• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Lineaum Tweeters...Why?

Theophilus Punoval

The Queen says it's OK...
Radio Shack bought into them during the Optimus and RCA eras but, as far as I know (and it ain't much!) no other companies did. This could a matter of Lineaum collapsing financially, getting signed to an exclusive contract that hamstrung their business or a mediocre, overpriced product or two or three.

Was it a bank brouhaha like the ones that took out Genesis? Are Lineaum speakers not that great and didn't sell well enough? Or did Radio Shack tie Lineaum to a sinking ship?

There were any numbers of reasons as to why Radio Shack went toes up. From the late 1990s on it was the retail version of the Ottoman Empire a century earlier, so it's easy to see them bringing a supplier with them. On the other hand, other companies didn't seem very interested in the technology.

Finally, were they good or hype?
 
Register to hide this ad
My impression of RS is that originally they were a supplier of parts for the electronics hobbyist. As time went by, they mostly got out of parts and sold products like cell phones & other gadgets.
 
I suspect that as time went by, the number of people experimenting with electronic circuits dwindled, and RS had to sell more popular assembled items, while still maintaining an image of an electronics store. Places like Digi Key and Mouser took over the electronic parts business and offered vastly more selection.
 
RS appeared to want to dabble in a lot of things, not a completely focused electronics components store, nor a focused audio store, nor a focused HT store, etc. I do recall they had a "catalog", but I do not recall the extent of their catalog offering versus in-store. I do recall they sold a lot of TV antennas back in the day (not much competition there, at least pre-internet), and it seemed everyone had their sound level meter for audio system tuning.
image
 
Always wanted to Try Optimus LX5 speakers but could never find the right pair. Either the Lineaum tweeters were crinkled or the woofer foam was shot.
 
Can't speak for Linaeum in general, but Radio Shack was still going strong when they came out with the Linaeum speakers. Some of them got some pretty good reviews, including this semi-famous old article on the inexpensive LX-4. To my knowledge, the Linaeum tweeters were made under license by other companies, rather than being constructed by Linaeum. The actual tweeters used in Linaeum's own speakers used different (i.e. more expensive), lower mass diaphragms. I can't imagine that the deal was a bad thing for Linaeum; after all, they were hardly a household name before, and the agreement certainly increased their market awareness. There was little if any overlap between the Optimus and Linaeum-branded models, at least price-wise, although the Optimus LX-5 did superficially resemble the Linaeum LFX (of course, the latter was almost an order of magnitude more expensive).
 
I called Linaeum back in the '90s, hoping to buy a pair of their tweeters. The Radio Shack deal hadn't been announced yet, but the guy who took my call told me about it; he may have been owner, I don't remember. He was giddy with excitement, said they were all drinking champagne and dancing, and I heard choruses of happy laughter in the background.

He wouldn't sell me Linaeum tweeters separately — company policy — but offered to send me a pair of the RS version for free. True to his word, they arrived three days later. They came in a plain box, and they were a gift: no charge.

They were not the RS version, but one of the prototypes RS commissioned them to design, and based their version on (probably with further compromises). They may have been better than RS, or halfway between. I think I still have them somewhere.

The tweeters themselves didn't matter, it was the spirit of the gift, and the excitement he shared with me, like I was a member of the family.
 
^ ^ None of those scenarios applied to me, so I never inquired, and it was 25 years ago, so you must seek a better source if you really care.
 
As an owner of a pair of Linaeum LT1000 speakers, that have the 6" high TLS tweeter / midrange, I have to say that I have heard nothing better, in my ~40 years of hifi. This driver is unique, and it has a lot going for it.


The Radio Shack version of the 1 1/2" high Linaeum tweeter is what got my attention - I first heard it at a Boston Audio Society demo at Goodwin's Audio, of one of the very first 24bit/96kHz digital recordings. The fellow had made simultaneous 16bit/44.1kHz and 24bit/96kHz recordings - and demonstrated this with a pair of LX-5 Radio Shack speakers.

It was no contest - and every one of the 40-50 people in the room could hear the qualitative differences. And that convinced me, both of how good higher resolution digital recordings could be - and how good the lowly LX-5 speakers were.

As tweeters, they are dipole (or other versions are monopole), and they have variable surface area - lower frequencies radiate farther along the curved leaves, and therefore push more air. As the frequency goes up, they radiate from a narrower and narrower area - and they approach a line source at the highest frequencies.

Same goes for the taller version used in some of the Linaeum speakers - except they cover down well into the midrange. My speakers are crossed over at 440Hz. Which is simply amazingly good sounding. Talk about coherent and clear and dynamic. It is about 94-95dB at 1W. It has very wide horizontal dispersion - but its biggest weakness is limited vertical dispersion; in the 6" high monopole version, anyway.
 
I think both were swept away by the rapid changes in technology which happened since the mid 90s. The stereo system is no longer a fixture of American living rooms, and a majority of the equipment and gadgets which were Radio Shack's bread and butter 25 years ago, are obsolete. Heck never mind Radio Shack, even Technics left the mass market and remember how big they were?

DIY electronics is all but a dead hobby, nobody buys clock radios, or ham radios, or shortwave radios. Hardly anyone upgrades their car stereo anymore. Home stereos are on life support, and I haven't seen a do it yourself burglar alarm in years. Answering machines, and extension phones? TV antennas and masts? Look through an old catalog and it's hard to find many items which would still sell enough today to be in every mall in America.
 
Paul Paddock - the designer of the Linaeum TLS driver, is still working. He has updated the driver - it is now called WBLS for wideband line source. The company is called MC Audiotech: http://mcaudiotech.com/

The WBLS driver in the 10 driver partial spherical array - is crossed over at 100Hz, to the two 18" subwoofers. It is quite efficient at about 93-95dB.

They make only the Forty-10 speaker, which sells for a mere $35K - and that points to why we don't have nearly as many companies making lower cost speakers, that are actually high fidelity.

forty_10_full_narrow.jpg
 
They make only the Forty-10 speaker, which sells for a mere $35K - and that points to why we don't have nearly as many companies making lower cost speakers, that are actually high fidelity.
forty_10_full_narrow.jpg
I hope those guys (there appear to be at least two at that company) have other jobs, because with a single niche luxury product in a bad economy, I can't imagine they're selling very many right now.
 
Agreed! I did email them, and inquired about whether they would be making something like a current version of the LT1000 speakers - using the dipole WBLS driver with a 8" (or maybe a 10") woofer in a transmission line cabinet. I suggested a name - the Forty-1 (since it would use 1 WBLS driver per side) - and I was told no, they were not considering this.

Which makes me sad and disappointed, frankly. Paul Paddock invented a wonderful driver, that has many excellent qualities - it is I think, a masterpiece.
 
My [LT1000] speakers are crossed over at 440Hz. Which is simply amazingly good sounding. Talk about coherent and clear and dynamic. It is about 94-95dB at 1W. It has very wide horizontal dispersion - but its biggest weakness is limited vertical dispersion; in the 6" high monopole version, anyway.
From Middle C to supersonic. Insane. And a commercial failure...?
 
Linaeum tweeters were used in the top several speaker models offered by Radio Shack for six or seven years when Radio Shack had ~ 7000 retail locations. I can't imagine that being bad for Linaeum unless they had simply negotiated a bad deal for themselves.

I saw a magazine ad during the late '90s for a speaker utilizing Linaeum tweeters. I can't be certain of the brand name now, but I recall it was one I associated with televisions. I think it was Toshiba.
 
From Middle C to supersonic. Insane. And a commercial failure...?

It is a driver that is counterintuitive, and seems to break the rules - but it is the real deal. It has variable effective width, as I mention. The flexibility of the curved leaves is the key - at lower frequencies, they propagate out farther along the arc, and move more air. As the frequency goes up, they don't propagate as far, and so the horizontal dispersion is kept wider than many tweeters, because it acts very close to a line source.

I am using 4th order Linkwitz Riley 24dB/octave slopes at 440Hz on the miniDSP 2x4 HD. With the EQ for each driver, and the speaker as a whole, this is the in room response curve:
index.php

The dips at 100Hz and 180Hz are (probably) floor cancellations. This is setup to a so-called room curve: flat from 200Hz to 1kHz, with 1dB/octave rise below 200Hz, and 0.5dB/octave drop above 1kHz - so +3dB at 20Hz, and -3dB at 20kHz.
 
I have one lx-5, keeping my eyes open for a second.

It makes an excellent center channel speaker. The airy nature of the tweeter really shows IMHO.

There's been more than a few speakers over the years that have an "open" top end, dahlquist, ohm, etc. These are the smallest of that style I've ever heard. Personally I prefer that openness, and how it doesn't sound like a tweeter mounted to a board.

It also blends better with the horns on my kg4.2s than anything else I've tried.
 
Back
Top Bottom