fail at any time. I would avoid any tubes that have this little amount of getter flashing,
you are spending good money on junk tubes.
s-l160w0.jpg

This EL34 has a good amount of getter flashing left and you can expect it to last awhile.
s-l1e600.jpg
 
Sylvania, RCA and GE sourced early EL34s from Mullard when they first came out. They released the American designed 6CA7 tubes later, they are distinguished by their "fatter" glass tubes. They are as smooth sounding as the Mullards but are good in their own way.
 
I'm not sure if my memory serves, but I thought I had read somewhere that the American tube manufacturers (Sylvania, maybe RCA) designed the beam tetrode 6CA7 in response to Philips having a patent on the pentode designed EL34. It kind of confusing, but I am assuming if the tube is labeled EL34/6CA7 with the skinny bottle, it is a true pentode.


Is your tube a fat bottle?
nope, looks like every skinny Muillard EL34 you've ever seen.
 
Note that the Electro-Harmonix, Mullard, Sovtek, Svetlana, Telefunken, Tung-Sol and Genalex (Gold Lion) are all made for New Sensor Corporation sourced from the Russian Saratov in the 1990s. While it is nice that the tubes are still being made, they have not released any updated designs since then. At least the Chinese manufacturers like Shuguang and Psvane have been releasing newer tube designs, but they are getting more expensive.

I find that the Russian tubes are generally more reliable than Chinese tubes. I read that Chinese EL34s normally last about 700-1200 hours and Russian tubes double that but that depends on the tube you get, some tubes may die shortly after purchase or last quite long.
The Chinese are releasing "new " tubes for marketing. I doubt there is anything really "new technology" about them. With the exception of 211 or 845 because they don't make them, I'll take an Eastern European tube (reluctantly) over a Chines tube any day.
 
Yeah, Chinese tubes look pretty but are unreliable compared to the Russian New Sensor tubes... My biggest gripe with Chinese tubes is their measurements. Psvane includes their factory measurements written on a card included with their top-line tubes... I have the MaxiMatcher tube testers and have measured all of my tubes... All the New Sensor tubes I bought were matched by the various vendors and when i measured them, they come close to what was tested and measured (I did have a couple of tubes that were bad out of the box but were quickly replaced). I really wish that New Sensor would release updated tubes with newer designs and materials. The tubes have not changed since they took the brands over in 2007?

Chinese tubes manufacturers OTOH are to put it mildly, liars... My expensive Psvane 6SL7-T3 ART tubes are off by 15% from one triode to another on the same tube. Psvane also claims the gain is measured at 90dB for the 6SL7 but I measured them at 70dB (which actually is more in line with other 6SL7 tubes). I have two quads of the EL34PH Legend tubes and one quad is ALL "certified" at 29 mA plate current, but they measure from 24-31 mA. The second quad is "certified" at 45 mA and measures between 30-38 mA, none even closely measures the 45 mA they are certified at. My Psvane EL34-Z Treasures are also all "certified" at 45 mA and I measured them from 34-40mA.

This brings me to the conclusion that Psvane just groups the tested tubes in batches that are kind of close and sells them as is. They even claim that their Amazon exclusive Horizon tubes were burned in for 24-48 hours before packaging to ensure quality control. There are a number of reviews that say the tubes were DOA or noisy right out of the box.

If you want matched Psvane tubes, do NOT buy them off eBay, Amazon or Psvane direct. Buy them from a third party vendor such as Viva tubes who prescreens the tubes prior shipping. I bought a set of Psvane 12AU7-ART and 12AX7-ART tubes from them and they all measured close to each other. My Russian Gold Lion KT-88 quad measures 51.3-52.3 mA, my Russian Mullard EL34s measures 43.3-44.3 mA. My EH 6CA7-EH measures 44.1-44.6. Even my OEM Willsenton KT88s measured 28.3-29.8, not shabby at all (nice to see Willsenton matching the tubes in the amp at the factory). I also bought some NOS Groove Tubes EL34-M tubes last year... One quad meaured 30.7-31.0 mA, a second quad was 32.2-32.7 mA, exemplary matching of tubes.

But I really do like the Psvane Legend EL34-PH tubes... They do sound great, especially with the vintage Ken-Rad and Tung-Sol VT229/231 tubes...
 
In the 20th century, there was a trade organization called the Radio Manufacturer's associstion (RMA) which standardized the naming of tubes in the USA. A company would invent a new tube, and the RMA would issue a name for this tube. The first number is the heater voltage, the letter(s) are a sequential identity given to a specific type tube, and the last number, is the number of "elements" in that tube.

The Europeans had their own separate system which had a letter for heater voltage followed by more letters to designate the type of tube, and then a number to indicate the sequential identity.

Imported tubes that were imported and sold in the USA in any quantity would get registered under an RMA type number, in addition to their original European tag. The 6CA7 type number was introduced in the 1950s, when the Dutch Philips EL34 tube was imported and distibuted by Amperex and the UK EL34 Mullard as well. The Japanese also adopted the 6CA7 designation around this time. These are all pentodes.

The true American beam power 6CA7 came well after 6CA7 tube designation was registered and commonly used, when the US companies developed a domestic alternative to the imported tube. It seems that it has retroactively become known that the beam power tube is a 6CA7, and pentode is EL34 but in reality, both versions of the tube were originally 6CA7 and EL34, and to determine the actual construction of a specific 6CA7 or EL34 tube, it should be examined instead of solely relying on the name.
 
This brings me to the conclusion that Psvane just groups the tested tubes in batches that are kind of close and sells them as is. They even claim that their Amazon exclusive Horizon tubes were burned in for 24-48 hours before packaging to ensure quality control. There are a number of reviews that say the tubes were DOA or noisy right out of the box.

If you want matched Psvane tubes, do NOT buy them off eBay, Amazon or Psvane direct. Buy them from a third party vendor such as Viva tubes who prescreens the tubes prior shipping. I bought a set of Psvane 12AU7-ART and 12AX7-ART tubes from them and they all measured close to each other. My Russian Gold Lion KT-88 quad measures 51.3-52.3 mA, my Russian Mullard EL34s measures 43.3-44.3 mA. My EH 6CA7-EH measures 44.1-44.6. Even my OEM Willsenton KT88s measured 28.3-29.8, not shabby at all (nice to see Willsenton matching the tubes in the amp at the factory). I also bought some NOS Groove Tubes EL34-M tubes last year... One quad meaured 30.7-31.0 mA, a second quad was 32.2-32.7 mA, exemplary matching of tubes.

But I really do like the Psvane Legend EL34-PH tubes... They do sound great, especially with the vintage Ken-Rad and Tung-Sol VT229/231 tubes...

Excellent recommendation on how to buy PSVane tubes. My experiences with PSVane quality control and testing has been the same as yours.
 
I have a set of EH 6CA7 that I like just fine but haven't really compared them to any other 6CA7. I own a set of Shugang but haven't actually listened to them in the same amp so I have no listening impressions for you.

I will say that the EH need a little more negative grid bias than old production. The Shugang need a decent bit less. The Shugang EL34's I had were the same way. The JJ EL34's I've had bias very much like old Euro production EL34 but I know nothing of their 6CA7. On things with limited adjustment range you may run into trouble getting things to bias right.
I bought a Chi- Fi SE EL-34 amp a long time ago as a tinker project. Since it came with two Shuguang EL-34B's, I ordered two more (cheap about 3 years ago) to have a quad of EL-34B's to swap in and out of my HF-87. I was just going to use the 34B's as starter tubes to dial everything in but they have proved to be great so far. Time will tell, but I can't say anything bad about them up to now.
 
I have gone through a bunch of EL34/6CA7 tubes....

The EH 6CA7 is very good for the price but there are better tubes out there.

