I agree they're overpriced, although repairable (grille frames will probably be hard to find). The worn upper corners are due to the grilles; they're held on by gravity alone, and centering them can be difficult, even when everything else is correct. I'm assuming the woofers are correct; although obviously one dust cap has been replaced, they look otherwise identical. But there also appears to be some rust on the right AMT. I think $200-$300 is closer to the correct price, and I'd be hesitant at the latter.
ETA: my AMT-1Cs had double dust caps (i.e. one larger one over another, smaller one) on the woofers. Although I don't see a glue trace, I wonder if the right side woofer is just missing the outer cap. The left one looks correct.