• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Modern integrated for Thiel CS2?

ashok

Active Member
Hi all,

I am considering a pair of Thiel CS2s for a 2 channel system in my family room. From what I have read, Thiels can be hard to drive, although the CS2 seem to have rather benign characteristics:
  • 87dB sensitivity
  • Minimum impedance dipping to 6Ω
  • Phase angle: ±10° which means the impedance is mostly resistive
Given the above, I am looking for suggestions for an integrated amplifier priced at about $500 ± $100, and am considering:
  • NAD D3020 - about 30W per channel, perhaps a good bit more given NAD's habit of stating their specifications conservatively
  • Marantz PM 6004 - 45 to 60W per channel
  • HK 3490 - 120W per channel. Not strictly an integrated, but has good reviews.
If you have any first hand experience with the CS2s and would care to make a suggestion, I would very much appreciate it.

The Thiels are local to me, and the price seems to be a bargain - hence my interest.

Thanks!!
 
Register to hide this ad
I ve heard Thiel and very nice choice. But I heard them driven with Pass Lab. The CS2's have a very good bottom and are very neutral. They will sound good with neutral to bright leaning amp...I would stay away from a warmer sounding amp unless you like that sound. The Pass Amp was more neutral.

They don't exaggerate anything. But they do like good clean power. Theils are very detailed and musical. You should chose your amp very carefully. Those are some very good speakers in my opinion. In your price range, I would go used, as to get more of what you need for them to get the best out of them.
 
Thanks for the response. I like neutral to slightly warmish, and musical is always good. I will look into buying used. This high-power thing is new for me having been a tubes/single-driver enthusiast for a long time.
 
When I was first exposed to high end audio, Thiel was the brand I was most connected to upon visiting most of the shops around Dallas. The 3.5, while not cheap, was what I considered to be the first good step over the Vandersteen 2 whatevers were current at the time (1988-1989). I am an acoustic musician and I'm pretty picky about how acoustic instruments are reproduced, esp in minimalist settings; solo cello, violin and trios and quartets for example.

I've long been a fan of Thiel speakers starting with that 3.5 and eventually the 2.2, 3.6 and 5. I always especially liked the 2.2s as I tend to think that speakers with a bit less bottom end are easier to work with in terms of placement and room treatment.

I don't know that I've ever heard the CS2 specifically but I've always thought of them as slightly to the bright side of neutral which I tend to like and I would definitely call it a 'bright without being harsh' rather than a 'too bright' or 'fatiguing' balance. I personally wouldn't recommend a neutral to bright amp, I'd recommend a neutral to warm amp.

Having said that, if you tend to prefer a warmer sound... I'd keep my options open.
 
I've heard the complaint about Thiel speakers quite a bit. There is a dealer that I used to work with that used to caution that Thiel speakers could be bright to some.

The first time I listened to Thiel speakers over an extended session was with some heavyweight Bryston power amps and an Audible Illusions pre amp. Sounded pretty damn good to my ears.

I have a neighbor with a nice new set of 2.4SE I believe and he is running his with all Ayre electronics and Nordost cables...nice.
 
Guys, rooms, cables, source, amp, mood, music taste... all this can affect our judgement to know if it sounds bright.

The real question is, are those bright ? ;)
 
I used to have Thiel CS2.2's and fed them with a Parasound Halo A21 Amp and P3 preamp. That combo was a bit too bright for my liking.
Fast forward a few years and I am now running Thiel CS3.7's being fed by either a McIntosh MC402 amp or Bob Latino M125 mono's.
The preamp is an Audio Research SP16. I have found audio bliss with this setup and I believe that the CS2.2's would have performed admirably as well with the same equipment.
My advice would be to throw those Thiels as much power as you can, and use a warmer rather than leaner amp. If you want an integrated, I'd look at something like a tube integrated from the likes of Cary, Rogue, or McIntosh.
My preference is seperates with a SS amp and a tube pre, but that's me.