Going through the tubes that I have tried, my preferences from best to worse... This is according to my use with the Willsenton R8 amplifier paired with my Polk R700 speaers and Oppo BDP-95 player. Tubes will sound different with other brands of tube amplifiers and their circuitry design, so take the ranking with a grain of salt.
  • Mullard EL34 XF2* - The best of the rest, superb sonics and soundstage, Extremely hard to find tubes that are in good condition. Most tubes on eBay are well used and not worth the price but occasionally good ones do appear at a decent price. Going rate, $1500/quad for good tubes.
  • Matsushita 6CA7* - Made in Japan with Mullard tooling. Very good tubes, not quite as good as the original Mullards. Pricing going up as supply diminishes. Tubes have reliability issues and do not have a long operating life. All the ones bought from different sources had low measurements. A couple in sealed boxes had vacuum leaks with white getters. About $500/quad.
  • GE 6CA7* - Very good vintage tube, smooth and warm but getting hard to find. About $600/quad
  • Psvane EL34PH - Psvane's best EL34-type tube, their knock-off of Amperex tubes. Better sonics than their newer ART and Treasure series, has good soundstage. But the tube is very sensitive when paired with different pre-amp tubes. Goes best with Ken-Rad VT231/VT229 or Sylvania VT231/229 tubes or Sylvania 6SN7-GTW metal base and vintage smoked glass Tung-Sol 6SN7/6SL7 tubes. IMHO, probably the best current EL34 tube when paired with good front-end tubes. This tube really sounds mediocre with some front-end tubes (e.g. new Tung-Sols, GE). ~ $420/quad
  • Groove Tubes EL34M* - vintage tube but can be found. This tube is the Groove Tube knock-off of the original Mullard EL34 made by Shuguang. Nice smooth, warm sound. Soundstage average. Note that GT made several variants of the EL34s, only the EL34M are worth considering. . This tube has been harder to find since Groove Tubes ended production in 2008. (NOS tubes can still be found at Watford Valves in UK)... ~$300/quad for NOS
  • Mullard EL34 - Probably the best EL34 in production, which is not saying much. Pretty reliable, warm, average soundstage ~$160/quad
  • Tung-Sol EL34B - Just as good as the above Mullards, but sounds more like a solid state, detailed, clean and crisp. Average soundstage and sonics. ~ $200/quad
  • EH 6CA7 - Good tube for the price, more musical than the following tubes. When I started out with tube amps, I really liked this tube until I started rolling others. Still a good tube. ~$130/quad
  • EH EL34 - Not as warm as the EH 6CA7, clean sound. ~$140/quad
  • Psvane 6CA7-T3 ART - Detailed, clean but not worth the high price. Slightly weak bass. ~$250/quad from China (you gotta pay the tariffs)
  • Psvane 6CA7-Z Treasures - I had high hopes for this tube but I had a couple red-plate within a couple of months. ~$200/quad
  • Psvane EL34-UK - Supposedly it's the Chinese knock-off of Mullard tubes, but it's just okay. ~$160/quad
  • Willsenton EL34 - came with my Willsenton R8. It's bright, thin. Looking at it, mine is a Psvane EL34-C. Yours may be different as Willsenton just buys a bunch of cheap tubes from different OEMs and have them relabelled. The Psvane EL34-C are $100/quad.
  • Sovtek EL34 - A New Sensor tube, weak and thin. ~$180/quad
Note that the Electro-Harmonix, Mullard, Sovtek, Svetlana, Telefunken, Tung-Sol and Genalex (Gold Lion) are all made for New Sensor Corporation sourced from the Russian Saratov in the 1990s. While it is nice that the tubes are still being made, they have not released any updated designs since then. At least the Chinese manufacturers like Shuguang and Psvane have been releasing newer tube designs, but they are getting more expensive.

I find that the Russian tubes are generally more reliable than Chinese tubes. I read that Chinese EL34s normally last about 700-1200 hours and Russian tubes double that but that depends on the tube you get, some tubes may die shortly after purchase or last quite long.
Nice personal review! :thumbsup:

I have had luck with 1990-to early 2000-vintage JJ-E34L tubes. The QA dropped off in the mid-2000s. I have not used them since 2006.

1970-80s Tesla EL34s (especially the #37 factory-made) were the cat's meow. The red E34L and blue glass EL34 ones were sweet. :thumbsup:

Have you tried these?

Thanks!
 
Back
Top Bottom