Speakers in the comparison are:
1) Harbeth C7ES-3
2) Spendor A6R
3) DeVore Fidelity Gibbon 8
4) KEF LS50
5) B&W 685 S2
Let me start by adding that these are just my impressions and bear no resemblance to reality...just my reality.
At the moment three characteristics of a speakers sound stand out to me and are important in how I evaluate a speaker. (1)When I listen to music the most important characteristic is tone. Instruments have to sound like what I hear live and voices as well. Piano, violin, cello and voice are all very good indicators of what the rest of a speakers range will sound like. (2)Another important characteristic in a speaker for me is balance. No one part of the frequency range is more obvious than the other. (3) Lastly is ease. I hate it when a speaker sounds like it is straining or having a difficult time reproducing any part of the frequency that it is capable of.
The speakers I listed above fall all over the place in relationship to those characteristics that I also listed. Only one comes close to perfect and I am listening to them at present. The Harbeth's get all of the elements right. At the price I can literally find no fault in them.
It was the B&W 685 S2's that were the undoing of my Spendor A6R's. How is that? Simple..the 685's literally embarrassed every speaker in the house relative to the tone of some of the important instruments that I mentioned earlier. Sure the 685's are a bit rough around the edges and have more than one weakness, but they get a very important element so correct as to have me shaking my head.
Tops dogs for tone are the Harbeth's followed by the Gibbon 8's and then the B&W's. Dead last are the KEF's. The LS50's paint a fairly monochromatic landscape. Every instrument has to go through a slightly filtered lens before reaching the ears. It's a pleasant coloration but a coloration none the less. The Spendor's are very good on the bottom end up through the lower midrange. Things start to come unglued as the tweeter gets involved. The top is gray and grainy to me. I started to complain quickly after buying them. I also tried to sell them but would always convince myself that I would never own anything that nice again. Perhaps with a better amp and source and so on.
For balance, again the Harbeth's are tops here. Coherent and balanced top to bottom. Everything in perfect order. Second are the KEF's. Very balanced loudspeaker. Nothing about them stands out as wrong sounding, especially when not comparing them to other speakers. The rest are all a bit of a mix. The DeVore's were a bitch to place. I spent more time trying to get their balance right than with any speaker I have owned, with the exception of the Rega R5's. When they were right they were superb (one of the best sound I have had in my home was when my dealer brought over a MasterSound Due Venti amp to drive my Gibbons), when they weren't right they could range from boring to bright. I came to the conclusion that I do not like the arrangement with the tweeter below the woofer. The B&W's are tipped up at the top. Not really fatiguing, but obvious. The Spendor's tweeter is so much a weak point that it caused me no end of hand wringing.
Lastly here is ease. I have to say that the Harbeth's and DeVore's are tied at the top here. Next are the Spendors with the B&W's not as far behind as one would think. The KEF's aren't bad either, especially given their size.
Well there you have a start. It's early so my articulation needs a bit of waking up. If you have any questions about this comparison feel free to ask.