• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Genesis Physics 3 - Improvements?

craig442

New Member
Just picked up these Genesis Physics 3 speakers. I'm told all drivers are original, and were recently re-foamed. I fired them up and they certainly have that nice laid back sound with nice soft highs from that inverted dome tweeter. The re-foam job looks pretty good, although not done as aesthetically nice as I think I would have. I did not hear any voice coil noises when playing music.

I wired them up to my Anthem Home Theater processor and ran a test tone through them to make sure the frequency response was adequate, and they were. But one of the 8" woofers during this test tone did make some noise (the tone sweeps from very deep base to the highs). Not sure if this is a big deal since no noise is heard playing music. The woofers during this test tone really move in and out a bunch! Could it be off center? Is it hard to remove newly applied foam if it is needed?

I will be removing the crossover this weekend to see how the caps look, and was thinking about some improvements functionally (new caps), but mostly aesthetically. Just wanted some thoughts or opinions if these improvements would be good or leaving them stock would be better. While good sound is of course important, as a former cabinet maker I'm a stickler for good aesthetics.

- I need to redo the grill cloth, should l go with the original brown color, typical black, or a beautiful beige cloth (like the old Advents).
- I don't like the Velco pieces to attach the grill, seems very cheesy. I was thinking about adding the plastic grill pegs.
- The mounting plate for the tweeter and midrange have the drivers offset to the left. Each speaker is offset the same. Not sure why they didn't make them mirror images of each other (one offset to left, other offset to right). So I was thinking about making new plates that are mirror images of each other for a symmetrical look.
- Thought about adding some internal braces to help deaden the large cabinet, which you can feel vibrate a bit when playing music with deep base.
- The speakers have real oak veneer, decent shape. Rear and front panel are of course unfinished (painted). Was thinking of applying new walnut veneer, and adding the veneer all around (including rear and front panel) to bring it up to furniture grade looks.
- The woofer and passive radiator have steel frames, and do not have the gasket around the outer edge to hide the area where the foam surrounds are glued (gives it an unfinished look). Has anyone added the gaskets to this area for a cleaner look ? Can probably even paint them green to pay tribute to the old green surrounds that are no longer available.
- The woofer and passive radiator are mounted on top of the front panel. Once again not a finished look. Has anyone recessed the frame to be flush with the front surface (like a few other smaller genesis models)?

Seems like a lot of stuff, but the only pricey step would be purchasing the walnut veneer.
 

Attachments

  • Genesis.jpg
    Genesis.jpg
    96.8 KB · Views: 28
Register to hide this ad
Foam removal depends on the glue they used.
Black cloth.
Your improvements are good ideas, but I think that time and money would better be spent on higher quality speakers.
Leave the velcro, the real wood veneer, mirroring with that little offset is pointless, get a subwoofer before you start bracing, recessing would mess up the alignment, gaskets would look pro audio.

Just go buy a pair of speakers that you're happy with the way they're built, or build your own speakers if you're looking for a project.
You'll get much better sound from the designs out there and can build them exactly how you want, instead of crazy modding $250 speakers that will be hard to sell when you're done.
 
I've gone hog wild doing lots of unnecessary things to speakers when I first got into doing that sort of thing. Done mostly as a learning experience. You need to weigh your time and money against the value of the speakers. If those were mine, I'd just recap, do the grills and be done. What you are thinking will take many hours and be relatively expensive balanced against the value of the speakers(veneer ain't cheap) - anyway, is up to you, do what makes you happy
 
But one of the 8" woofers during this test tone did make some noise (the tone sweeps from very deep base to the highs).

I ran into a problem like that with a pair of speakers I have. At first, I though it was a problem with the woofer. However, in my case, the problem was not the woofer, but that the tweeter was not tight enough against the cabinet, so it would make noise when a particular bass frequency was played loud. All I had to do to fix it was tighten the screws holding the tweeter in place. The hard part was figuring out the fact that the problem was just the tweeter not being properly tight against the cabinet.

I have no idea what the problem is for you, but you can get noise from playing bass tones if something is not properly tightened. It can be anything: the woofer, a tweeter, some other thing that is rattling because it is not properly tightened.

Of course, you need to be careful not to over-tighten anything, or you can strip out the threads of the cabinet.


As for the rest, I would not put a lot of money into these speakers. Maybe new grill cloth, and deal with any scratches on the wood finish. Possibly new capacitors.

- The mounting plate for the tweeter and midrange have the drivers offset to the left. Each speaker is offset the same. Not sure why they didn't make them mirror images of each other (one offset to left, other offset to right).

It costs more to make two versions of a speaker instead of one. Doing them mirror image would make them more expensive speakers. With them all the same, it is one assembly line, all the same. With mirror image, it is two assembly lines, or different versions on the same assembly line, and they need to make sure they make the same number of both.

In this case, since the offset is not that far, doing a mirror image would likely not dramatically affect the sound. But it would affect the price. It is only relatively expensive speakers that they do in mirror image.

Frankly, in the 1970's, when so many speakers had the drivers seemingly randomly placed on the front of the cabinet, I always wondered why they did not just stick them all in a vertical line, as that way, when one is equally distant from the left and right speaker cabinets, one would be equally distant from both woofers, both midranges, both tweeters, etc. And there would be just one version, keeping the manufacturing costs down. Evidently, many speaker companies have since then decided to do speakers all vertical, as that is how most seem to be made these days. What puzzles me is why they did not do it that way from the start.
 
Back
Top Bottom