• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Expensive box sets quality or hype?

bobspets

Well-Known Member
I have bought several box sets lately including Dylan's Ten of Swords and Strip Tease after having searched reviews on other sites after not finding any Info. on AK and found all the reviews to be positive. Then been quite disappointed when finding the playback was quite noisy to put it mildly. Kinda perplexed that not a single review mentioned poor quality vinyl.
Anyone else have any experience positive or negative?
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
I have bought several box sets lately after having searched reviews on other sites after not finding any Info. on AK and found all the reviews to be positive. Then been quite disappointed when finding the playback was quite noisy to put it mildly e.g. Dylan's Ten of Swords. Kinda perplexed that not a single review mentioned poor quality vinyl.
Anyone else have any experience positive or negative?

Dylan's Ten of Swords is a 30-year-old bootleg!
 
None of the following box sets I own are what I'd call "expensive." The Hendrix set was only $53 brand new!

Eric Clapton - 9 single, 2 double LP box set, Deutsche Grammophon (German import)
Beatles - "Blue Box" BC-13 (UK import)
John Coltrane - The Heavyweight Champion 12 LP box set, Rhino (USA pressing)
Bob Dylan - Biograph (USA pressing)
Bob Dylan - Tell Tale Signs (USA pressing)
Bob Dylan - The Witmark Demos (USA pressing)
Jimi Hendrix - Winterland (USA pressing)
Elvis Presley - The Complete Singles (Japanese import)

Pressing and sound quality on all of these box sets is above average, without flaw. Based on this experience, I have little reason to not buy box sets.

But those are just a few examples. In addition, I own countless box sets of Classical, Opera, Various Artists compilations, Readers Digest, Franklin Mint, Time Life, and more. Some of the budget labels like Murray Hill, Everest, and Olympia used marginal quality vinyl, for many releases including box sets. Other box sets issued by more reputable labels offered better pressing and sound quality. I have a number of Classical box sets that are German pressings and of very high quality.

Overall, I don't see radical differences in quality of single LP vs. box sets. As always, there some risk in buying a poorly pressed or badly recorded record. No bigger risk with box sets in my experience.
 
I recently bought the Clifford Brown, Max Roach Emarcy reissue box set from Mosaic records. I didn't know what to expect, and it was pretty expensive, $100. So I started a thread on Music forum. Got lots of good advice and experience on the material, the publisher, and the set itself. Based on the that, I bought the set and was very pleased.

Guess the lesson is: if you ask for specific advice, lots of people will chime in.
 
My personal experience is that box sets are just like any other release ... some are good and some are not. I try to to look for information about where the records are pressed and who did the mastering.

I recently bought the grateful dead warners bros lp's box set and the quality is superb. I also got the zeppelin song remains the same box set and it is likewise very nice.
 
I recently bought the Clifford Brown, Max Roach Emarcy reissue box set from Mosaic records. I didn't know what to expect, and it was pretty expensive, $100. So I started a thread on Music forum. Got lots of good advice and experience on the material, the publisher, and the set itself. Based on the that, I bought the set and was very pleased.

Mosaic is an exceptional company. First class all the way. :thmbsp:
 
The only really expensive box-set I have is the Sigur Ros: In a Frozen Sea box. Thing was like $200. And some of the pressings are good, some not so great (noise...need to attempt another cleaning). I really bought it just to have it, as the packaging is the best I have ever seen in a record of any kind, and they're one of my favorite bands. I'd rather listen to them digitally anyway...album sides are too short for a band meant to zone-out to.
 
I recently found a used Bob Dylan Biograph Box Set. The five records are in mint shape, they did not look like they were ever played. The box is VG+, the two insert booklets are also like new. Price was $40. :thmbsp:

When you buy a compilation like this you are at the mercy of how good the original recording/engineering was. It is hard to make each track consistent when the records span several decades and numerous engineers and producers.

I would say that the sound quality is overall very good. Some tracks are excellent sounding and a few are just ok. I would recommend this set to both Dylan fans and those that just seek a well represented and reasonably comprehensive sample of his career.

cheers, Bob
 
Slayer Boxed set it excellent. So is the Dead's. The only other boxed sets I have are all at least 30 years old but they are also excellent.
 
I thought I did the research. All the reviews (And they were extensive) I found on the set I mentioned were positive, not a single mention of poor quality vinyl. The same holds true for other sets I purchased as well. Anybody have the Ten of Swords or Strip Tease box sets?
 
Bootleg releases are always a gamble, particularly older audience recordings, and alot of the feedback you will find will be from die hard fans more interested in the content, focusing their comments/reviews on the material more then the quality of the recording/pressing, etc...
 
Bootleg releases are always a gamble, particularly older audience recordings, and alot of the feedback you will find will be from die hard fans more interested in the content, focusing their comments/reviews on the material more then the quality of the recording/pressing, etc...

I guess it's a lesson learned. By the way damn nice fish! Trout?
 
Back
Top Bottom