• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Low Efficiency Vs. High Efficiency Speakers

strat10

Well-Known Member
I have 150 watt per channel receiver. What are the benefits and disadvantages to using low efficiency or high efficiency speakers? I would appreciate it if someone could explain the benefits and disadvantages of each.

Also, when a receiver has been sitting for 20 years without use what is the advantage of starting the receiver slowly with a variac as opposed to just turning it on and using it? Thanks for all your help.
 
Register to hide this ad
low effieciency is easy to listen to.

high efficiency peels your paint.

very high efficiency, you gotta open windows to use as bass ports or you risk blowing out your windows.:D
 
I've always preferred 90-96db speakers. Seem to provide a wide variety of amplifier sources. If your amp is ss, I wouldn't variac. Tube I would.
 
High efficiency is great for using little single ended tube amps. Also good for situations where you need to fill a huge room with music, but getting 400 watts is not feasable.

Everything else being equal, a high effeciency speaker will be costlier to build than a low effeciency speaker that sounds the same with twice as much power. Or it will be a whole lot bigger.

As someone once said, you can have a speaker that is efficient, small, or has low bass extension, but not all three. Its all a matter of trade-offs.


Starting an amp up with a variac allows the caps to reform. It also (as an added bonus) isolates the amp from the line. It's probably good for more things too, but someone else will have to tell you those.
 
low eff.=more power for given spl
hi eff.= less power for given spl
after 20 yrs slow turnon ok for not frying unit if something has gone bye bye. but if ya aint gotta a variac just use the power on switch.
 
Choose any two (and two only) of the following:

1) Extended bass response

2) Small (rational) box size

3) High efficiency

*****

Bringing a dormant amp up to voltage gradually will reform the electrolytic power supply filter capacitors, if they are not too deteriorated from disuse. 24 hours is not an unreasonable time period over which to accomplish this, in small voltage increments, like 5 VAC at a time, beginning at 60 VAC. On tube gear, be sure to put dummy loads on the outputs....
 
As someone once said, you can have a speaker that is efficient, small, or has low bass extension, but not all three. Its all a matter of trade-offs.

That would be Anthony Hoffman (the H in KLH) and it's called Hoffman's Iron Law. You can get 2 of the 3. So with high efficiency speakers you can either have low bass or small size but not both. Most folks go for the bass so high efficiency speakers tend to be big. Look around here for a pic of Powerman's speakers.

If you want to go low and have a small size then you have to give up effiiciency to get it. Since watts are cheap these days this is where most folks go. You will have to deal with power compression and distortion at higher levels but these are addressed in many newer drivers with advanced motor designs. They still won't do what a big, high efficiency speaker will do, but they fit in the house.

It all depends on what you've got to work with (room size, WAF, etc) and what you want to get out of it (concert level sound vs moderate relaxed listening, etc).

Ray
 
Thanks for all the replies. The reason I was asking about the variac is because I purchased an amp that hadn't been played and I didn't use one. I didn't actually know about using one until coming here. It plays great and sounds great, but I was wondering by not using a variac are my capacitors not fully formed now?

As far as my speaker questions, I used a friends Pioneer HPM-60's and really loved the sound. My amp is a Toshiba SA 7150 and I have a chance of buying some Polk Audio RT10's for $50.00. How well would these speakers pair with my receiver. Also, how do they compare to HPM-60's? Thanks again.
 
I'm copying this from the klipsch site and he in turn, copied it from "Romy the Cat" ( :scratch2: )

http://forums.klipsch.com/forums/t/109002.aspx

Got this from "The Good Sound Club" website by some guy who calls himseld Romy the Cat



"Some of the initial inspiration wrt. distortion in speakers came from reading articles and JASA papers by Paul Klipsch, who also always insisted that distortion in speakers generally is inversely proportional to efficiency. As my own studies progressed, however, I've come to view Klipsch's explanations for this to be somewhat simplistic. Or, rather that he could have argued more convincingly by pointing at the fact that something like a dozen significant nonlinear factors are "forcibly" linearized in high efficiency small excursion designs. The cumulative effect of simultaneously reducing nearly all these dynamic nonlinearities in a fell swoop makes for a perceptible improvement in clarity, articulation, dynamics, effortlessness etc. Klipsch, however, tended to emphasize reduced intermodulation distortion in horns which is ONLY due to reduced diaphragm velocity. This distortion mechanism exists independently of nonlinear parameters in the driver itself, as this generation of nonharmonic sidebands is due to the doppler effect and is proportional to the product of peak diaphragm velocity and bandwidth. It is therefore not related to efficiency or driver nonlinearity as such. Neither does it explain the improved dynamics and other advantages of high efficiency speaker design"
 
My impression is that class AB amps (which most vintage amps and recievers are) operate in A at very low power levels (relative to its rated output), and go into B at higher levels. So even if you don't listen to music at high levels a high power amp may be helpful because it will have a higher point at which it switches to B. And similarly a very efficient speaker may allow your amp to stay in A more of the time.
My own feeling is that high efficiency speakers tend to have better small scale dynamics (large scale dynamics can be achieved though high power), but they tend to be more colored (because its much easy to achieve uniform response by cutting peaks than it is to boost troughs, but cutting peaks lowers efficiency). So its a matter of what aspects of music matter most to you.
 
Back
Top Bottom