Al. Wise
 
Last edited:
Always loved those Thiel 2.2s. Funny thing is, the shop I initially listened to them at had all their gear running with Parasound gear as they'd just picked up both lines. They also carried McCormack which, while not 'warm' were a better match in my opinion. The store owner just felt that they (McCormack) just generally lacked the beef that the Parasound HCAs had.

A member of the family runs 3.7s... in a system that mostly sees home theater use. :no:

They sound great but he uses some kind of multi zone amp that probably puts out about 60 watts. He's been asking my opinions on high-ish end gear for about 20 years but never goes with the ancillary gear as he wants to keep everything similar brands in terms of electronics. I pointed out that the Thiels would probably sound 50% better if he kept all the other stuff on the zoned amps and bought a nice 2-channel amp just for the fronts.

Having said that, they enjoy them almost every day so that's good. I just can't imagine having a little dinky amp driving $7,000 speakers or whatever they sell for these days.
 
My research and the comments on this thread indicate that the speakers thrive on being fed lots of clean power. In my opinion, the best way to achieve this would be with a tube preamp and a solid-state amplifier. That would definitely be out-of-budget. So, I have decided not to pursue the Thiels.

Thanks for your advice, every one. My apologies if this seems like a wasted effort, but I hope you all had fun discussing your experiences.

If any of the Boston, MA AK'ers are interested, you can find the sale on Audiogon.
 
No wasted effort at all man!

Havingbsaid that, I personally think you don't 'need' a tube preamp. I've heard a variety of Thiel models at four or five shops and in two homes and in think only one had an AR preamp. The rest well e all solid state pre and pro. And I think with the 2s, you'd be pretty good with 150 quality watts. I just think that a 50 or 100 ward receiver would be pushing it... if you'll pardon the pun.

For the right price, I think the 2s might make a great option, esp if you value well-recorded acoustic instruments. I just wouldn't seek out the brightest, most detailed pre/pro.

To get your started, you could get the Thiels and something like an Acurus A150, A200 or A250 and use (gulp) any receiver with pre outs then when funds afforded, get a better preamp. Though Thiels tend to be pretty revealing, I have no doubt that would make a great-sounding rig for several years if needed. I hgsd a pretty nice system through university, but when I started upgrading, we couldn't do it all at once. For well over a year, I had a pair of Apogee ribbon hybrids ($1,600 or $1,800) and McCormack DNA0.5 power amp ($1,200 at discount) and a lowly JVC receiver and CD player.
 
Last edited:
You know, what about something like a B&K EX-442, or ST-202? Great power, warm but detailed, and relatively inexpensive? Of course they're pushing 25 years old, and are just power amps.
 
I got a fabulous deal at an estate sale on a pair of Thiel 2 2s - $225 for the pair, and the drivers all work. I would never have been able to afford these speakers under ordinary circumstances, but I know their worth and would like to take a run at setting them up. However, I can't afford to go out and get (for instance) a dedicated pre- and power-amp, both of sufficient quality for these.

At the same time, I know I need to bring in a good quality integrated amplifier and DAC, and that's where I'm curious. I can think of three main approaches:

- One option - which most folks don't think is a good one - would be the Marantz PM6005. That gets me a reasonable amount of power and an optical input in the box, at $700.

- A second option would be to look at the Teac components like the AI-501DA which can be found for $850 or so. I don't know anything about that little box, and it seems very new.

- A third is to bring in a traditional integrated amp first, and the DAC later on. In this case, I'd be looking for a good relatively warm used integrated amp for not too much dough.

What I've been reading up until now has led me to look hardest at used Arcam and Rotel amplifiers - things like the Arcam alpha 9 and the Rotel 1062.

In brand new amplifiers, I'm hearing recommendations that I look at the Arcam 19 and Riga Brio to keep under a 1k price point - but I'm hearing at least one shop say they don't think I'd be satisfied with either of those amps.

