• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

IGD, how about some good examples?

I don't think anybody really knows what IGD actually sounds like or if it really is that they are hearing. Most of the time, I believe it's stylus or record damage.

Doug
 
What’s amazing is that on YouTube, if you type “examples of LP inner groove distortion,” You get a LOT of talking heads explaining what IGD is and how to fix it, but few really good examples. :( Often the audio quality is poor, so you don’t know whether it’s recording artifacts or a really bad track. :(

This is about the best example I could find. The vocals are less focused.

Compare to this example. You need to adjust for differences in recording volume.
 
Is that off the Tacet Test Record? I never listened to that side of the LP.

Very obvious examples.

:thumbsup:
Yes Tacet test record. The same tracks are also recorded in the outer groove. With significant better reproduction. The tracks are there to illustrate the difference between inner and outer grooves.
 
Yes Tacet test record. The same tracks are also recorded in the outer groove. With significant better reproduction. The tracks are there to illustrate the difference between inner and outer grooves.
That’s the best test record that I own. I have a Shure Obstacle Course Type V. The Tacet is better for anti-skate settings and resonance testing.

You have to find a used one now. I think it’s been out of print for a while. :(
 
The Tacet is better for anti-skate settings
You can't really use a test record for anti-skating settings because the skating force is highly dependant on the modulation of the groove (signal strenght) and all anti-skating test records are either based on no modulation (blank record) or modulation that is way too high (to the point that there is loss of contact to the groove wall).
Both are not representative for normal signal strenght thus per definition you'll end up with the wrong antiskating setting (as in too high, but unknown how much too high).
That said, the 'right amount of anti skating force' is also a question in itself. Is the right amount of antiskating force the compensation force during quiet passages in the music, or during 'average' music strenght, or during maximum music strength (usually the chorus in pop music)? Also different records from different era's vary quite a bit in this sense, but they are never on the level of a test record modulation track to set antiskate. That difference is easily 3 times that. We're talking about regions of +12dB from a level that is virutally already never seen in the loudest peaks normal music.

As for resonance testing, the Tacet record has a really strong resonance track, which results into an interesting insight tot the point that stylii can loose groove wall contact or even jump the groove. However, that is also not a real world scenario. Both compliance and damping don't have to be the same per say at the extreme amplitudes of the cantilever suspension as they are at minor amplitudes. For real world implementations and experimentation, a test track from say the Firato test record is more useful.
Those tracks have way less amplitude and also miss their pilot tones so they are purely ment for research with an oscilloscope or spectrum analyzer but they represent a more representative situation that could occur at normal playback.
Won't make much difference in the resonance frequency but it would in determining damping characteristics of suspension.
 
Last edited:
You can't really use a test record for anti-skating settings because the skating force is highly dependant on the modulation of the groove (signal strenght) and all anti-skating test records are either based on no modulation (blank record) or modulation that is way too high (to the point that there is loss of contact to the groove wall).
The Tacet anti-skate track has various modulation (loudness) levels. From very low levels to very loud. That’s what makes it better than most test records.

I like both the SKATING and RESONANCE tracks. To me, they work for setting parameters. Simple, too!

:thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom