If it's emotion you're after, I can't recommend the Audire Legato enough in that price range. I don't think it's a coincidence that the Audire, looking like a little guitar rack processor, captures emotion better than the receiver sized-C-85. Of all the gear I've had through here, it seems with all of it, the more involved the preamp/preamp section, the less of the emotional impact is carried through to the amp/speakers. The Audire is very simple if you look inside, but what's there is top quality. Very clean, very smooth sounding, excellent phono stage. All of this is opinion, of course, some people like to have a million tone controls (the audire has none), but I don't miss them. I really get sucked into the music with this thing. Since I got it, any other preamp I've tried hasn't lasted more than a day before I put the Audire back. It may not be the most accurate preamp...it seems to add a hint of midrange 'bloom' that I like, which is one thing I also like about tube preamps, at least vintage ones. It has a 'fat' sound.
I have to say that part of this must be some sort of synergy with my power amp, a really sweet, smooth sounding Robert Grodinsky Research unit (he lived up in Skokie or Evanston, north of Chicago). But for preamps in the $200 range, I don't know what I would recommend that would be better. There are probably some really nice, simple preamps from the '90s that get overlooked. A lot of the '90s high end gear is going for really cheap it seems. The Audire is from around 1980...designer was a former Apollo moon-landing engineer.