• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

New Tubes vs Old Tubes

Khodabear

Super Member
I've been away from all this for some time. When I was still into it - early 90's - New and NOS tubes were easily obtained and reasonably priced.
Today I see NOS still around but quite spendy.
I see people buying equipment solely for the value of the used tubes.
I also see new tube lines such as Electro Harmonix available at reasonable prices.

So I ask those who've been running the ship all these years - how do the new tubes compare to NOS and Used? I understand that it's about the circuit and I get tube rolling and all...but the question is really just about baseline quality and performance.

I read that the Russian tubes are decent and getting better. That a lot of the Chinese tubes are pretty good.
But like Packard said..."Ask the Man who Owns One" :~)
 
Register to hide this ad
I think you are going to have to narrow down your question a bit to get an answer more detailed than "It Depends". What tubes are you specifically questioning?

I think some of the new production tubes are good, but not as good as old stock in general. But that does not really help you decide between a 1950's NOS tube for $60.00 and a new reissue for $15.00.
 
Good point
My needs run in the area of 12AX7 12AU7 6L6 6V6 5881 6973 - which is what led me to E.H..
Mundane items such as that.
 
Some of the comments I've seen are that if your gear runs the tubes pretty hard you may be better served with NOS, or be prepared to weed out a few of the new ones. YMMV.
 
I tried a lot of new 12ax7 tubes and the best I've found so far are the Genalex Gold Lion reissues. They cost a little more but I think they're worth it. I use six of them in my Fisher X-100-C and it really sounds good. In my Fisher 500C and use Telefunken smooth plates and original Mullards and I really don't know if any of the new production 12ax7 tubes can compare. With that said, IMO the Gold Lion reissues do sound damn good.
 
My needs run in the area of 12AX7 12AU7 6L6 6V6 5881 6973 - which is what led me to E.H..

I didn't like EH 12AX7 & 12AT7's, they were better than the stock Shuguangs in my amp, but not a lot. Many here like the Sovtek 12AX7LPS. I've heard good feedback regarding Mullard 12AX7 reissue.

Psvane 12AT7's are really nice, but are just as spendy as NOS. Haven't heard their 12AU7.

Some people like JJ's for small signal tubes, and others don't?

Russian 6P3S-E's are "the" tube for 5881/6l6GB and in some cases, an EL34 sub.

Lots of options.

jeff
 
FWIW, I've never heard a chinese tube that I would buy (even the ones in fancy packaging and white gloves).:D When I get something in with a chinese tube in it, the tube goes straight into the trash. Russian military, and Sovteks that I've tried have all been very good IMO, especially stuff from the old Reflektor plant. I also like most Japanese (old stock but affordable) tubes I've used. Matsushita and Awai are a couple examples. For awhile the Japanese had the old Mullard tooling. You can tell those tubes by the seem tops, or so I've been told.:yes:
 
Good point
My needs run in the area of 12AX7 12AU7 6L6 6V6 5881 6973 - which is what led me to E.H..
Mundane items such as that.

The small signal tubes such as 12AX7 and 12AU7, along with 6V6, are still as cheap or cheaper to buy used NOS (I hate that term, because, well, nevermind) than the premium new manufacture tubes, and are better in my experience. Used 12AU7 are dirt cheap, I bet I acquired a pair or quad of almost every manufacturer for under $100 total!

I seen a quad of good tested RCA sell today for $27 on that auction site. You cant even buy the cheapest Chinese manufacture for that cheap.

I have tried some of the new manufacture 12AX7, such as SovtekWA, SovtekWB, Chinese multiple generations, EH, reissue Tungsol (pains me to even type, as the orginals are such WONDERFUL tubes). In multiple pieces of MY gear, none of these compare to any (and I have listened to nearly all of them) NOS tubes, even the cheaper ones such as RCA, Sylvania, GE. And not even in the same universe with the really good stuff such as Telefunkens, Brimars, Mullard long plate, real Tungsols.

The 6V6GT you can still get very reasonable (<$10 tube), except for the crem de la creme RCA smoked glass (best there is IMO, and worth seeking out). I have not heard many/any bad 6v6GT tubes. The russian close equivalent 6P6S sound decent and are dirt cheap.
 
Most of my experience with newer tubes is in guitar gear.

I tried some Chinese 12AX7s under the "TJ Full Music" brand a while back and I thought they sounded outstanding. In guitar amps, they sounded better than any other tube I'd ever tried, and by a wide margin. (I've tried most of 'em... Telefunken, Mullard, GE, RCA, etc....) They are reported to sound that good in hi-fi gear as well, but my testing of them in a stereo was very limited. Grant Fidelity used to carry them, I don't think they do any longer. They were as expensive as used Teles, or NOS domestic tubes.

For 6L6 types in Fender amps, the Russian "winged C" tubes are the best of the new stuff, but they still leave me cold. There's nothing close to an RCA blackplate in a Fender. Nothing.

I do run Russian EL84 equivalents in a Dynaco SCA-35 and they are just fine. I can't tell a difference from whatever the original tubes were, and they seem to hold up OK.

A friend had a pair of Russian EL34s in a Marshall combo and they shorted after a year or two of moderate use. Not impressive. Sounded OK, though.
 
I read a review on a Dynalab Hybred tuner with Amperex 6922 NOS tubes. Someone suggested that the old tubes had lost their vacume, and he would get better sound out of these new ones. Nice try, the NOS Amperex killed the new ones in SQ.
 
I've had mixed luck with new issue tubes. I've had some lightly used ones just quit, some with bad results. Others just sounded like crap. New KT66's sound nicer than many 6L6GC's but the original Genalex KT66 sound smoother/better to me. Many of the 12AX7's sound good and are very reliable.
I stay away from the new production power tubes. Don't think the quality is there with many of them.
 
Back
Top Bottom