I'm certainly far from an audiophile, lol, but I've never been a huge fan of Dolby C. IMHO Dolby C muffles the sound too bad to the point of losing crisp highs and just a general lackluster sound. I keep my cassette deck in good working order via cleaning the tape path and demagnetizing, etc. Dolby B on the other hand is a must for me. Any tapes I do automatically get the Dolby B treatment.
I used to think the same thing, about Dolby B or C, until I got and refurbed a Nak RX-505. Dolby C is amazing on a quality NAK. I'm not trying to knock whatever deck you own, but I was used to my high quality Yamaha K960, that I owned since new in the early 80's (so, of course, I knew that Dolby sucked), but now it is clear that it doesn't hold a candle to my 505's. It REALLY makes a huge, huge, difference what tape deck you use. Most pre-recorded tapes played on my Naks sound superb, with Dolby B decoding. The ones that state Dolby HX and B NR, (most of the latter high quality pre-recorded tapes) sound better than many CDs I have, have almost as good S/N for background noise, and the highs are crystal clear. I recently got a hold of a Yamaha K-1020, and it rivals the Naks. I just love finding little used tapes for $.85 at the GW, and listening to a new album, in new condition for pennies!!!