• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Oh the Joy

JJ -- To clarify what I think is some apparent confusion, some basics might be in order here.

The Control Grid is also called Grid #1, and is always the closest grid to the cathode. As the first grid to be discovered/developed, its name comes from what it does: It controls the current flow through the tube at any given time, from cut-off (no current flow), to the maximum possible current flow that the tube and/or circuit will allow.

Proceeding towards the plate, the next grid is the Screen Grid which is also called Grid #2 (conveniently), because it was the second grid to be developed as the vacuum tube was maturing. While it too can ultimately control current flow through the tube, it is much more non-linear in action, and is therefore primarily used to establish the maximum current that will be allowed to flow through the tube at any given time, from zero, up to potentially the limitations of the tube itself. While the Control Grid can be thought of as a simple throttle, the Screen Grid could be thought of as a governor.

Absolute current flow in nature is always from negative to positive. Therefore, current flow through a tube is always from the cathode to other more positively charged elements -- namely, the screen grid, and the plate. The circuit path of energy through a tube tube then is from the cathode to the screen grid, and from the cathode to the plate, with the cathode current representing the sum of the individual screen and plate currents.

While there is never any current flow interaction between the screen and the plate, in early multigrid tubes called tetrodes (a cathode, only two grids, and a plate), there was an undesirable interaction between the two elements, when electrons that bombarded the plate so hard that they dislodged other electrons (called secondary emission), ultimately found their way to the screen grid rather than back to the plate -- and when the plate voltage dropped well below the screen voltage. This gave rise to the famous "kink" in the plate curves of tetrodes, that prevented these tubes from reaching their full potential.

Enter the third grid (or beam forming element in beam power tubes), placed between the Screen Grid and the Plate, called the Suppressor Grid or grid #3, because it was the third grid element to be developed. With it typically operated at the same potential as the cathode, it therefore conducts no current of its own, but acts as a channel to suppress the flow of any potential secondary emission from the plate to the screen, by causing the any dislodged electrons from the plate to ultimately go back to the plate. This neat little element then eliminated the kink in the plate curve, creating a huge increase in efficiency, and gave rise to the famous British line of power pentodes which were all identified with a "KT"xx, the KT standing for Kinkless Tetrodes. In the US, the 6L6 was the first ever Beam Power Tube.

With these understandings then, it will be seen that the only element that can source power in a vacuum tube is the cathode. The screen and plate can only sink power -- hence, besides their voltage rating, they are also rated in terms of dissipation, based on how much power they can sink. On the other hand, because the cathode can only source power, it is rated only in terms of maximum current flow -- both under continuous, and peak conditions.

I hope this helps!

Dave
 
It helps. I previously understood most of that, but a refresher is always good and new perspective is certainly greatly appreciated. I also add, you've a knack for explaining things very clearly.

I'd like to continue the discussion, but I've some guests over and I need to digest some text. Hope to get back this thread later tonight or sometime tomorrow.
 
Dave,
( and JJ )
THANK YOU that cleared up some muck stuck between my ears....
And put facts instead of voodoo.. in my brain.. which helped me solve a current ( no pun intended ) problem I was having on one of my rebuilds....
THANKS!

Mike
 
Er ... <knock knock> ... anybody home?

I was just starting to enjoy this!

I take it the "physical properties of tube design" discussion went elsewhere, which should, theoretically, make this thread once again an evaluation of the KT150? Maybe one last gasp and add a link if that's the case?

Back to the KT150's ... sort of.

I recently got a virgin set of KT120's for a Latino ST120 and would be interested in knowing how the KT150's would compare in a head to head in either this or a similar KT88 capable design. Not looking for more power, just interested in adding to the stable when it comes to sonics. It's also a longevity thing, as the tubes won't be worked all that hard without a full circuit refab ... I do know that Mr Bob has tested the KT120's extensively in the ST120 amp. Plenty of reserve capacity to drive them properly, with very nice results. Pretty sure he mentioned seeing about a 10% increase in power, but don't quote me on that. He drove them up to 75ma bias, but backed down to the "stock" 55ma of the amp as there was no appreciable change in output or improvement in sonics past that point. Haven't heard anything specific yet about the KT150 in that amp.

As for the red plating, be interested to hear from others who've got the consumer version that's now available. Hopefully, that was just a pre-production blip ...
 
I had guests in town for a week, and then life took priority. I still have the intention of continuing the conversation, but I've some reading to do on the subject that takes more focus and time than I have available at the moment.
 
Er ... <knock knock> ... anybody home?

I was just starting to enjoy this!

I take it the "physical properties of tube design" discussion went elsewhere, which should, theoretically, make this thread once again an evaluation of the KT150? Maybe one last gasp and add a link if that's the case?

Back to the KT150's ... sort of.

I recently got a virgin set of KT120's for a Latino ST120 and would be interested in knowing how the KT150's would compare in a head to head in either this or a similar KT88 capable design. Not looking for more power, just interested in adding to the stable when it comes to sonics. It's also a longevity thing, as the tubes won't be worked all that hard without a full circuit refab ... I do know that Mr Bob has tested the KT120's extensively in the ST120 amp. Plenty of reserve capacity to drive them properly, with very nice results. Pretty sure he mentioned seeing about a 10% increase in power, but don't quote me on that. He drove them up to 75ma bias, but backed down to the "stock" 55ma of the amp as there was no appreciable change in output or improvement in sonics past that point. Haven't heard anything specific yet about the KT150 in that amp.

As for the red plating, be interested to hear from others who've got the consumer version that's now available. Hopefully, that was just a pre-production blip ...


Do carry on, please carry on despite that this thread, and for that matter
the KT150 may have been tainted by a small trace of Korean plutonium.
 
I can carry on with the best of them ... <G>

Some interesting stuff here though. Never got much past the basics, as it wasn't really a necessity. Still isn't, but being retired, I find I have all kinds of time to kill.

:lurk:
 
I can carry on with the best of them ... <G>

Some interesting stuff here though. Never got much past the basics, as it wasn't really a necessity. Still isn't, but being retired, I find I have all kinds of time to kill.

:lurk:

You said it Brother…..
 
If anyone including Craig,
wants any of this info moved to a new thread I will do my best to do so.

No need to move, lock or anything. If these gents want to go at it over something this simple they can have at it. I'm just glad somehow I lost my subscription to this thread :banana:

Dave great comments. I'm glad you have the time for this shite! I surely don't.
 
Good morning Craig , as It looks like you have another month racked up on your KT-150's I for one would appreciate any further consideration in this regard.

I was most interested to read your earlier comment ~

" Electrically they seem to work fine. I really question the raised heater voltage specification since it does not cause a bit of voltage drop on my heater circuit. The KT-120 didn't either... "

For my part I am running an ARC Ref 150 / KT-120 amplifier and It is my understanding that ARC are currently evaluating the KT-150 ( no doubt with an eye toward future models) as an user option in current model production in place of the KT-120.

Whilst we await the official Word from ARC , early rumour would seem to indicate that the Ref 75 /4 x KT-120 may receive sanction however this may not prove to be the case for the Ref 150 sporting 8 x KT-120's !

One could speculate that the Mains transformer / Capacitor tank of the Ref 75 may have a little more head room left available , whereas the Ref 150 may not :scratch2:

Which brings me back to your earlier findings in regard to actual live circuit readings which I am hoping might indicate that there may yet prove to be enough head room left in the Ref 150 for ARC central to green light the option , especially when considering that the output tubes in the ARC Ref 150 circuit appear to be run somewhat conservatively.

Jasper.
 
Last edited:
I think your best bet is to wait and see what ARC has to say. They know more about your amp then I do. I'm testing them for use in my amplifiers. They work great and sound great.

In the grand scheme of things I think they will be a poor value compared to the KT120's. Kind of a overkill type thing when used in the KT-88 type amplifier. They seem to me to sound and work identical to the KT120's in every way.

As far as my finding in respect to red plating having to do with early production versions....I'm not buying that for a minute. When it comes right down to it they have been building the guts of this tube for many years since the internals are identcal to the Tung-Sol reissue 6550 and KT-120. If they want to solve the red plating they will have to redesign the plate stucture and I'll be shocked if they do that.

Red Plating....like Dave G. previously mentioned many tubes of yesteryear have displayed red plating at maximum plate dissipation without reliability issues.. The MOV KT-88 and KT-66 both do it. But were talking at or near maximum not 30% below. I can't imagine how low one would have to bias these tubes to run them at 850V on the plates... 300 watts of power ...at 50% distortion would be my guess!

New Senser is a marketing company and they have proven the tactics they will use to maximize profits....believing them would be similar to believing a sleezy used car salesmen ;)

The Tong-sols are not remotely like the original Tong-sols
The Mullards are not remotely like the original Mullards
The Gold Lions are not remotely like the original Gold Lions

These new KT-120 and KT-150 are nice tubes but nothing remotely as fantastic as the bogus spec sheets would lead one to believe.

This is my opinion and I'm sticking to it. I have no coin in this game I do not sell tubes.
 
I think your best bet is to wait and see what ARC has to say. They know more about your amp then I do. I'm testing them for use in my amplifiers. They work great and sound great.

In the grand scheme of things I think they will be a poor value compared to the KT120's. Kind of a overkill type thing when used in the KT-88 type amplifier. They seem to me to sound and work identical to the KT120's in every way.

As far as my finding in respect to red plating having to do with early production versions....I'm not buying that for a minute. When it comes right down to it they have been building the guts of this tube for many years since the internals are identcal to the Tung-Sol reissue 6550 and KT-120. If they want to solve the red plating they will have to redesign the plate structure and I'll be shocked if they do that.

Red Plating....like Dave G. previously mentioned many tubes of yesteryear have displayed red plating at maximum plate dissipation without reliability issues.. The MOV KT-88 and KT-66 both do it. But were talking at or near maximum not 30% below. I can't imagine how low one would have to bias these tubes to run them at 850V on the plates... 300 watts of power ...at 50% distortion would be my guess!

New Senser is a marketing company and they have proven the tactics they will use to maximize profits....believing them would be similar to believing a sleezy used car salesmen ;)

The Tong-sols are not remotely like the original Tong-sols
The Mullards are not remotely like the original Mullards
The Gold Lions are not remotely like the original Gold Lions

These new KT-120 and KT-150 are nice tubes but nothing remotely as fantastic as the bogus spec sheets would lead one to believe.

This is my opinion and I'm sticking to it. I have no coin in this game I do not sell tubes.

Hmmmm---.
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • Very_Interesting.jpg
    Very_Interesting.jpg
    33.4 KB · Views: 136
Back
Top Bottom