Well first I'm certainly not bashing anyone. But let me offer some valid points of view coming from someone who also has many years of repairing, modding, testing, and building electronics.
1: A headphone amp connected to a main amp will
(should) better the sound from a dedicated headphone amp.
I believe this can never be true. First you assume everyone has a receiver ( since these are the only gear that have built-in power amps ). But if we have separate pre and main amps then there is no way to have the amp "resistered down" to a headphone jack. A preamp will have to have it's own dedicated headphone amp circuit designed, and the chances of the manufacture paying as much attention to that circuit over the rest will most probably be very little.
I didn't assume everyone had a receiver actually I don't know anyone with a receiver, I think I actually said if you only had certain types of equipment you would benefit from a headphone amp, BUT if you have a good quality Hi-Fi amp you are not going to necessarily notice a big difference
2: Having a power amp resistered down to a headphone jack presents many problems. First you will not be able to adjust the headphone amp impeadance to match specific headphones.
As you can't with most headphone amplifier's
3: You can vary the "sound" of the headphone amp by swapping OP AMPS, tubes, power supplies, etc. This means that you can tweak the sound and performance even further to your liking, to your particular headphones, and to your source equipment. Using Class A amp circuit, tubes, OP AMPs, or any combination means more precise and accurate control of the headphones as opposed to a "one size fits all" design of a built-in headphone jack on a receiver.
Most amplifiers have tone controls
I also wonder how many people including yourself would hear these tweaks in a ABY situation.
4: Placebo effect. Personally I view the placebo effect as what a person would hear ( or not hear ) when he has no true frame of reference for comparison. Basically, if you never made a direct comparison, then how can you make an accurate judgement? It's true that many people will WANT to hear a difference since they paid good money for their gear. But there are also many, many more people who have made more accurate and truthful claims based on experience, comparisons, and a willing to learn by being non-judgmental. The the majority agree that, at least in this topic, a dedicated headphone amp will sound more natural, is a better combination, and will bring out the performance of the headphones much better than a receivers headphone jack.
5: Looking pretty in pictures. I've owned many gear that while it looked awesomely pretty, sounded like total garbage. Just because it looks pretty in pictures is no guarantee it will perform decent. I do believe, however, that posting pictures of your gear will give more validity and weight to a persons opinions and comments simply because of the gear that he owns. Saying you heard a friends gear a few years ago is not the same as saying you own the gear and hear it on a daily basis when making a comment.
I just buy and sell gear not listen to other peoples as you have to live with it for a while, even now I can put my Grado's on one day and I am in musical heaven other days they sound tinny and fatiguing.
Hey, we all have opinions, and we here at AK want to hear everyones opinion. But we don't want to hear negative opinions with no real-world facts. To blanket all headphone amps as a complete waste of money is a pretty bold statement, and unless you want to avoid the voices of real-world users coming at you from all sides with "their opinions" at being offended that you just told them they spent their hard earned money on garbage you'd better be ready to accurately back up your statement.
I think I have said in a couple of posts it is down to personal personal preference, it seems you are the only one who is offended. I'm sure your little dot sounds very nice as do many Hi-Fi amplifiers.
---Peace--
Jimmy