I'm interested in suggestions for amps, new or used, that have the power and the sonic contour that might help drive the low range on the Thiels better than the gear I'm considering.

If anyone has specific experience using the Marantz or the Teac in addition to other amplifiers with low impedance speakers I'd be interested in hearing about it.

thanks in advance!

-------------

Here is why I'm saying warm, by the way: got the thiels home, and am surprised at how little bass I'm hearing from them in comparison with a pair of Mission 731s I have. In exactly the same setup, the Thiels just aren't producing as much low end as the Missions. I'm feeding both pair from a Yamaha RX 595 through 14 guage cables with banana plugs at the receiver and rings at the speaker posts.

It's obviously not the right amp for the 2 2s, but I think it means that for my room and musical taste, I'll want a warmer rather than a neutral or brighter receiver.
 
I always have to suggest the Krell S-300i. Plenty of power, very neutral and none of the complaints about earlier Krell int. amps sounding sterile or two dimensional. The S-300i is being discounted by Music Direct.
 
Even at 1800, the Krell is close to twice what I was thinking about at the north end.

Have you heard it specifically with the Thiels, or is it mostly a very good price on a very good amp?
 
Having owned Thiel 2's I recommend using a stout amplifier. The Krell would be a good option, maybe a larger B&K, or the like. If underpowered - and I did underpower them at one point - they do sound bright. Even though they are only rated to 6 ohms I suspect they go lower. Just my opinion as a former owner of the model.
 
I'll be able to hear a B&K ST-1400 drive these in the next few days.

Once I started paying attention to integrated amps versus power amps, I realized that most integrateds in my price range are marginal, and that the B&K power amp may be a good fit.

The silence on the Arcam and Rotel options for feeding these was pretty deafening, and the ST-1400 is priced such that if, after hearing it, I want to upgrade I won't be in as far over my head as I would be with many other choices.
 
Even at 1800, the Krell is close to twice what I was thinking about at the north end.

Have you heard it specifically with the Thiels, or is it mostly a very good price on a very good amp?



When I shopped for Thiel's the shop was using Spectral Electronics. I have never heard the Thiel's and Krell together. I have used the Krell with Monitor Audio RS6's that have a rep for brightness. The neutral sound of the amp does not increase any high frequency peaks of the metal dome tweeter. I also own Focal 806's, JBL Synthesis Studio 530's and Mobile Fidelity OML 1's. The amp adds little if any sonic character to the sound and it is easy to hear the differences in source and speakers. The power and current really take control of the woofers and deliver great bass.
 
This may well not be the final configuration, but after deciding on going with a very low cost approach (nad 1000 and B&K st1400) I stopped into a used gear shop and explained my conundrum - very nice speakers I couldn't afford to feed but wanted to hear.

I went home with nad 1600 pre / nad 2400 power amp, with the understanding that I'm also trialing the B&K amp and may be returning the 2400.

The difference is night and day even with this gear. The Thiels now outpace the Missions, especially on complex classical pieces and midrange and high end articulation. The room no longer sounds overbright, despite the fact that it's an old stucco walled house with relatively little on the walls and a hardwood floor.

I must say that to all three of us in the house (the geezer, my partner and her teenager) the Missions did a very credible job with what they had. Which may mean the Thiels need some work or may mean that we're none of us experienced/acclimated enough to spot the problems especially in comparison to what went before.

Well, okay, I'll admit that I think the speakers could be doing a better job of creating a coherent soundstage - my memory is that that's well within range for speakers of this calibre.

When they're brand new.

In high end audio shops.

Being connected to multi-k electronics.

Which is also either very new or wonderfully maintained.

In rooms with very carefully arranged wall absorbency.

That no one lives in with their dogs, kids, bikes, etc.

For us, the whole package sounds great, and unbelievable on a sub 800 dollar budget.

Thanks to all for input.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom