• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Home audio VS. Pro Audio

freddypete

New Member
So I'm from both sides of the spectrum... I love hi-fi, but am also a studio engineer. Sometimes I like to pose this question.... What is the real difference?

Studio nuts say hi-fi is not fit for the studio due to low quality and hight noise ratios... but Hi-Fi nuts pay top dollar for gear studio owners would deem unuseable to produce the records you all are listening to.

My question is this:

Why do hi-fi nuts not use pro gear? is it the different cables used? seems like a pro studio preamp would be leagues better than a consumer made one. I've always wondered about this.... also, why not use hi-fi amps in the studio? all you need to do is boost the DB from -6 to +10 and use short runs of cable to eliminate any hum you might have gained from not having a balanced connection.

Basically. WHO IS RIGHT?

studio nuts or audiophiles
:lurk:
 
Register to hide this ad
I guess people buy home audio for tone (especially tubes), and pro audio for neutrality (or power).

But e.g. Electrocompaniet and Dynamic Presiscion amps are used in studios, as well as B&W speakers, and pro power amps and crossovers are popular in some hi-fi circles. So no one is right.

I use a Yamaha PC2602 power amp in my main system, and it sounds d*mn good to me.
 
I've owned some Yamahas (CR-2040), McIntosh (MC-2102), Wright 2A3's, Jolida (tubed, forget model), Transcendent SE-OTL's, dbx (BX1), dbx (BX3), Viva 300B SET, Quad's (Kt66 version) and now, some Crown K2's.

I still have the Yamaha, primarily because it's in storage and I've owned it through college in the early 80's. I've sold everything else but the dbx BX3 and the Crown K2's. I'm currently USING the K2's.

Excellent amp as far as I'm concerned. I'm keeping the others for when my basement is finished (if ever) and everything goes to its final resting place. I might want to blend in the 3 channel dbx amp for HT duty.
 
...all you need to do is boost the DB from -6 to +10

This part I disagree with, the rest all I'll say is I use both.

I've looked at the input sensitivity of lots of consumer/home amps and lots of pro amps and it goes both ways. Many are very similar, ~1.5V give or take, some consumer have higher or lower input sensitivity than pro amps and vice versa.

The +4dBu vs -10dBV thing moreso applies to fixed level devices like a pro audio tape deck output level vs a consumer/home tape deck output level.
 
Last edited:
Pros also want repeatability. Industry standards like the Yamaha NS10, JBL LSR series, 4430, 4310, Altec 604 and so on are/were ubiquitous because they are tools of the trade. Engineers use these tools to read the mix.

Real-world consumer experience embodies that professional output trough a pair of speakers. One pair of thousands available, in uncontrolled enviroments, built to suit a plethora of tastes.

Of the available models, why not choose the exact same speakers used to master the original audio? The speakers the artists stood in front of in the control room or green room and nodded in subtle acceptance of their final product.

Well, the requirements of home audio vary depending on the user's requirements and budget, for one. Many pro monitors were large, not acceptable in some cases. Some consumers are looking for a particular sound or effect, and a monitor will not suit.

So, it is a highly individualized process that happens when an end-user finally decides on the gear to use. In fact, it may be evolution that decides what we wind up with, going through candidates and casting off those that do not measure up.
 
Neither group is correct, IMHO. This has been discussed ad nauseum here at elsewhere on the 'net.

My take on the threads: It depends.

I use both types of gear - and happily.

Cheers,

David
 
I have 9 units meant for studio use in my set-up among 42 units all in all.

However there is just as much trash in the pro music/hifi world as there is in the consumer music/hifi world.

So matching quality product for achieving synergy counts just as much in the pro world.
This is partly why we experience some very few published music in between to be wonderful high quality and most is just mediocre or directly bad produced.

"dolph"
 
But e.g. Electrocompaniet and Dynamic Presiscion amps are used in studios, as well as B&W speakers, and pro power amps and crossovers are popular in some hi-fi circles.

Aaaarrr... (I'm a pirate today)... you beat me to the punch. I know that B&W speakers (in the Nautilus 800 series) are used both at Abbey Road and Peter Gabriel's Real World studios.

B&W provides its dealers with a demo CD of tracks all recorded at Abbey Road (I presume it helps to improve the overall listening experience if you're listening on the same speakers the music was mastered on). I was lucky enough to get a copy of it. It's pretty nice as a demonstration of just how good CDs can sound, too.

http://assets.bowers-wilkins.com/med/Libraries/3/01-Abby-Road_l2_w357_h268.jpg
 
There is both great-sounidng pro-gear, and not-so-great sounding pro gear. And there is both some amazing sounding consumer gear, and some lousy sounding consumer gear.

Pro gear tends to be designed more for ultimate reliability, and for best specs. High-end consumer gear tends to be designed more for a more subjective goal of great sound, often times without regards to specs, or reliability.

Some studios do use consumer amps. Consumer preamps simply do make not sense in a studio becuase they are not designed to do what you need a preamp to do (amplify mics, not phonographs).

I know one local mastering lab which uses some high-end consumer speakers and amps as his reference. He will only use what he considers to be the best, regardless of the source, or price.

http://pugetsoundstudios.com/

(no affiliation, but I do know this person: Mods please delete this link if you think that it is inappropriate)
 
Last edited:
There is both great-sounidng pro-gear, and not-so-great sounding pro gear. And there is both some amazing sounding consumer gear, and some lousy sounding consumer gear.

Pro gear tends to be designed more for ultimate reliability, and for best specs. High-end consumer gear tends to be designed more for a more subjective goal of great sound, often times without regards to specs, or reliability.

Some studios do use consumer amps. Consumer preamps simply do make not sense in a studio becuase they are not designed to do what you need a preamp to do (amplify mics, not phonographs).

I know one local mastering lab which uses some high-end consumer speakers and amps as his reference. He will only use what he considers to be the best, regardless of the source, or price.

http://pugetsoundstudios.com/

(no affiliation, but I do know this person: Mods please delete this link if you think that it is inappropriate)

Yep, some very good mastering engineers also use high-end consumer speakers & amps:

http://www.mastermindproductions.net/

je
 
speaking as another recording engineer/hifi nut/pro musician, I can say a few points for sure, although I don't think they help define any particular group:

- some hifi nuts own/prefer gear that is every bit as accurate as the best studio gear (including myself)
- some hifi nuts own/prefer gear that rolls off the highs, emphasizes certain other frequency ranges, uses speaker dispersion technics you'd never be able (or choose) to use in a studio (such as dipole/omni which might be more useful in a home setting where people walk around rather than sit in the ideal listening seat as in a studio control room)
- many studios with outboard analog gear own gear that is exceptionally inaccurate but there for musical reasons (certain tape machines, compressors like my home built 1176, tube preamps that emphasize the mids (great for certain vocals, terrible for others), and so on)

Other than repeatability/mobility (such as my nemesis, the ns-10), there is also the fact that all control rooms are acoustically very different from almost all home listening rooms. So the same speakers, setup the same way, will sound very different. In homes we try to get a great sound in a crappy room, so there are so many compromises and there is so much room for experimentation so things fit into our lifestyles and choices of music that it's just a different situation.

The fact that I listen on (very listenable) studio monitors, AND on great classic but still very revealing home hifi speakers, and with very revealing studio-quality preamp/power amp combinations, is my own choice but also a design decision. I make music as a job, so I really don't want to get used to listening to something that alters the sound (sansui preamps, AR speakers, what have you). But I do like to use setups like that for listening reference later on, and I completely acknowledge that they may, in fact, make many recordings of a certain style of music sound better overall to one's ears than more accurate, flat speakers could, unless you're used to listening to accurate, flattish, revealing systems (as I am).

It's personal choice - in one's home, who really cares? do waht fits your needs. I do! :-)
 
Yep, some very good mastering engineers also use high-end consumer speakers & amps:

http://www.mastermindproductions.net/

je

I fully agree with that concept, although not as a rule for everyone (whatever works for each engineer is what matters!)

- most studios I've worked in, my own included (to an extreme in my case), have at least one type of average home stereo setup for listenign comparisons. In my case I have several, all easily enabled for playback monitoring.

It's easier than thinking I've done everything just right, no matter how well I know my monitors, only to burn it, take it somewhere and play it back on a system that is really bizarre and finding out it sounds crappy (like one of those huge 5 year old jvc "mini" systems with uber-loud servo powered single note subs, or like my car system which is frustratingly uneven while still sounding not too bad... a situation that I think happens rather often).
 
- most studios I've worked in, my own included (to an extreme in my case), have at least one type of average home stereo setup for listenign comparisons. In my case I have several, all easily enabled for playback monitoring.

More on this.... is that I've heard /read some studios actually have basically a "cheap" factory car speaker set up to see how it sounds on that because that's often the first exposure people get to a new song is in their car on the radio.

Dunno if it's true, but I seemed to make some sense to me, and certainly seems to fit in with the whole "loudness wars" and mastering for Ipods, etc. :dunno:
 
definitely. I've seen that in a couple of locations, although it's certainly not common in my experience. I have some extra car speakers, I should do exactly that. good call :-)

I NEED to take up more space in my tiny studio LoL
 
I fully agree with that concept, although not as a rule for everyone (whatever works for each engineer is what matters!)

- most studios I've worked in, my own included (to an extreme in my case), have at least one type of average home stereo setup for listenign comparisons. In my case I have several, all easily enabled for playback monitoring.

It's easier than thinking I've done everything just right, no matter how well I know my monitors, only to burn it, take it somewhere and play it back on a system that is really bizarre and finding out it sounds crappy (like one of those huge 5 year old jvc "mini" systems with uber-loud servo powered single note subs, or like my car system which is frustratingly uneven while still sounding not too bad... a situation that I think happens rather often).

Agreed- especially your first line.

On the desk next to my recording desk are mini-versions of my main monitors (6.5" woofs + same silk-dome tweets as the 10" 3-ways + sub). Then, the very first thing you see when you walk out of my control room is a boom box. Within a few feet of that is a DiscMan into a mixer into a Crown into JBL L100s. A few more feet, and there's a surround system with sub & 8" 2-ways with aluminum dome tweets.. Upstairs, bi-amped big-ass 15" 3-ways with horn mids & ring radiator tweets, or a surround system + sub with 8" 2-ways & Ti tweets. Up another flight, a Nak system with dual push-pull subs & Ti tweets. An iPod brings WAV files out to the Pioneer system in the van.

All of the systems sound good on their own (even the boom box), but still vary in tone & overall quality/outright performance (partly due to the room's/vehicle's listening environments). Also, none of them have tone controls engaged except the van & boombox (mid-cuts, usually). One of the most useful checks I do while mixing is listen to the previous day's mixes by blasting the bedroom system while showering in the bathroom about 20' away- if I can follow the bass line, solos are clear, and the vocals are sitting where I want them to within all the other instruments, I know I'm in pretty good shape.

je
 
definitely. I've seen that in a couple of locations, although it's certainly not common in my experience. I have some extra car speakers, I should do exactly that. good call :-)

I NEED to take up more space in my tiny studio LoL

True/funny story- when I first got a removable car stereo (not just the face, the whole head unit), I installed another sleeve in my bedroom wall with a 12V DC supply & recessed 6 x 9"s, and that's how I double-checked the mixes I was making (on to cassette, at the time). :yes: My van at that time had Minimus 7s, too.

je
 
True/funny story- when I first got a removable car stereo (not just the face, the whole head unit), I installed another sleeve in my bedroom wall with a 12V DC supply & recessed 6 x 9"s, and that's how I double-checked the mixes I was making (on to cassette, at the time). :yes: My van at that time had Minimus 7s, too.

je

brilliant! I had a deck like that at one time, never thought of doing somethign so clever :-) although I wasn't as much an engineer back then as a performing musician, so my priorities have changed. Too bad you don't see that design any more, just for the reason you pointed out.

I'll be setting up my kenwood 2 way component speakers (5.25" plus 1" dome tweets plus passive crossover boxes) in my studio asap...... I bought them a year ago and never used them because my car is incredibly difficult to replace speakers in and I won't pay anyone to do it for me because I'm cheap.

So ironically these speakers will actually be somewhat better than what my car actually has (which is stock chrysler components, no not chrylser infinitys...), although with my jvc car deck's custom eq tweaked to the max it does sound quite decent overall so I'm hoping to approximate that at home, or at least approximate some people's car systems.

This thread sparked a light inside me and I just spent 15 minutes creatively and effectively stream-of-consciousness style writing a long list of things I will do to reorganize my home studio. Completely moving things around, changing my speaker locations, how they're interconnected, switched, and so on... should be a lot of work but also a big improvement!

The last step out of around 30 was "replace drivers in my cts/mirage mini speakers with kenwood 2 way component car speakers + xovers and locate as if in door panels".

As a result I'll then have an unmounted pair of mirage 750 5" midrange drivers (which were the woofers in these mini speakers) sitting in my driver drawer LoL. Along with several pairs of 8" woofers (philips, infinity, chinanoname) and a stack of crossovers and 4 foster 3.5" horn tweeters. I HAVE to do something with that stuff...

cheers,
Don
 
Back
Top Bottom