Had a Grado Black, thought it was a fair sounding cartridge for the money spent. Something I would happily put on a TT that I was selling. Bought a Grado Green as an upgrade and thought WTF, this thing isn't as good as the Black.
So I bought an Ortofon 2m Red. Got my attention right away, big bass, big high end, ok mids, super high output compared to the Grado. I thought this is great, but after a few months of listening I found it edgy, had a real CD/digital quality to it I did not like for long periods of listening. I found myself turning it down. This tells me its not a good fit if you're looking for the warmth and detail of analog, and something to bring vinyl to life.
Anyway no problem selling it to a young guy getting into vinyl, without intending to sound like an ass I figure he has been raised in a digital world and I am sure the punch and output of the 2M Red appeals to him and the style of music he listens to, that's all that matters.
Found myself sitting in limbo cartridge wise, like a man with no country I drifted around trying whatever came along. Nagaoka MP20, Shure V15 iii, etc.
Was finally convinced to try Grado again, but this time stepped up to the Blue, guy I bought it from said better deal than the Silver! Anyway got it set up and so far think its fabulous. Detailed, restrained in the right way, punchy and lively. Mids just sort of bloom in front of you. For the same price point as the 2M Red, far better cartridge. The lack of colouration is ultimately its greatest appeal and its not even broken in yet. At 120.00 the Blue is an Epic deal. I like it as much as the Nagaoka but at a fraction of the cost.
Cheers
My 2 cents worth.