Usually flip over styli have a LP rock on one side and a 78 rock on the other, so you want to make sure it's set right for what you're playing. LP is generally something like a 0.7mm conical while the 78 will be in the neighborhood of 3mm.
Also, if you have a ceramic cart on there now, you need to determine if the preamp in your console has a phono stage in it or if you need to stick with a ceramic cartridge. Basically there are three different types of cartridge - ceramic, which outputs a line level signal more or less; moving magnet, which is most of the modern carts on the market today, which requires a RIAA phono preamp; finally, moving coil which is a much lower output than MM and requires either a special phono stage or a step-up transformer to use with a normal RIAA phono stage. Now before dismissing ceramic as obsolete and unworthy of use, unless your system is super high end, it is in fact possible to get pretty good sound out of a ceramic cart, and if you subscribe to the theory that simplicity in the signal path is good, you could make the argument that there are technical advantages to a ceramic.
Yes, before any of the pedants jump in and point out that that was not a complete list, I actually own several MA2002e carts, but I'm talking about what the vast majority of carts available are, not weird outliers like that.
As for your buzzing, how is the TT grounded to the preamp? I would disconnect and reseat the RCA cables (WITH THE POWER OFF) and also check if there is a separate ground wire that it is firmly attached and unbroken. Also maybe R&R the headshell in case one of those contacts is oxidized.