• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

MC60's vs. MC250 - a valid test?

kelsa

Active Member
I've had a pair of MC60's that were brought up to spec by Terry Dewick along with my C27 preamp. Recently bought a MC250 to use during the hot summer months and as a second system amp. I connected the left channel to one of the MC60's and the right channel to one of the MC250's channels. Adjusted the MC60 gain to match the lower gain of the MC250. Once the volume was similar between the right and left channels I was surprised that I could not hear a difference. Maybe the MC250 had a bit tighter bass but the highs and mids were identical. Listened to several old jazz cd's, new jazz (Diana Krall) vocals, others as well. Speakers are Klipsch Cornwalls, cd player is Sony X33ES. I realize that by only listening to one side, both with the preamp switched to stereo and also to mono, I am missing any sounstage differences, etc and other attributes that audiophiles discuss.

Any thoughts on this? Is this a valid method to use to test differences?
 
Register to hide this ad
I bought my MC250 new and used it as my main amp until I subbed a MC2105 in a few years ago. I have always maintained that 1) is is the best 50/channel watt amp ever made and 2) it could be the most under noticed of the Mc amps and that is 1 of the biggest errors of all times. The 2100/2105 has a bit tighter bass but is a shade darker and has slightly less resolving power and delicacy.

Frank held off offereing ss amps until he got the voicing to = that of the tubes as did some others but he came closer than others in succeeding. Sadly, in my opinion, with each succeeding gen, Mc moved away from that level of attention and that was not such a good move. Welcome to the 250 club.
 
Roger Russell told me, when I had an MC225 and an MC7150, that tubes and solid states Mc Intosh amplifiers should sound the same.
Can we consider your experience as a confirmation of what he said ...

JérômeB
www.ls3-5a-forum.com
 
The later production MC250 can make spec at 75W with ease, yes this is a good comparison between a 60 and a 250, IMHO a very valid comparison.
 
The comments on the bass don't surprise me, but I would have thought you would hear some more "air" in the mids with the MC60.
 
Brian said:
I have always maintained that 1) is is the best 50/channel watt amp ever made and 2) it could be the most under noticed of the Mc amps and that is 1 of the biggest errors of all times.
I agree with one small exception, don't forget the MC50s. My local McIntosh dealer has 4 MC50s in stock and I took home all 4 to demo and they made some beautiful music. Unfortunately they had what I would call excessive transformer noise so I passed on them.
The first generation McIntosh SS amps have always impressed me big time, enjoy your MC250. :)

Victor
 
I've owned just about all of the Mac tube amps from the 50W2 to the MC275 and my conclusion is that the older solid state amps sound pretty much the same as the tube amps but with tighter bass and maybe a little more resolution. This means to me that most Mac amps old or new are pretty nuetral devices. People always want to believe that the tube amps are better but if you listen objectively you will find that this is not always the case. I do like Mac tube gear though.

Mike
 
Back
Top Bottom