• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

IT WENT LIKE THIS...SO CLOSE.

quiet

Addicted Member
I picked up a soon to be nice pair of working KLH 17s with the wrong tweeters. The tweeters had been replaced with Realistic 8 ohm dome units that don't cover any of the midrange as the original 17 tweeter did.
They sounded pretty bad.
Some 3.3 ohm caps or somethings had been added at the tweeters to make the speaker 8 ohms again.
I think this was done because the KLH tweeter itself is 4 ohm not 8. So when I replaced the Realistic tweeters with a pair of correct 17 tweeters I had on hand I just removed the 3.3uf whatever it is along with the Realistic tweeters. The tweeter wiring looked original otherwise.

Did I remove the woofers and check the crossover wiring for changes also? Noooo, as a rookie why would I?
When I plugged them in and fired them up they sounded much better for about 10 minutes at low volume. By then I was thinking this is great.
So I turned them up some more. They sounded great, for about 5 seconds. Then left crackle......... right crackle ....... no more mid or tweeter sound.
Turns out the crossovers had been completely by passed and the tweeters were running full range in an effort to get more out of that realistic tweeter that was never doing to get the job done.
More caps and tweets on the way. Love this hobby.
 

Attachments

  • P3260001.JPG
    P3260001.JPG
    46.5 KB · Views: 86
  • P3260002.JPG
    P3260002.JPG
    28.1 KB · Views: 86
Register to hide this ad
Sounds like you blew the tweets. Sorry to hear that. Those RS tweeters were actually pretty good, so you might want to keep them around for a more suitable project.

Good luck with the KLH 17's. They are nice when working as designed.
 
3.3 ohm cap and 3.3µF whatever

You mean a 3.3 microfarad capacitor. Ohm is a measure of resistance. Farad is a measure of capacitance and since that is a lot the u or µ symbol is used to indicate micro. A 3.3µF cap going to the tweeter will be a high pass filter only allowing higher frequencies through. The value of the cap is determined using the impedance of the driver and the frequency of the cut off wanted.

The replacement tweeter was used like many tweeters in less expensive speakers, run with a full range woofer and crossed over with a high pass filtering capacitor. EPI does this, more companies do, too.
 
I see. Thank you. So I would have been ok if I had left the 3.3. What about the total speaker ohms?
Yes it definitely fried the tweeters
 
3.3 ohm cap and 3.3µF whatever

You mean a 3.3 microfarad capacitor. Ohm is a measure of resistance. Farad is a measure of capacitance and since that is a lot the u or µ symbol is used to indicate micro. A 3.3µF cap going to the tweeter will be a high pass filter only allowing higher frequencies through. The value of the cap is determined using the impedance of the driver and the frequency of the cut off wanted.

The replacement tweeter was used like many tweeters in less expensive speakers, run with a full range woofer and crossed over with a high pass filtering capacitor. EPI does this, more companies do, too.

Running without a cross-over on the woofer is usually a cost-cutting move. KLH did that with the 17's. With the more expensive KLH Sixes, they did put a cross-over on the woofer. That is the only difference between the cross-overs of the 17's and Sixes. Running a woofer free - without cross-over will run it through the "breakup" region and that usually isn't desireable.
 
More bad news. The new tweeter seller has replied that upon checking they are open resistance.
The hunt is on.
 
Plenty out there.
Just look up a photo of a regular Model 17 crossover and rebuild it accordingly. Should be numerous threads here as well as over at classicspeakerpages.
 
>>What about the total speaker ohms?

If you're asking what the 8 ohm RS tweeter did to the overall system, it was not the worst of your problems. It would have created a higher impedance in the upper range, which might result in lower output, but that's dependent on the sensitivity of the RS vs. the original driver. A change in the opposite direction can be dangerous (replacing an 8 ohm driver with a 4), especially with woofers, because it can easily overstress the amp. Also it changes the actual crossover frequency by a factor of 2, so even if everything else is the same - even if you have two otherwise identical drivers with 4 and 8 ohm voice coils - it's going to change the sound of the speaker.

None of this was what killed the tweeters, it was driving them with no cap and a full range signal going to them.
 
Maybe someone in Bartertown has some KLH 17 tweeters sitting around.
>>What about the total speaker ohms?

If you're asking what the 8 ohm RS tweeter did to the overall system, it was not the worst of your problems. It would have created a higher impedance in the upper range, which might result in lower output, but that's dependent on the sensitivity of the RS vs. the original driver. A change in the opposite direction can be dangerous (replacing an 8 ohm driver with a 4), especially with woofers, because it can easily overstress the amp. Also it changes the actual crossover frequency by a factor of 2, so even if everything else is the same - even if you have two otherwise identical drivers with 4 and 8 ohm voice coils - it's going to change the sound of the speaker.

None of this was what killed the tweeters, it was driving them with no cap and a full range signal going to them.
Yep, no protection. Rookie move on my part not to catch it.
 
I may move on to recapping my model 5s and sell these woofers. Besides, I'm not liking the full range woofer thing already.
I do understand these 17s are good speakers. But if the 5s sound better I would rather fret over them.
 
I've got it in my head that what I really want is a single pair of 6' tall, 4' wide, 3' deep sealed box speakers.
That I don't have to build myself.
Instead of what I have which surprising as it may seem sounds great when run all together.
Yes I use a speaker selector switch that shows the receiver 8 ohm, works great. Like you might use for whole house sound.
I think I'll ask for recommendations in a new thread.
 

Attachments

  • P2160001 (1).JPG
    P2160001 (1).JPG
    70.6 KB · Views: 34
I've got it in my head that what I really want is a single pair of 6' tall, 4' wide, 3' deep sealed box speakers.
That I don't have to build myself.
Instead of what I have which surprising as it may seem sounds great when run all together.
Yes I use a speaker selector switch that shows the receiver 8 ohm, works great. Like you might use for whole house sound.
I think I'll ask for recommendations in a new thread.
You run all of those speakers together?
 
You run all of those speakers together?
YES, absolutely. I may at times delete a pair or two depending on the music. Can't do that with just one pair.
I don't know image, resolution, stage, air, accurate and so on...............even though I've been fortunate to here lots of plenty pricey speakers.
All were way way better than very impressive. And yes all sounded different to me.
This sounds like all of them but none of them.
I think I can hear all the music all the time. I constantly hear things I hadn't heard before, not occasionally.
I want to have ONE pair that sounds like THIS.
And I want it for no more than ten 10 grand.
 
The tweeter is the same as in the 5, 6, 20 and 23 according to an ebay ad for a pair of tweeters.

I notice that whole working speakers are going for well over $100 on there so if your cabinets are OK it might be worthwhile to just pop in some tweeters.
 
The tweeter is the same as in the 5, 6, 20 and 23 according to an ebay ad for a pair of tweeters.

I notice that whole working speakers are going for well over $100 on there so if your cabinets are OK it might be worthwhile to just pop in some tweeters.
Yep, what to do what to do......
 
Back
Top Bottom